“Where am I?”
The question floats in my mind before I’m fully awake, like a whisper caught between waves. Everything is sore. My skin burns with salt and sand, my throat raw from choking on something too dry, too sharp. I blink against the light, but the world above me spins, smudged with gray clouds and dying thunder. The storm is leaving, but it’s taken something with it.
I’m lying on a beach, that much I can tell. My fingers sink into wet sand, trembling. My lungs rattle in my chest—tight, unfamiliar. My body is… wrong. Heavy, slow, like it’s been rewired overnight. I reach instinctively for my neck, for something I know should be there. Gills. But all I find is smooth skin. Human skin. My breath catches, my chest tightening. I’m not supposed to be like this.
I try to sit up, but my muscles won’t cooperate. My legs are numb, long, pale things that feel like they belong to someone else. I stare at them, confused. Two legs. Not a tail. My body is draped in seaweed, tangled and cold, barely covering anything. My top is ripped and soaked, clinging in all the wrong places, pulling tight over the curves I was always told were too much. I tug the seaweed off with shaking fingers, trying to hide, but it doesn’t matter. I feel exposed, like the tide spat me out just to be laughed at again.
I don’t know my name. I don’t remember who I was. Not really. But I remember the word.
“Pufferfish.”
It slaps through my skull like a slap across the face. That word, sharp and sing-song, spat out with fake smiles and glittery laughter. Faces blur in my mind—perfect, slim, shining girls with tails like silk ribbons. They moved like poetry. I was never like them. I was the punchline. The background. The joke.
Pufferfish.
Too fat. Too slow. Too clumsy.
“Why don’t you float away, Pufferfish?”
“Try not to get stuck in the coral again.”
Their laughter was always louder underwater. Louder and colder.
Even in whatever world I came from, I was an outsider. Always too big. Always in the way. I remember their eyes—wide and pitying when they weren’t laughing. Like they couldn’t figure out what I was even doing there. I wasn’t graceful. I wasn’t delicate. I didn’t glide. I bobbed. I bumped into things. I covered up, I sucked in, I tried to take up less space, but it never worked.
They made sure I never forgot.
The word won’t leave me alone.
Pufferfish.
That’s all I am now. A washed-up, nameless lump on a beach, covered in kelp and shame.
I heard footsteps crunch nearby. I panic, trying to curl into myself, but everything aches. I can’t move fast enough.
“Hey!” a girl’s voice calls out, surprised and gentle. “Oh my god—are you okay?”
She kneels beside me. I blink up at her, dazed. She looks like she stepped out of a beach ad—freckled shoulders, sun-streaked curls tied back in a scarf, white linen romper spotless and flowing. Her skin glows with health, her frame all long limbs and confidence. She doesn’t look like someone who’s ever been called names. She doesn’t look like someone who’s ever felt wrong.
She looks at me with wide green eyes, not recoiling at the mess I must be.
“What’s your name?” she asks.
I open my mouth, but it stays empty. My voice shrivels up before I can speak. I shake my head.
“That’s okay,” she says softly. “I’m Bryn.”
She shrugs off a big hoodie from around her waist and wraps it around me without hesitation. It swallows me whole. For a moment, I just sit there, clinging to the fabric like it’s the only thing keeping me from falling apart.
She doesn’t ask what happened. Doesn’t push. Just stays beside me like I’m worth the space I take up.
I hate that.
I hate how kind she is.
Because the part of me that remembers—really remembers—knows I’m not supposed to be treated this way. Kindness feels like a lie. Like a trick. Like something I’ll pay for later.
I look away, toward the ocean, but even that feels distant. It used to feel like home. Maybe. But now it’s just noise. A place that threw me out.
I pull Bryn’s hoodie tighter around me, my voice barely above a whisper. “I’m fine. Just need a minute.”
But inside, I’m screaming.
“I’m not fine. I don’t know who I am. I don’t know what happened. All I know is I’m not from this land. I used to be a mermaid. A mermaid who knows too much about humans. But how I ended up naked on the shore with human feet tells me something forced me out of the ocean.”
The waves keep crashing like they don’t care. And maybe they don’t. Maybe the world’s better off without me knowing who I was.
Because if all I ever was… was the fat one…
Then maybe forgetting is the best thing that’s ever happened to me.
Swipe up to continue
I didn’t expect to wake up again, let alone in a bed.
But I do.
The sheets are soft, cottony, and smell faintly like coconut. I’m wrapped in a big shirt that says “Pelican Cove Resort” on the front, and I’m pretty sure it’s meant to be a nightshirt or a large for someone way smaller than me. On me, it’s tight around the chest and rides up when I shift. I keep pulling it down, fidgeting. It’s stupid. It’s just a shirt. But it makes me feel like I’m wearing a label that says “Doesn’t Belong.”
Bryn appears in the doorway like a breeze, carrying a glass of water and a plate of something warm. She smiles when she sees me awake, like I’m some fragile bird she’s nursing back to health.
“I brought toast,” she says, like toast can fix an identity crisis. “You’ve been asleep since yesterday.”
I mutter a quiet thanks. My voice sounds foreign in this new space. The room is bright and beachy—light walls, seashell curtains, a fan spinning lazily overhead. It’s one of the guest rooms at her family’s resort, she told me. She’s letting me stay here “for now,” whatever that means. I want to be grateful, I do. But it feels like a trick. Like she’s going to wake up one day, realize what I am, and kick me out.
I eat slowly, pretending I’m okay. I’m not.
The mirror over the dresser keeps catching my eye. I hate it. It reflects everything I try not to think about—my thick arms, the curve of my stomach, the way my face looks too soft, too round, too wrong in this delicate space. I keep seeing that seaweed girl on the beach. I keep hearing the word pufferfish echoing in my skull.
***
Later, Bryn takes me on a quiet tour of the resort. We avoid the main lobby where guests drift in and out in sundresses and sandals, all looking like they belong here. I cling to the edges of the hallways, pulling at the too-tight hem of her spare shirt, feeling like an intruder in a world built for smaller, prettier people.
Then we reach the pool deck, and that’s when I see him.
There’s a guy adjusting umbrellas near the pool, humming to himself, moving like someone who doesn’t have to second-guess every step. He’s tall, broad-shouldered, with tanned skin and dark hair pushed back like he just shook it out of the ocean. When he looks up and sees us, he smiles. It’s the kind of smile that hits you straight in the chest. Warm. Easy. Effortless.
He walks over, and I instinctively try to shrink behind Bryn.
“Hey, Bryn,” he says, all casual confidence. Then he looks at me. “Hey there.”
I flinch, barely nod.
“This is… my friend,” Bryn says with a light glance at me. “She’s staying with us for a while.”
“I’m Finn,” he says, grinning like he means it. “Nice to meet you.”
So now I know his name.
Finn.
Of course that would be his name. The kind of name you give to guys who have abs and charm and probably never once worried if a shirt would make them look fatter.
“You’ve got a great smile,” he says.
I freeze. My first instinct is to laugh.
Great smile? Yeah, sure—if you can ignore that it’s plastered across a face shaped like a soft dinner roll. My cheeks puff when I talk. My nose crinkles. I look ridiculous.
I want to say, Are you blind? I’m fat, Finn. You don’t say things like that to girls like me. But the words never make it out. They stick in my throat, too heavy, too loaded. Instead, I mutter something close to a “thanks” and stare down at the tiles.
And then—
“Seriously, Bryn?” a sharp voice cuts through the sunlit air. “This is who we’re letting stay here now?”
I don’t recognize the voice. But I recognize the tone. I don’t even have to look to know what’s coming.
I turn anyway.
He’s standing near the cabana—lean, golden-skinned, beach-sculpted, smirk already locked in. He’s wearing expensive-looking shorts and a bored expression, as if the world exists solely to annoy him. His hair is tousled in a way that says it takes effort to look that careless.
“That’s Kieran,” Bryn says quietly to me. “His family’s one of the resort’s major stakeholders. He thinks that means he owns the place.”
Of course he does.
He saunters closer, eyes on me like I’m a curiosity he’s trying to decide whether to mock or ignore.
“What’s her name?” he asks Bryn. “Or does she not come with one?”
I stiffen. My mouth opens, but nothing comes out.
“Are you mute?” he says, grinning like he’s being clever.
“I... am...” I choke out.
He lifts a brow. “Wow. So articulate.”
“That’s enough,” Bryn snaps, stepping between us like a barrier. “She’s staying here, and I’m the one in charge while my parents are gone. So back off.”
Kieran rolls his eyes and throws his hands up. “Sure. Whatever. Just don’t blame me when she starts freaking out the guests.”
I want to disappear. Melt into the pavement. Crawl into the ocean and never come back.
Bryn softens again once he walks off. She turns to me gently. “Do you really not remember your name?”
I shake my head. Shame tightens around my throat like a rope.
“Well,” she says after a beat, “for now, let’s call you Aqua.”
The name catches me off guard. It feels clean. Fluid. Simple.
Not pufferfish. Not fat girl. Not stray.
Just… Aqua.
I nod.
“Aqua,” I whisper, tasting it.
And for the first time, it doesn’t feel like a joke.
Swipe up to continue
Bryn didn’t just give me a name. She gave me something else I didn’t expect: a job.
“I need help,” she’d said, her hands deep in a bin of folded towels. “We’re short-staffed, and Kieran’s about as useful as a sunburn.”
That was all it took. No paperwork, no explanation, just a borrowed clipboard and a name tag that said Aqua in neat handwriting. And just like that, I was part of the resort staff. Sort of.
Now I spend my days cleaning up after other people’s vacations—stocking towels, refilling sunscreen pumps, pretending not to notice when guests glance at me and then look away like I don’t fit the aesthetic. It’s fine. I don’t.
The worst part of the day always comes early: Kieran’s entrance.
He shows up like he owns the place—because technically, his family does. Or at least part of it. Stakeholders, Bryn had whispered, rolling her eyes. He’s not on payroll, but he doesn’t need to be. He gets everything for free: food, drinks, space, attention. The whole resort is his playground, and the rest of us are just props in the background of his summer.
He’s beautiful, in that awful, effortless way. Golden-blond hair that somehow never looks greasy, a lean body that’s all angles and shadows, tanned skin that glows even when he’s doing absolutely nothing. He always wears button-downs like he got caught mid-strip, and swimsuits that cling a little too perfectly.
And he hates me.
“Stray whale,” he said today, in passing, as I struggled to push a cart of drinks across the deck. He didn’t even stop walking. Just dropped it behind him like a grenade and kept going, letting it explode in my chest.
He doesn’t need to try hard. He just aims.
“Sea cow.” “Beach blob.” “Tide accident.” He’s creative when he wants to be.
I laugh sometimes. Not because it’s funny, but because laughing hurts less than crying.
Maybe I should collect the insults. Hang them like art. Pufferfish. Whale. Monster. Frame them in my mind so I remember what I’m not supposed to forget—I don’t belong here. I never did.
I try to keep busy. Avoid mirrors. Avoid attention. But Finn doesn’t let me fade.
I’m folding towels at the supply station when he walks over with a pool net slung over one shoulder and that familiar, stupidly kind grin on his face. He glances at the stack I’ve been working on.
“You’ve got a rhythm going,” he says.
“Or I’m just doing the bare minimum,” I mutter.
“Well, your bare minimum is still better than Kieran’s best effort.”
I smile despite myself, small and tight. He’s easy to talk to, which somehow makes it worse. Like he’s disarming me on purpose.
He leans against the wall, arms crossed, watching the guests splash and float. “You settling in okay?”
I shrug. “As much as someone with no identity and a part-time towel folding gig can settle.”
He glances sideways at me. “Hey. Don’t let that jackass get in your head.”
I know who he means. He doesn’t even have to say the name.
“Oh, yeah. Because that’s so easy,” I say, keeping my tone light, sarcastic. “Just turn down the volume on the human megaphone who makes sure the entire pool hears what I look like every morning. Problem solved.”
Finn’s jaw tightens. “He does it because he’s bored and insecure. Doesn’t mean a word of it.”
I shake my head, scoffing. “Yeah, well, he’s not wrong. I am fat. I get it. He just has better words for it than I do.”
“Jesus, Aqua,” he mutters, pushing off the wall to face me more directly. “That’s not all you are.”
I stare at him, heart pounding. He means it. I can see it in his eyes. But it doesn’t reach me. I want to believe it. I just... don’t know how.
“I’ve always been the fat one,” I say quietly. “The too-much one. The one people laugh at when they think I can’t hear.”
“You’re not too much,” he says. “You’re just surrounded by people who are too small to handle you.”
That silences me.
He doesn’t wait for a response. He just gives me one of those soft, crooked smiles—like he’s letting me keep something—and turns back toward the pool.
But before he walks away, he calls over his shoulder, “You coming to the party tomorrow?”
I blink. “What party?”
“Kickoff for the guests. Bonfire, drinks, music. Bryn’s making me go.”
I open my mouth to say no. My instinct is always no. No to crowds. No to attention. No to dresses that don’t fit and people who’ll stare. But Finn is still looking at me.
For a second, just one, I think about what it would be like to say yes.
Swipe up to continue