“Come on, it’ll be fun,” Bryn had said, bouncing around the room like we were prepping for prom.
I gave her a look that basically said, I’d rather eat sand.
She just smirked. “You need to get out. Breathe a little. Look hot. Shock some people.”
I’d laughed—awkward, hollow. “Yeah, shocking people is kind of my brand.”
And yet, here I am. In front of the mirror. Staring at myself like I’m trying to find a version of me I don’t hate.
The dress Bryn lent me is… tight. Too tight. Like it was made for someone else—someone narrower, smoother, easier to look at. The color’s pretty. Ocean blue, soft and shimmery. I used to dream about dresses like this, back when I watched parties from the edge of the waves. Humans dancing under strings of lights, twirling in each other’s arms like it meant something.
Back then, I thought it looked magical. Back then, I thought maybe someday I’d be one of them.
Now? I feel like a fraud stuffed into taffeta.
I grab the cardigan and yank it on, pulling it tight across my chest like it can somehow make all of this—my body, my fear, this night—smaller. Manageable. If I pretend hard enough, maybe the girl in the mirror isn’t me.
The lobby looks like a fairy tale exploded. Lights everywhere. Music thumping from hidden speakers. The guests? Models. Everyone tanned, toned, glowing. Like they all crawled out of the same Instagram filter.
I stick to the walls, sweating under my sweater, pretending to look casual while trying not to throw up. I get a few looks. No one says anything, but I can feel it. The glances. The quiet whispers. That look that says what is she doing here?
And then I hear him.
Of course it’s him.
Kieran’s voice cuts through the music like a whip.
“Well, damn. Someone really tried to gift wrap a beach ball. Nice sweater, though.”
Laughter follows—sharp and fake and echoing in my skull. My face flames. My fingers dig into the sleeve of the cardigan, knuckles going white. I freeze, wishing for invisibility. Wishing for the sea.
I blink fast, jaw tight, trying to hold it together.
And then—Finn.
He doesn’t say a word. Just slides up beside me and hands me a drink, quiet and smooth, like he knows I need an exit but won’t make a scene.
I nod once. Grateful. Shaking.
And then I chug it.
Bad idea.
The burn hits quick. Sharp, fizzy. I barely breathe before I’m reaching for another.
The second drink goes down easier.
Too easy.
And suddenly the room feels soft at the edges. Like a watercolor. Like a blur.
The pain is still there, but now it’s muffled. Like someone turned the volume down on my thoughts.
And that’s when I decide.
If Kieran wants a show, I’ll give him one.
I pull away from the wall, feet heavier than I expected. People glance up as I move across the room, my dress tugging in all the wrong places, my heart thudding like a drum in my chest.
He’s leaning against the bar, laughing at something I wasn’t part of.
Until I am.
I stop right in front of him.
He looks up, smirk already forming, until he sees my face. Something flickers in his eyes.
I don’t stop. I reach for the buttons on my cardigan and start undoing them. One. Two. Three. My hands are trembling. My stomach’s flipping.
But I keep going.
I want him to see.
Not the insult. Not the joke. Me.
The real girl he keeps tearing down.
His expression shifts instantly. The grin disappears. His jaw tightens.
“Hey—” he starts, stepping forward, voice low and angry. “What the hell are you doing?”
I laugh. It sounds broken. Sloppy.
“Isn’t this what you wanted?” I slur. “A good laugh? Big reveal?”
My fingers slip on the last button.
Before I can pull the cardigan off completely, he moves.
Fast.
He grabs both sides and yanks them closed, his hands gripping tight. Not rough, but not gentle either. Like he’s trying to fix something without making it worse.
His face is inches from mine now.
His voice drops. “Don’t do that.”
I blink, dizzy. The room tilts sideways. My balance shifts. And suddenly, my fingers are tangled in his jacket, holding on because gravity is no longer my friend.
“I just wanted to show you…” I whisper, voice thick and shaky, “I’m not what you said.”
And then my knees buckle.
The world swims.
And I fall. Right into him.
And he catches me. Not like he wanted to.
But like he couldn’t not.
Swipe up to continue
The party’s a ghost I can’t shake.
It haunts the back of my eyelids, flickering every time I blink. Kieran’s voice cutting me open like a blade. My cardigan slipping. The flash of his face when he caught me. Not laughing. Not smirking. Just… tight-jawed and furious.
Was it anger? Disgust?
Pity?
Whatever it was, it’s been chewing at my brain all night. Sleep didn’t stand a chance. I tossed and turned for hours, drowning in the memory of every laugh, every stare, every second of silence after I fell into him like some sad, drunk cliché.
By morning, I feel like chewed-up driftwood.
I drag myself downstairs, hoping to slip by unnoticed, maybe vanish into some forgotten corner of the pool deck.
No such luck.
Finn spots me from halfway across the lawn, two lemonades in hand and that same stupid, golden-boy smile like nothing in the world could possibly be wrong.
“Hey! You survived. That’s a good sign.”
I groan. “Barely. Pretty sure I’m legally dead inside.”
He laughs, handing me a drink. “Cool. So just regular dead girl vibes, nothing dramatic.”
I actually smile—small, tight, but real. He makes it easy. When Finn looks at me, I don’t feel like the joke everyone else sees. I don’t feel like the punchline.
But the universe can’t let me have a moment.
The air shifts. A ripple across the back of my neck.
And then he’s there.
Kieran.
Leaning against a post like he’s part of the architecture. Shirt half-unbuttoned, eyes sharp, unreadable. He’s too close. Too much. My heart slams.
Finn’s smile flickers.
Kieran looks right at me, and the temperature drops.
“You sober now, pufferfish?” he says, voice loud and easy. Too easy. “Or should we keep the cardigans locked down just in case?”
The words hit like a slap. My fingers tighten around the lemonade.
He said it loud on purpose. So everyone could hear.
Finn steps forward. “Seriously, Kieran? You’ve got nothing better to do than bully a girl who already had a rough night?”
Kieran shrugs, unfazed. “Oh, I’m sorry. Did I hurt her feelings? Maybe next time she can flash someone who actually cares.”
I flinch. My cheeks burn. My throat closes.
Finn’s jaw clenches. “You don’t get to talk to her like that.”
The silence after that stretches. Finn’s standing between us now, fists tight at his sides, but Kieran doesn’t look at him.
He looks at me.
Like I’m something he can’t quite figure out. Something he doesn’t like not having the answer to.
His stare is colder than the ocean.
I should be furious. I should say something—anything. But my words have gone into hiding again, buried deep under embarrassment and fury and something worse.
Something that shouldn’t be there.
Because I don’t just want him to stop.
I want him to mean it.
I want him to look at me and not see a joke.
God, I hate myself for that.
Kieran scoffs, shoving off the post like he’s bored. “Whatever. Try not to trip over your own drama.”
He walks off without waiting for a response, leaving a silence behind that feels like pressure in my chest.
Finn turns to me, brows furrowed. “You okay?”
No.
“Yes,” I say.
“You don’t have to listen to a word he says.”
I nod, not trusting my voice.
“He’s just—” Finn sighs. “Kieran. Always been like that. Doesn’t know how to be a decent person unless it’s to impress someone richer.”
That makes me snort a little, which earns a smile from him. But my laugh fades fast.
Because I can still feel Kieran’s stare.
I mumble something about needing to check the towel station and bolt before Finn can offer to come with me.
As I walk away, my heart hammers in my ribs like it’s trying to warn me.
I don’t know who I’m more afraid of right now—Kieran or myself.
Because when he looked at me like that?
It didn’t feel like he was mocking me.
It felt like he was angry. Like he was jealous. Like it mattered.
And that makes my chest ache.
That makes me hate myself.
“Stop it, Aqua,” I whisper under my breath. “He’s just the guy who thinks you’re a joke. Remember?”
But that look?
I can’t stop remembering that either.
Swipe up to continue
The sun is high and lazy, dripping heat over everything like honey. Bryn and I sit under a big striped umbrella with melting popsicles and sandy feet, watching the world pretend to be perfect.
I should feel relaxed.
I don’t.
Because Finn is down by the lifeguard tower, shirtless and sunshine-lit, throwing a frisbee with two kids like he’s the poster boy for summer. His skin is bronzed, his hair tousled just enough to look like it was done on purpose, and when he laughs, it’s the kind that makes people turn and smile without even knowing why.
He’s hot. I mean, that’s obvious. Anyone with a pulse would notice.
But me? I notice—and then... nothing.
No butterflies. No weak knees. No swoony music playing in my head.
Just appreciation. Like art. A safe distance.
It should be different. He’s sweet. He’s safe. He talks to me like I’m human, like I’m not some joke walking around in a borrowed body. And still, I feel... nothing.
Not like—
Bryn interrupts my thought.
“Any flashes yet?” she asks, licking orange juice off her thumb.
“Huh?”
“Your memory,” she says, giving me a quick side-glance. “Anything coming back?”
I pause. Lie already curling in the back of my throat.
Because yeah—things are coming back.
Little pieces. Slippery fragments of where I’m from. Cold saltwater. The shimmer of coral. My sisters—or girls who used to feel like sisters—circling me, laughing. The sting of the word pufferfish echoing through water. I remember leaving. I remember why I ran. I remember how it felt to finally break the surface and not look back.
And I remember what I gave up to do it.
But I can’t tell her any of that.
So I do what I’m getting better at.
I shut my eyes and lie.
“No. I don’t.”
She watches me for a second, like maybe she sees through it. But Bryn’s good. She lets it drop.
“Finn’s been nice to me,” I say quickly, redirecting. “That’s... cool.”
“Nice?” she repeats, smirking. “He’s cute. And he’s definitely into you.”
I laugh. Not because it’s funny—because it’s so absurd I can’t not. “Yeah, okay. I’m sure he’s dying to get with the girl who hides under oversized cardigans and sweats through every public appearance.”
“You’re ridiculous,” she says, nudging me with her elbow. “You don’t see yourself clearly.”
“No. I see myself too clearly. That’s the problem.”
I say it flat, but my voice cracks on the edges. She doesn’t argue. She knows better than to try.
The silence stretches between us for a while, warm and sticky, until something shifts.
It’s not the breeze. Not the light.
It’s me.
My skin prickles before I even look up.
And there he is.
Kieran.
Leaning against the deck railing, sunglasses hiding his eyes, expression unreadable. He’s shirtless too—of course—and his body is lean and sculpted like he’s never had to try. His lips are set in that lazy line, the one that says he’s already decided he’s better than you, and he’s just waiting for you to realize it.
I feel my stomach drop.
Not like it does with Finn.
This is worse. It’s sharp. Heavy. Physical.
I hate it.
I hate the way my body reacts before my brain has time to veto the attraction. I hate that I want to know what he’s thinking when he looks at me like that—like I’m something between a puzzle and a fire hazard.
Bryn follows my gaze. “And him?”
I exhale slowly. “He’d rather drown than like me.”
She raises an eyebrow, unconvinced.
“I’m not being dramatic,” I say. “I’m his favorite insult. His personal comedy hour. If I got hit by a boat tomorrow, he’d probably celebrate.”
“You sure?” she asks. “Because he stares at you a lot.”
“Yeah, well, so do sharks.”
She smirks, but doesn’t say anything. Just sucks on the last bit of her popsicle and wipes her hands on a napkin.
Then she says it. Soft. Too soft.
“Sometimes boys say the meanest things when they feel the most.”
I groan like I’ve been physically wounded. “Please don’t start. Not with him.”
“But—”
“No,” I cut her off. “That’s the kind of thinking that gets girls writing sad poetry at two in the morning. Kieran doesn’t feel anything for me. He feels at me. That’s not the same.”
Bryn doesn’t fight me on it. Just gives me that maddening, quiet, wise look.
Still, I glance up again. He’s gone. Just like that. The deck’s empty. Like he vanished the second I started wondering.
I sigh, wiping my sticky hands on a napkin, even though it doesn’t help.
“He’s not... like that,” I say quietly. “Whatever he feels, it’s not about me.”
Bryn shrugs. “Maybe not. Or maybe he just doesn’t know what to do with it.”
I shake my head. “Or maybe I should stop caring about what a guy who calls me a sea monster thinks.”
She grins. “Also valid.”
We sit there a little longer, letting the sun drip down our shoulders and the waves carry away our words.
But even as I try to laugh with her, the feeling lingers.
Kieran’s stare.
The twist in my stomach.
The part of me that hates how much it wants him to see something different when he looks at me.
Swipe up to continue