The morning after our confrontation, I stood in the kitchen reconsidering everything.
I'd shown Nate too much. Given him ammunition to use against me, to convince Gabriel I was a threat rather than an asset to the pack.
"Coffee?" I offered when Nate entered, keeping my voice neutral.
He stopped in the doorway, suspicion radiating from every line of his body.
"What's your angle now?"
"No angle. Just coffee." I poured two cups, sliding one across the counter. "I thought about what you said. Maybe we should try to coexist peacefully. For Gabriel's sake."
"Right. For Gabriel." He took the coffee but didn't drink, watching me like I might poison him. "This is another performance, isn't it?"
"Everything's a performance to you," I said, sitting across from him. "Can't someone just offer coffee without ulterior motives?"
"Not you."
Here we go again…
The week that followed became an exercise in persistence. Every morning, I made coffee for both of us. Every afternoon, I asked his opinion on pack matters—genuinely listening to his responses.
When he mentioned missing Gabriel during evening patrols, I walked with him in companionable silence.
"Why are you doing this?" he demanded on day three, when I brought him lunch during his training session with the younger wolves.
"Because you're important to Gabriel, which makes you important to me," I said simply. "And because maybe you're right. Maybe I have been too guarded."
"This is just another mask," he shot back, though he took the sandwich. "Sweet Kat, trying to win over the bad mean Beta."
"Or maybe," I said, watching the young wolves spar, "I'm trying to show you that being multifaceted doesn't make someone fake. People can be both soft and strong, Nate."
He laughed bitterly. "Save the philosophy for someone who believes it."
On day five, I found him in Gabriel's office, surrounded by patrol schedules and territory maps.
"The eastern border," I said, studying the markings. "You're stretching the patrols too thin."
"And here comes the real Kat," he muttered. "Can't help yourself, can you?"
"I'm trying to help." I pointed to the map. "If you rotate the schedule here and here, you get better coverage without exhausting the guards."
"Why would you help me?"
"Because protecting the pack protects Gabriel. And despite what you think, I do care about him." I met his eyes directly. "The bond might have brought us together, but what I feel for him is real."
"Feelings based on lies aren't real," Nate countered, but he adjusted the patrol schedule as I'd suggested.
Day seven brought everything crashing down.
I was at the pack school, teaching the youngest pups their letters. Nate lounged against the wall, his constant shadow, when little Emma asked the question that lit the fuse.
"Miss Katherine, why doesn't Beta Nate like you?"
The room went silent. Eight pairs of innocent eyes stared at me, waiting.
"Beta Nate and I are still getting to know each other," I said carefully. "Sometimes adults need time to become friends."
"But he looks at you mean," Tommy added. "Like you did something bad."
"Maybe she did," Nate said from his corner, his voice carrying clearly. "Maybe Miss Katherine isn't as nice as she pretends to be."
The pups gasped and my hands clenched around the storybook.
"Nate," I warned quietly.
"What? They asked a question." He pushed off the wall, approaching slowly. "Shouldn't we teach pups about honesty, Katherine? About being genuine?"
"This isn't the place—"
"No? Where is the place? Because you seem to perform everywhere." His voice grew harder. "In the pack house, at meetings, even here with children. When do you stop pretending?"
"Stop it," I said, standing slowly. "Not in front of them."
"Why? Afraid they'll see through you too?" He was right in front of me now. "Afraid these innocent pups will realize their future Luna is—"
"ENOUGH!"
The word tore from my throat with such force that several pups whimpered. My entire body shook with barely contained fury.
"You want to attack me? Fine. But not here. Not in front of children who have nothing to do with your personal vendetta."
The pups huddled together, some beginning to cry. The sight of their fear shattered something in both of us and I’ve mentioned how Nate's face went pale.
"Guys, I'm sorry,” he said calmly, kneeling beside them. “Beta Nate was just... having a bad day. Sometimes adults argue, but it's not your fault."
"Miss Katherine isn't really mad, are you?" Emma asked tearfully.
I forced my body to relax, kneeling beside them.
"No, sweetheart. I'm not mad at you. Never at you." I gathered the crying children close. "Beta Nate and I just disagree sometimes, but we both love this pack and all of you very much."
"Even each other?" Tommy asked hopefully.
Nate and I looked at each other across the sea of small heads.
"We're working on it," Nate said quietly. "I'm sorry, Katherine. That was... I went too far."
The remaining hour passed in forced normalcy. We read stories, practiced letters, and pretended the ugly scene hadn't happened.
But the damage was done and the walk back to Gabriel's residence stretched in suffocating silence. The moment we crossed the threshold, Nate tried to speak.
"Katherine, about earlier—"
"Don't." My voice came out hollow.
"I need to apologize properly. Using the pups like that, making them scared… that was unconscionable."
"It was." I set down my bag with trembling hands. "Those children look up to us. They trust us to be safe, to be stable."
"I know. I let my suspicions override my judgment." He moved closer, genuine remorse in his voice. "Whatever I think about your motivations, the pups didn't deserve that."
"No, they didn't." The tears I'd been holding back suddenly overwhelmed me. "Do you know what it's like? Every day, every moment, being watched and judged and found wanting? Never being enough, never being right, always being suspected of something?"
"Katherine—"
"I tried!" The tears flowed freely now. "This whole week, I tried to show you I'm not some villain. That maybe I'm just a woman doing her best in an impossible situation. But nothing is ever enough for you!"
He reached out, perhaps to comfort, but I jerked away.
"I'm tired, Nate." The words came out broken. "I'm so tired of fighting you, of proving myself, of being torn between who I am and who everyone needs me to be."
"Let me—"
"No." I backed toward my room, tears still streaming. "I can't do this right now. I just... I need to be alone. Please. Just leave me alone tonight."
"Kat, wait!"
But I was already closing my door, sliding down against it as sobs wracked my body. Through the wood, I heard him stand there for a long moment before his footsteps finally retreated.
Tomorrow, I'd rebuild my walls. Tomorrow, I'll be strong again.
Tonight, I just needed to break.
Swipe up to continue
The days following my breakdown passed in careful silence.
Nate and I moved around each other like wary animals, maintaining distance while fulfilling our respective duties. No sarcasm from him, no attempts at connection from me. Just coexistence.
At the pack school, Nate had somehow transformed into the pups' favorite visitor. He brought wooden practice swords for show-and-tell, demonstrating basic defensive stances that had them squealing with delight.
"Beta Nate, show us the wolf move again!" Emma bounced on her toes, completely forgetting the tension from last week.
"Only if Luna Katherine says it's appropriate," Nate replied, glancing at me with careful neutrality.
"It's fine," I said quietly, returning to the reading corner.
The pups cheered as Nate demonstrated a rolling dodge, his movements fluid and controlled. Their laughter should have lifted my spirits.
Instead, it highlighted the hollow ache Gabriel's absence had carved in my chest.
Two weeks. Two weeks since he'd left, since I'd felt the warmth of our bond at full strength. The connection stretched thin across the distance, present but muted, like trying to hear music through water.
When his name finally lit up my phone screen that evening, and my heart nearly stopped at that moment.
"Gabriel?" My voice cracked with desperate relief.
"Katherine." His voice wrapped around me through the phone, deep and warm. "Goddess, I miss you. Tell me everything. How are you?"
"I miss you too. So much it hurts." The honesty spilled out before I could stop it. "When are you coming home?"
"Soon, my love. Barrett is being... difficult. But hearing your voice makes everything bearable. Are you eating properly? Sleeping?"
"Nate makes sure I eat." I curled into Gabriel's pillow, breathing in his fading scent. "Your bed feels too big without you…"
"I dream about you every night. About coming home to you, holding you…" His voice dropped to that intimate rumble that made Elsie whine. "Just a little longer, sweetheart."
"How much longer?"
The pause that followed sent ice through my veins.
"I need to stay a bit more. Barrett's demanding additional concessions. Territory adjustments, trade agreements… He's making this as painful as possible."
"Oh."
The single word carried all my disappointment.
"Katherine, I'm sorry. I'm trying everything—"
"I know. I understand. Pack comes first." The words tasted like ash.
"You come first. Always. But I need to handle this carefully to protect our future."
We talked for another twenty minutes, but the magic had dimmed. When we finally said goodbye, the loneliness crashed back tenfold.
The next morning at breakfast with pack members, Sarah touched my arm gently. "You look tired, dear. Are you alright?"
"Just miss Gabriel," I admitted, pushing eggs around my plate.
My mother appeared at my elbow as if summoned.
"Katherine, a word?" She pulled me into the hallway, her expression stern. "Your sadness is too obvious. Everyone's noticed."
"I can't help missing my mate—"
"You can help how you display it." Her fingers gripped my shoulders. "People love sunny and kind, Katherine. Not this moping shadow. Hide it better."
"You're right." I straightened my spine, forcing brightness into my expression. "I'll do better."
"Good girl. Remember, sweetness and light. Always."
I returned to breakfast with a practiced smile, chattering about lesson plans and upcoming pack events. But Nate watched from across the room, his gray eyes tracking every forced gesture.
That afternoon, he finally broke our unspoken ceasefire.
"Stop."
I looked up from the book I wasn't really reading. "Stop what?"
"The fake cheerfulness. It's worse than your usual act." He dropped into the chair across from me. "My wolf can sense your misery from across the pack lands. It's... unsettling."
"Your wolf shouldn’t care about my emotional state."
"Actually, he does." Nate ran a hand through his hair, seeming to wrestle with something. "Look, this is ridiculous. We're stuck together for who knows how long. Gabriel would want us to get along."
"We are getting along. We haven't fought in days."
"We haven't talked in days. That's not the same thing." He leaned forward, elbows on knees. "I'm offering a truce. Real truce. Not just avoiding each other."
I studied his face, searching for the trap. "What kind of truce?"
"The kind where we actually do something besides circle each other like wounded animals." He gestured broadly. "I'm literally assigned to you twenty-four seven. Might as well make use of it. What do you want to do? Anything. Name it."
"Anything?"
"Within reason. Can't take you to Paris or teach you to fly." His mouth quirked slightly. "But otherwise, I'm at your disposal. What has Kat always wanted to do but couldn't?"
The question hung between us, and suddenly I felt the weight of every restriction, every 'that's not ladylike,' every dream pushed down.
"I want to learn to fight.4"
The words tumbled out in a rush, followed immediately by heat flooding my cheeks.
Nate's eyebrows shot up. "Fight?"
"Self-defense. Combat training. Real training, not just theory." My hands clenched in my lap. "Mother always said it wasn't appropriate. Fighting is for warriors, not proper she-wolves. But I've watched every training session I could, memorized the forms, studied the techniques…"
"You want me to teach you to fight." He said it slowly, like he was tasting the words.
"Forget it. It's stupid…"
"It's not stupid!" His whole demeanor had shifted, energy crackling through him. "It's the first genuine thing you've said to me. You really want this?"
"More than anything…" The admission felt like stepping off a cliff. "I'm tired of being helpless. Of standing on the sidelines. Of pretending weakness is the same as femininity."
"Your mother will lose her mind."
"Mother doesn't have to know."
Nate grinned then, a real smile that transformed his entire face. "You want to secretly train behind everyone's back? That's almost devious, princess."
"Can you arrange it or not?"
"Oh, I can arrange it." He stood, already planning. "Early mornings, before the pack wakes. Private training ground in the north woods. We'll start with basic stances, build your foundation properly."
"Really?" Hope bloomed in my chest for the first time in weeks.
"Really. But I won't go easy on you just because you're the Alpha's mate. You want to learn to fight? You'll learn properly. That means sweat, bruises, and probably some tears."
"I'm not afraid of hard work."
"No," he said thoughtfully. "I'm beginning to think you're not afraid of much at all."
The anticipation thrumming through my veins felt better than any practiced sweetness.
"Tomorrow?" I asked.
"Dawn. Wear something you can move in." He headed for the door, then paused. "Kat? This stays between us."
For the first time since Gabriel left, I smiled genuinely. "Thank you, Nate."
"Don't thank me yet. Wait until you see what I have planned for your first session."
The promise in his voice should have worried me. Instead, it made Elsie practically sing with anticipation.
Swipe up to continue
Dawn mist clung to the north training grounds as I stepped into the clearing. Nate stood in the center, stretching his shoulders in fluid movements that showcased years of combat discipline.
Every line of his body spoke of controlled power—a true Beta in his element.
"You came," he said, turning to face me.
"Did you think I wouldn't?"
"Honestly? I gave it fifty-fifty odds." He circled me slowly, assessing. "First lesson—stance. Everything builds from your foundation."
He demonstrated, and I found myself mesmerized. The way he moved wasn't just skilled—it was art. Each motion flowed into the next with lethal grace, muscles shifting beneath his training gear like water over stone.
"Your turn."
He adjusted my feet with gentle kicks, hands correcting my arm position. Despite his promise not to go easy, his touch remained patient, instructive.
"Better. Now, hold that while I explain the three zones of defense."
Two weeks transformed my world. Every dawn brought new bruises and breakthroughs. My body learned to move in ways Mother would have called unseemly, unladylike, unwanted.
But here, with Nate, I felt alive.
"You're a natural," he said during our tenth session, tossing me a water bottle. "That counter-move you just executed? Most wolves take months to master it."
"Good teacher," I replied, drinking deeply.
"No. Good instincts." He sat beside me on the log, close enough that I could smell pine and sweat. "You know, I owe you an apology."
"For what exactly? Be specific."
"For thinking you were just another power-hungry fake. You're genuinely brilliant, Kat. The way you analyze movement patterns, predict attacks… it's extraordinary, really."
He turned to face me fully then, a soft smile blooming on his lips before he finally speak again.
"Thank you, for finally showing me who you really are." Something shifted in his gray eyes, warming them to silver. "I'm beginning to admire you. As a person, I mean. Your strength, your intelligence, the way you protect those pups even while maintaining your cover."
My chest tightened. The way he said 'as a person'—like he needed to clarify, like there might be another way he admired me.
"One more round," he said abruptly, standing. "Let's see if you remember yesterday's takedown defense."
We circled each other in the morning light. He feinted left, I dodged right, but his real attack came from below.
The world spun, and suddenly I was flat on my back with Nate's weight pinning me down.
His hands bracketed my wrists above my head. His hips pressed against mine. Every inch of contact burned through our training clothes. His breathing was ragged, eyes dark as storm clouds.
My body responded instantly—heat pooling low, pulse racing.
Was this the mate bond crying out for Gabriel? Or was it Nate himself, solid and warm above me, making my wolf stir with forbidden interest?
His gaze dropped to my lips and the air itself seemed to crackle between us.
It was when he kissed me.
His mouth crashed against mine, desperate and hungry. For one shocked second, I replied to the heat. Then I froze for a second when reality slammed back.
"What are you doing?" I shoved him off, scrambling backward. "Nate, what the hell?"
"Kat…” Horror dawned on his face. “Shit, sorry. I don't know what—"
"We're forgetting this happened." My voice came out sharp as glass. "Nothing happened. Everything's fine. We're fine."
"Katherine, wait—"
But I was already running. The worst part—the part that sent terror racing through my veins—wasn't just the kiss itself. It was a split second before I'd pushed him away, when every cell in my body had screamed yes.
When I wanted to pull him closer, to taste him deeper.
Gabriel.
I needed to think about Gabriel.
My mate, the man I craved with every breath, whose absence left me hollow. I counted the days until his return like a prisoner marking time. The mate bond ached for him constantly, Elsie crying for her chosen.
Gabriel's hands, Gabriel's mouth, Gabriel's warmth—that's what I wanted. That's what I was waiting for.
Yet my lips still burned from Nate's kiss.
That horrifying confusion chased me all the way back to the residence, leaving him kneeling in the dirt.
* * *
The Summer Wolves Festival filled the pack square with laughter and music that night. I stood beside the fortune-telling booth, watching couples dance while my stomach churned with anxiety. Every time I closed my eyes, I felt Nate's lips on mine.
"Katherine." His voice came from behind me, low and urgent. "Please. Let me apologize properly."
I glanced around. No one was watching us, too caught up in the celebrations.
"There's nothing to apologize for. It didn't happen."
"It did happen, and I'm sorry." He stepped closer, careful not to touch me. "I crossed a line. You're Gabriel's mate. My Alpha's, my best friend’s mate… What I did was unforgivable."
"Stop." I turned to face him fully. "You want to know why I'm really like this? Why do I play this role so perfectly?"
He nodded, eyes intent.
"When I was nine, my father was still Beta here. Strong, principled, everything a Beta should be." The words tumbled out, needing to be said. "Then the Alpha's son from the Mountain Ridge Pack beat one of our she-wolves nearly to death. She was hospitalized for weeks."
Nate's jaw clenched. "I remember hearing about that incident."
"My father demanded justice. But the old Alpha refused to act—politics were more important than one battered wolf. The alliance with Mountain Ridge mattered more."
My voice turned bitter, I could still see father’s face in my mind, his eyes full of rage and hollow at the same time.
"Father challenged the decision publicly. Said protecting pack members should come before politics."
"He was exiled for it?"
"We all were. Mother, me and Father. Banished overnight because he dared to say that a she-wolf's safety mattered." I wrapped my arms around myself. "Father died three years later. Broken. Away from his pack, his land, his purpose… everything."
"Kat…"
"Mother never recovered. She became obsessed with returning, with being accepted again. She drilled into me that the only way back was to be perfect. Sweet, gentle, non-threatening. Never challenging, never difficult, never strong enough to be seen as a threat."
Understanding dawned in his eyes. "That's why you can't drop the act?"
"I can't disappoint her. Not after everything she sacrificed, everything she lost…" I met his gaze directly. "This return, this acceptance—it's all she has left."
"And now you're the Alpha's mate."
"Which makes it even more critical that I'm perfect." I stepped back, creating distance between us. "What happened this morning… it can't."
His hands clenched at his sides. "And this thing between us?"
"Doesn't exist." The lie tasted like ash. He nodded slowly, though something in his eyes suggested this wasn't over. "You're Gabriel's Beta. I'm Gabriel's mate. That's all we can be."
Swipe up to continue