The bedroom door clicks shut behind us and the click sounds final, like the last page of a chapter I’m not ready to finish reading.
For a heartbeat no one moves. The only light is the faint gray bleed from the streetlamps through half-closed blinds, striping gold across Mateo’s cheekbones and turning Axel’s eyes into glacier water.
Mateo is the one who breaks first. He drags a hand through his curls, exhaling like he’s been holding his breath for weeks.
“Selene.” My name is soft, careful. “Last chance to kick us out. No hard feelings. Swear on my jump shot.”
I should laugh. I should say something clever and therapist-neutral that puts us all back on safe ground. Instead I reach up, fist the fabric of his t-shirt and yank him down until his mouth crashes into mine.
That’s all the answer he needs.
Mateo kisses like he plays: creative, instinctive, a little filthy. His tongue slides against mine, teasing, then demanding, and his hands are already mapping my waist, my hips, the curve where my blouse meets skin.
He tastes like tequila and the lime we passed around earlier, and I want to drown in it.
Behind me, the mattress dips. Axel hasn’t said a word, but I feel him: six-foot-eight of deliberate heat settling at my back. His palms skim up my sides, slow, like he’s memorizing the shape of me through fabric.
There’s no awkward shuffle, no accidental elbow. They’ve shared hotel rooms for years; they know exactly how much space the other needs. That same choreography is here now, effortless, and it’s devastating.
Mateo pulls back just far enough to grin against my lips. “Told you she wouldn’t kick us out.”
Axel’s answer is a low growl in Icelandic: rough syllables that vibrate against the shell of my ear and make my knees weak even though I don’t understand a single one. Then his mouth is on my neck, teeth scraping just hard enough to promise a mark tomorrow.
Buttons scatter. My blouse disappears somewhere across the room. Mateo’s t-shirt follows, then Axel’s, and suddenly there’s skin everywhere: warm tan and pale marble and the dark ink of Axel’s Norse runes flexing over muscle as he moves.
I reach for Mateo again and he lets me, but Axel catches my wrists before I make contact, pinning them gently above my head against the headboard.
The wood is cool against my knuckles; his grip is anything but.
“Look at me,” Axel says, voice gravel and smoke. His eyes are molten now, all that ice melted into something dangerous. “You’re sure?”
I nod, breathless. “Don’t you dare stop now.”
He makes a sound: half laugh, half prayer, and crushes his mouth to mine.
This kiss is different: controlled, filthy, deliberate. He kisses like a man who’s been starving and finally allowed to feast. His free hand slides down my body, thumb brushing the underside of my breast, and I arch into him without meaning to.
Mateo’s mouth finds my collarbone, then lower, tongue tracing the lace edge of my bra until I’m trembling.
“You taste better than I imagined,” he murmurs against my skin, and the vibration shoots straight between my legs. “And I imagined a lot, Doc. Like, embarrassingly often.”
I laugh: actually laugh, while Axel’s teeth graze my throat and Mateo’s fingers hook into my jeans zipper. The sound surprises all three of us.
“There she is,” Mateo says, grinning up at me, hazel eyes bright even in the near-dark. “Knew we could get the real smile back.”
Axel releases my wrists only to slide both massive hands under my thighs and lift. My back meets the mattress and suddenly I’m flat on the sheets with two very focused men looking down at me like I’m the only thing in the universe.
Mateo crawls up my body, kissing every inch he passes, until he’s braced over me. “Tell me what you want, Selene.”
“You,” I breathe. “Both of you. Now.”
He groans like I’ve wounded him and kisses me again, deep and dirty, while Axel’s hands work my jeans down my hips. Cool air hits overheated skin and then Axel’s mouth is on my inner thigh, slow, deliberate, speaking more Icelandic that I feel in my bones.
His beard scrapes deliciously, tongue drawing lazy circles higher and higher until I’m writhing, begging without words.
Mateo shifts to the side, giving Axel room without ever stopping: his fingers roll my nipple through lace until I’m gasping. When the bra is gone too, his mouth replaces his hand, hot and wet and perfect.
He bit hard enough to make my hips buck, then soothes the sting with gentle licks that have me moaning his name.
I lose track of who is where. There’s just sensation: Axel’s beard scraping sensitive skin, Mateo’s curls tickling my stomach, four hands that never seem to be in the same place twice.
Someone’s fingers slide inside me: two, then three, curling just right while a thumb circles my clit until I’m shaking, dripping, pleading.
“Please…” I gasp, not even sure what I’m asking for.
“We’ve got you,” Mateo whispers against my breast. “Let go, baby.”
Axel moves up, replacing his fingers with his cock: slow, thick pressure that stretches me open, makes my eyes roll back. He pauses, forehead pressed to mine, letting me adjust to the feeling. “Breathe.”
I do, and he slides home in one long thrust that blanks my mind completely.
Mateo watches us, pupils blown, stroking himself lazily. “Jesus, you two are gorgeous.”
Axel starts to move: deep, measured strokes that hit every perfect spot, and Mateo leans in to kiss me through it, swallowing every moan.
Then they switch, seamless, like they choreographed it in a past life.
Mateo inside me now, faster, playful, angling his hips until I see stars. Axel behind me, chest to my back, one hand splayed over my stomach, the other tangled in my hair as he growls praise I don’t need translated.
I come first: hard, blinding, crying out into Mateo’s shoulder while Axel holds me through the aftershocks. His palm pressing low on my belly like he’s claiming the pleasure itself.
They follow seconds apart, one after the other, like they timed it that way on purpose.
After, the room is nothing but tangled limbs and heavy breathing. Gray pre-dawn light creeps across the ceiling.
Mateo is half-asleep, arm flung across my stomach, face buried in my neck. Every few seconds he mumbles something that might be English, might be Spanish, might just be contentment.
Axel lies on his back beside me, one hand resting on my hip, the other staring at the ceiling like it owes him answers. His thumb traces idle circles on my skin.
I float somewhere above my body, lighter than I’ve felt in weeks.
My brain: the one that analyzes everything to death, is finally, blissfully quiet.
Mateo’s voice is sleepy-rough against my collarbone. “Should’ve done this months ago…”
Axel’s fingers find mine in the dark. He squeezes once, firm, grounding. Doesn’t say anything. Doesn’t need to.
Tomorrow I’ll overthink every second of this. Tomorrow I’ll panic about professionalism and reputations and what happens when the league finds out.
Tonight I’m just Selene, and Selene is free.
Swipe up to continue
I woke up alone.
The sheets are cold. The pillows still hold indentations—two of them, one on each side—like archaeological evidence of last night's monumentally bad decisions. My head throbs.
My body aches deliciously while the bed is catastrophically, devastatingly empty.
I sit up too fast and immediately regret every life choice that led to this moment. There's a note on my nightstand, folded once, written in two distinct handwritings.
Mateo's messy scrawl takes up the top half: ‘Last night was… yeah.’
That's it. That's the whole fucking sentence. Not "yeah, amazing" or "yeah, we should talk" or "yeah, here's my number even though you already have it because you were literally our therapist."
Just ‘yeah’.
Below it, Axel's precise block letters: A.
One letter. One initial. The emotional equivalent of a read receipt.
I stare at the note until the words blur. No phone numbers—they already have mine. No promises. No "let's get breakfast" or "call me when you wake up" or literally any indication that last night meant more than scratching an itch.
The apartment is silent except for the distant hum of traffic and my own increasingly panicked breathing. I'm surrounded by pizza boxes and fairy lights and the lingering scent of expensive cologne mixed with tequila-fueled regret.
My clinical brain—the one that stayed blissfully quiet last night—kicks into overdrive with the subtlety of a freight train.
I slept with two former clients. Two teammates of my ex-fiancé.
Two men I actually liked and respected, which somehow makes it worse.
By next week, the entire NBA will know. Locker rooms are vaults where secrets go to become legends. This will be a legend.
The nausea hits fast. I barely make it to the bathroom before I'm on my knees, retching into the toilet while my body tries to physically reject the last twelve hours of my life.
When I'm done, I sit on the cold tile floor, forehead pressed against the bathtub, and catalog every way I've destroyed my career.
My phone buzzes from somewhere in the bedroom. I ignore it. Then it buzzes again. And again. Finally, I drag myself off the bathroom floor and find my phone wedged between the mattress and the wall.
Seventeen missed calls. All from Naomi. Before I can decide whether to throw the phone out the window or answer it, it rings again.
"You're alive," Naomi says the second I pick up. No hello. No preamble. Just relief wrapped in accusation. "I've been calling for an hour. I was about to file a missing person report."
"I'm alive. Barely." My voice sounds like I gargled gravel. "What time is it?"
"Almost noon. I just got off my night shift. How'd the party go?"
I open my mouth to lie. To say something bland and neutral like "fine" or "nice of them to throw it."
Instead, what comes out is: "I slept with Axel and Mateo."
Silence. Then: "I'm sorry, you what?"
"Both of them. At the same time. In my bed. Which is where I'm currently sitting. Alone, holding a note that says 'yeah' and a single letter A."
More silence. I can hear Naomi breathing, processing, probably running through her mental checklist of appropriate sisterly responses.
"Okay…" she finally says. "Scale of one to ten, how much are we panicking right now?"
"Eleven. Maybe twelve. Possibly entering thirteens."
"Right. Okay. Talk me through it. How did this happen?"
So I told her. The whole story: the tequila, the conversation about revenge, Gestalt theory and unfinished business and closing loops, the way they looked at me like I was the only thing in the universe that mattered. The note. The empty bed. The dawning horror that I've professionally self-immolated.
When I finish, Naomi is quiet for exactly three seconds. Then she says, in a tone of absolute calm: "So you had hot revenge sex with two professional athletes. Congratulations."
"That's your response? Congratulations?"
"What do you want me to say? That you're a terrible person? You're not. That your career is over? It's not—you already quit, remember? You're free." She pauses. "When's the last time you did something just for yourself, Selene? Something that wasn't calculated or professional or designed to make everyone else comfortable?"
I sit with that. The party debris seems less accusatory now. More like evidence of a life finally, messily lived.
"But what if word gets out?" My voice is small. Pathetic. "What if Cassian finds out and uses it against me? What if I run into them at some league event and have to face what we did?"
"Then you hold your head high and remember you're the one who walked away from a cheating asshole while they're stuck playing for the same organization that covered for him."
But I’m also thinking about is what if it meant nothing to them when it's already starting to mean something to me?
That's the fear, isn't it? The one I've been avoiding since I opened my eyes and found cold sheets.
Not that they'll tell everyone. That they won't.
That it was just a drunken mistake they're already forgetting while I'm sitting here cataloging every touch, every word, every moment I felt seen.
"I can't stay in Philadelphia," I say.
"I know. So don't." Naomi exhales. "I told you about Seattle, right? My contract starts in December. Found a two-bedroom in Capitol Hill that's way too expensive for one person. Hypothetically speaking, if someone wanted to split rent and start over somewhere that doesn't have Cassian's face on every billboard, the offer's there."
Seattle. Rain and mountains and three thousand miles between me and this bed.
"I'll think about it," I say, but I'm already opening my laptop.
The job listings load slowly. Most of them are boring: corporate wellness, private practice, university counseling.
Then I see it, posted yesterday: Team Psychologist - Seattle Sirens (Expansion Team).
Brand new franchise. Brand new city. Brand new Selene.
My finger hovers over the apply button. This is insane. I'm running away instead of dealing with consequences. I'm making life-altering decisions while emotionally compromised and possibly still drunk.
I click apply anyway. The confirmation email arrives instantly: ‘Thank you for your application. We'll be in touch soon.’
"I just applied for a job in Seattle," I tell Naomi.
"Good. Now shower. You smell like bad decisions and tequila."
"How do you know what I smell like?"
"Because I know you, and you're definitely surrounded by party garbage, and you probably haven't brushed your teeth."
She's not wrong.
She's never wrong, which is simultaneously comforting and infuriating.
After we hang up, I sit in the wreckage of my apartment and look out at the Philadelphia skyline. I've known this city my whole adult life. Built my career here. Fell in love here. Watched it all burn here.
Soon, I'll be gone.
Swipe up to continue
* * Two years later * *
Sören screams like he's auditioning for a death metal band. Aria joins in. Elio waits three seconds before adding his voice because maximum volume equals maximum attention.
Welcome to 6 AM, where peace goes to die.
"I've got Sören!" Naomi calls from the nursery, already in combat mode despite working a twelve-hour night shift. "You handle the hunger twins!"
I'm in the kitchen with Aria on one hip, Elio on the other, trying to warm bottles and not drop either baby.
Motherhood is advanced circus training nobody warned you about.
Naomi emerges with Sören, who's calming down because Auntie Naomi has magic powers. She's serenading him with off-key pop while bouncing him in a rhythm that could cure world peace.
"Remember when you said you were just crashing for a few weeks?" Naomi grins at me over Sören's dark curls. "That was almost two years ago. Now look at you. Surprise, triplets!"
"I seem to recall you screaming so loud when you saw the pregnancy test that Mrs. Chen next door called the police." I managed to get both bottles ready without causing a natural disaster.
Small victories.
"In my defense, you peed on a stick and it basically was a little spoiler and said 'congratulations, you're having a small basketball team.' The screaming was justified."
She's not wrong. Three babies. The universe decided I needed to make up for lost time in reproduction.
Aria latches onto her bottle like it's personally wronged her. Elio is more philosophical about it, drinking contemplatively. Naomi settles on the couch with Sören, who's finally stopped auditioning for the metal band and is now just adorably gumming his fist.
"Still can't believe the Sirens GM didn't even blink when you showed up to your interview visibly pregnant."
"She just said they wanted my brain and the rest was none of their business." I sink onto the couch beside Naomi, careful not to jostle the eating twins. "Best interview of my life."
"Because you weren't trying to hide anything. You were just you, complete with a baby bump and zero apologies."
I love this job. Love it in a way I never loved working for the Ravens, even before everything exploded.
The Sirens are hungry and hopeful and completely assholes-free. No ghosts in these halls. No ex-fiancés lurking around corners. Just basketball and babies and a fresh start that actually feels fresh.
"Thanks for watching them today," I say, adjusting Aria before she decides the bottle is for throwing, not drinking. "Full day at the facility. Team meetings, one-on-ones, probably some minor crisis management."
"It's literally my job." Naomi rolls her eyes. "I'm the live-in aunt. I signed a contract. There were clauses."
"There were no clauses."
"There should have been. I would've negotiated for more wine and less baby vomit!"
Sören chooses this exact moment to spit up on her shoulder. Comedic timing runs in the family.
After we get everyone settled—babies fed, changed, and arranged in their various baby containment devices—Naomi gets that look. The one that means she's about to ask a question I don't want to answer.
"Do you ever think about telling them?"
She doesn't need to specify who. We both know.
My answer is immediate, rehearsed, delivered with the confidence of someone who's answered it a million times already—because I have.
"They left before I woke up. That was an answer enough. And I don't want to know which one is the father because they're all mine. All three of them are mine."
It's not a lie. I decided months ago that I didn't need DNA tests or paternity results or any kind of definitive answer. Aria, Elio, and Sören are mine. That's the only truth that matters.
Naomi doesn't push. She never does. Just nods and adjusts Sören on her lap while I gather my work bag and try to look like a functional adult instead of someone running on four hours of sleep and pure determination.
"Go save some basketball players' mental health," Naomi says. "We'll be here, teaching the babies about the patriarchy and why sharing toys is a capitalist construct."
"Please don't radicalize my children before they can walk."
"No promises."
***
The Sirens facility is buzzing when I arrive. Not the normal pre-practice energy—something else. Something electric and slightly manic.
People are clustered in groups, phones out, whispering like they're planning a heist.
I'm halfway to my office when I catch fragments of conversation: "...huge trade..." and "...announcement tomorrow..." and "...can't believe they pulled it off..."
My coffee suddenly tastes like anxiety.
In the break room, two of my players—Jordan and Martin—are practically vibrating with excitement. I grab a fresh cup and try to look casual, like my heart isn't currently attempting to break several Olympic records.
"Morning, Doc," Jordan says, grinning. "You heard about the trade?"
"Trade?" My voice comes out steady. Therapist voice. Professional. "What trade?"
"Big one. GM's been working on it for weeks." Marcus leans in conspiratorially. "Getting two players from Philly. Announcement's tomorrow."
The coffee cup freezes halfway to my mouth. Philadelphia. Of course it's Philadelphia.
The universe has a sick sense of humor and I'm the punchline.
"Do you know who?" I ask, still in that carefully neutral tone that's taking every ounce of training I possess.
"Not yet. Could be anyone." Jordan shrugs. "But whoever it is, they're good enough to be worth three first-rounders."
Three first-rounders.
That's not a trade. That's a heist.
I manage some appropriate response—something about being excited for the team—and escape to my office before my face betrays the absolute chaos happening in my brain.
It could be Cassian.
The thought makes my stomach turn. Thirteen months of Seattle sunshine and coffee and freedom, and he could be walking through those doors tomorrow, ready to ruin my carefully constructed peace.
But it could also be Axel. Or Mateo.
Or both.
Honestly? The only one who wouldn’t make me shit my pants is Mr. Pop. And he’s not even on the team.
I spend the rest of the day going through the motions. Sessions with players who don't realize their psychologist is having a small internal crisis. Paperwork that might as well be written in hieroglyphics for all the attention I'm paying it.
Every time someone mentions the trade, I smile and nod and die a little inside.
By the time I get home, I'm exhausted in a way that has nothing to do with sleep deprivation and everything to do with existential dread.
Naomi takes one look at my face and hands me a baby and a glass of wine. "Bad day?"
"Long day," I say, which isn't a lie. Just not the whole truth.
She doesn't push, just settles beside me with Sören while I hold Elio and try to look like someone whose world isn't about to implode. We sit in comfortable silence while the babies do their evening routine of being cute and demonic.
"You okay?" Naomi asks eventually.
"Yeah," I lied. "Just tired."
That night, I couldn't sleep. Just lie in bed listening to the baby monitor, tracking three breathing patterns, trying not to think about tomorrow. Trying not to imagine faces I haven't seen in thirteen months.
It could be Cassian, which would be an epic nightmare.
It could be Axel or Mateo, which might be worse.
It could be both, which would mean the universe has a sick sense of humor and I'm the punchline.
Tomorrow I'll find out.
Swipe up to continue