* Present *
Six weeks of college, and I've learned that hope is just disappointment wearing a pretty dress.
Here's the thing about applying to twelve universities: you think you're buying options, but really you're just collecting different flavors of the same disappointment.
I had acceptances from everywhere—UCLA, NYU, places with actual seasons and zero Caleb Thorntons per square mile. But no. Dad pulled the "family needs to stick together" card. Catherine deployed the weaponized puppy eyes.
The local university had an excellent pre-law program, they said.
We'd already been through so much change, they said.
So I caved. Of course I fucking caved. Because I'm Serena Lakin, professional people-pleaser and gold medalist in sacrificing my happiness for family harmony.
I told myself it would be fine.
We pretended that nothing happened in my bedroom near, kept our distance through the rest of the high school senior year and Caleb had no interest in college anyway.
He'd made that clear for years—school was just a social playground, academics beneath him. He'd probably take a gap year, travel, do whatever bad boys with charming smiles do when the world hands them everything.
A girl can dream.
Then orientation day arrived, and I saw him across the quad.
The bastard had applied after me. After. Found out where I was going and followed like some kind of stalker.
Even won grants and scholarships—including the one from his high school presidency, the position he'd stolen from me senior year—to make it work.
My fresh start rotted before it even began.
Today the family picnic sprawls across our backyard like a Norman Rockwell painting gone wrong.
Checkered blankets dot the grass. Neighbors mill about with paper plates and forced laughter. Catherine floats between groups, the perfect hostess, while my father mans the grill with practiced ease.
I'm arranging a fruit platter when I hear it. That voice.
That specific frequency of feminine giggle that makes my eye twitch.
"Caleb, this is so cute! Your family is adorable."
Jade stands at the garden gate, her hand threaded through Caleb's arm. Her sundress clings to curves I remember from the locker room, curves I heard him worship in his bedroom while my body betrayed every principle I claimed to hold.
My fingers tighten around the serving spoon until the metal bites into my palm.
He brought her here. To our home. In front of our parents.
"Oh, Caleb!" Catherine practically levitates with maternal joy. "You didn't mention you were bringing someone! Jade, sweetheart, welcome! There's so much food!"
"Thanks, Mrs. Lakin." Jade's smile stretches wide and vacant. "Everything looks amazing. Did you make all this yourself?"
Of course she did. It's her house. Her party.
"Most of it," Catherine beams. "Serena helped with the fruit platters."
Jade's gaze slides to me, and her smile shifts into something I recognize—that subtle female assessment that happens in microseconds. "How domestic! You're so good at this stuff, Serena."
The compliment lands like a slap wrapped in ribbons.
This stuff. Like I'm some 1950s housewife in training while she's out here being decorative and touchable and everything I'm not.
She has no idea she's a weapon.
Or maybe she does, and the vacant smile is just better armor than mine.
Caleb's eyes find mine across the yard. That familiar smirk tugs at his mouth, the one that says ‘I know exactly what I’m doing.’
I look away first. Always do.
"We're so proud of both of them," Catherine tells the Hendersons from next door, who definitely didn't ask. "Adjusting to college life so beautifully. And it's just wonderful having them home together!"
"Serena's doing wonderfully," Dad adds, because he can't help himself. "Dean's list material, her advisor says."
"Well, she has to excel at something," Caleb says pleasantly, his voice carrying that razor edge wrapped in charm. "Competition's tough when you can't coast on personality."
The Hendersons laugh uncomfortably while I smile so hard my molars ache.
"Some of us prefer substance over charm," I reply sweetly.
"Kids." My father's warning glance cuts between us.
"Babe, you two are hilarious!" Jade giggles, pressing closer to Caleb until she's basically wearing him. "It's like watching real siblings bicker!"
Real siblings.
The words land like ice water down my spine. I watch her manicured nails trace patterns on his forearm, watch how easily she touches him, claims him openly… and the jealousy that rises tastes like battery acid.
We end up on the same picnic blanket because the universe has a sick sense of humor. His knee presses against mine—subtle enough to look accidental, deliberate enough to make my skin burn through my jeans.
I shift away. His leg follows.
I move again. So does he.
Jade chatters about rush week and themed parties and other things that would require me to have a soul that wasn't currently being corroded by proximity to Caleb's thigh.
Every time she touches him—and she's always touching him—my jaw clenches tighter.
She doesn't know him. Doesn't know he checks the locks three times before bed. Doesn't know he still has nightmares about his father. Doesn't know he reads Bukowski when he thinks no one's watching.
And you do? My brain supplies unhelpfully.
You know him because you're obsessed, not because you matter.
After the neighbors evacuate and our parents disappear inside with wine that'll make them nostalgic and weepy, I escape to the kitchen.
Jade left an hour ago—something about a "sorority emergency" that sounded suspiciously like "I'm bored and these people are old."
I'm loading dishes into the sink when his voice reaches me.
"Thought you'd hide in here all night."
I don't turn around. "I'm cleaning up. Some of us contribute."
"Contributing." He moves closer, and I catch his reflection in the window above the sink—dangerous and beautiful in the fading light. "Is that what you call sulking in corners and shooting death glares at my girlfriend?"
"She's not your girlfriend." The words escape before I can stop them. "She's a prop. An accessory. This week's validation fix."
"Jealous much?" His smile sharpens in the glass.
"I'd rather be jealous of a yeast infection."
"Strong words." He leans against the counter beside me, arms crossed, close enough that his shoulder nearly brushes mine. "You know what I think?"
"That you're God's gift to insecure women everywhere?"
"I think," he continues, ignoring me, "you can't stand watching me with her. I think it eats you alive."
I rinse a plate with deliberate calm.
"You followed me here," I say quietly, each word precise. "I stayed for family. You could have gone anywhere—UCLA wanted you for lacrosse, Miami offered you a partial ride. But you chose here. You chose to follow me. So who's really the jealous one?"
"Maybe I just liked the school."
"Maybe you're so terrified of being alone with yourself that you need me around to torture because it's the only way you know how to feel anything real."
"Watch your fucking mouth, princess."
I set the plate in the drying rack with exaggerated care and finally turned to face him. He's ready for a fight—shoulders tense, those blue eyes dark now and that familiar pre-combat energy radiating off him.
But I'm so fucking tired of this dance.
"You know what?" The words come out exhausted rather than angry. "I feel sorry for you."
His smirk falters.
"I'm serious.” I hold his gaze, watching confusion flicker across his features. “I feel sorry for the boy whose father beat him and then abandoned him. The boy so desperate for approval he'll fuck girls who don't even know his middle name because it's easier than admitting no one's ever actually loved him for who he is."
The color drains from Caleb’s face and I see his hands curl into fists at his sides.
"Jade doesn't see you, Caleb. None of them do." I continue, my voice deadly calm. "They see the smile and the body and the charm, and that's enough for them. But you know it's not real."
I tilt my head, studying him like he's a case study in psychology textbook.
"That's why you keep cycling through them, isn't it? Because the validation never lasts. It can't fill whatever your father carved out of you."
"Shut the fuck up."
“And that works for you because if they saw the real you—the broken, desperate, terrified little boy under all that armor—they'd run. They all would. And you know it.”
His breathing has gone shallow. There's something wild in his eyes now, something wounded and dangerous.
"I'm not jealous of Jade." I pick up a dish towel and dry my hands with slow precision. "I pity her. And I pity you. You're both just going through the motions of intimacy without any idea what it actually means."
I drape the towel over his shoulder and step past him toward the door.
"The rest of the dishes are all yours. Consider it practice for all those nights you'll spend alone once the girls figure out there's nothing underneath the performance."
Swipe up to continue
The library smells like anxiety and desperation with hints of stale Red Bull—basically the official cologne of higher education.
My study group occupies our usual table near the windows. Textbooks spread across the surface like territorial claims. Mia sits across from me, allegedly writing her sociology paper but actually deep-stalking her TA's Instagram.
I know because she keeps making these tiny gasping sounds every time she scrolls past a shirtless beach photo.
"He has a dog," she whispers reverently, like she's discovered the cure for cancer. "A golden retriever named Pancake."
"Mia. Focus."
"I am focused. Focused on how that man fills out a wetsuit."
Six weeks into freshman year, and Mia is the closest thing I've ever had to a real friend. The realization still catches me off guard sometimes—this easy companionship I never learned how to want.
In high school, I couldn't afford friends. Friends meant vulnerability, and vulnerability meant giving Caleb ammunition. Every secret shared, every weakness revealed, could become a weapon in his hands.
So I stayed sharp and alone, a fortress of one.
But Mia doesn't know that girl. She just saw someone sitting alone at orientation and decided I needed adopting.
She kicks me under the table. Hard. "Ow! What?"
Another kick. Her eyes go wide, darting toward the entrance with the urgency of someone witnessing a crime.
"Look," she hisses. "But don't make it obvious."
"Mia, if this is another guy you think has 'protagonist energy'—"
"Serena. Shut up and look."
I drag my gaze toward the door, ready to dismiss whatever frat boy has caught her attention.
My pen stops moving.
Lucas Bennett is walking toward us, and apparently puberty decided to work overtime on him.
Sandy hair falls across his forehead, longer than I remember. His shoulders have broadened since high school. His jaw has sharpened into angles that catch the afternoon light.
The last time I saw Lucas, he was Caleb's perpetual shadow—always there but never quite there, you know?
The nice one who'd buffer Caleb's cruelty with distracting jokes, redirect the attention before it could land its full blow. Small kindnesses I never acknowledged because acknowledging them meant admitting I needed saving.
They stopped being friends senior year. No explanation, no drama, just sudden radio silence between two guys who'd been inseparable since middle school.
Now he's standing before me, smile easy and warm, eyes crinkling at the corners.
"Is this seat taken?" He gestures to the empty chair beside me.
I open my mouth to respond, but he's already sliding into it, dropping his backpack with casual familiarity.
"Serena Lakin." He says my name like he's been waiting to use it. "I thought that was you. How long has it been?"
"A while." My voice comes out steadier than I feel. "Since high school, at least."
"Too long." He leans back, arms crossed, studying me with undisguised interest. "I heard you were here. Pre-law, right? Of course you are. You were always terrifyingly smart."
Mia kicks me again, but gently this time. Her foot taps against mine in what I recognize as her universal signal for GET IT, GIRL.
"Pre-med for me," Lucas continues, filling the silence I'm too stunned to break. "Turns out all those years of patching up lacrosse injuries gave me a taste for it."
"You patched up lacrosse injuries?" I raise an eyebrow skeptically. "I thought you were one of the ones causing them."
His laugh is warm and unexpected, filling the space between us without demanding anything in return.
"Fair point. Maybe I was just atoning for my sins." His eyes hold mine with quiet intention. "We all have things we wish we'd done differently back then."
The statement hangs there, weighted with meaning I'm not ready to examine.
"I remember you from honors English," he adds. "You demolished everyone in that Fitzgerald debate. I was genuinely scared of you."
"Good." I feel my lips curve despite myself. "Fear is an appropriate response to literary analysis."
He grins, and the warmth of it catches me off guard.
Neither of us mentions Caleb.
The absence of his name sits between us like a third person at the table, but Lucas talks around it with practiced ease. He asks about my classes, my professors, whether I've found decent coffee on campus yet.
"The café by the humanities building is acceptable," I tell him. "Everything else tastes like it was brewed during the Reagan administration."
"A coffee snob. I respect that." His grin is criminal. "Strong opinions about beverages are a green flag."
Mia clears her throat pointedly, gathering her things with exaggerated slowness.
"Would you look at the time," she announces to absolutely no one. "I have that... thing. The urgent thing. With the people. At the place." She squeezes my shoulder as she passes. "Serena, text me everything."
She squeezes my shoulder as she passes—a small gesture that lands in my chest with unexpected weight. This is what friendship feels like, I think.
Someone who notices. Someone who makes space.
Then she's gone, leaving me alone with Lucas Bennett, his stupidly perfect jaw and the growing awareness that I'm being watched.
I don't have to turn around. I know exactly who's watching.
"So," Lucas shifts closer, and I let him, "are you going to the Halloween party next Friday? The big one at Sigma Chi. Everyone goes."
"Parties aren't really my thing." The response is automatic, reflexive.
"That's exactly why you should come." His smile is easy, uncomplicated. "College is about new experiences, right? Breaking out of old patterns?"
His teasing is gentle, without the sharp edge I've learned to brace against.
Three tables away, I feel the weight of Caleb's gaze like fingertips trailing down my spine.
I turn my head just enough to catch him in my peripheral. He's sitting alone, some textbook open in front of him that he's definitely not reading. His eyes are locked on me with an intensity that makes my stomach flip.
The look on his face isn't just anger. It's something darker, more possessive. Something that says mine even though he has no right.
Our gazes lock across the distance between us.
He doesn't look away.
Something reckless unfurls in my chest—a wild, dangerous thing I usually keep caged. Is that jealousy burning in those dark eyes?
The possibility sends heat racing through my veins like wildfire.
Two can play this game, stepbrother.
I turn back to Lucas with a smile that feels like a weapon being drawn.
"Tell me more about this party." I lean closer, close enough to catch his cologne. "What exactly makes it so unmissable?"
His face lights up, encouraged by my sudden interest.
"It's legendary, honestly. The costumes get competitive. The music is actually decent." He shifts toward me until our shoulders nearly touch. "Plus, I hear the punch is strong enough to make even pre-law students have fun."
"Bold assumption that I don't already know how to have fun."
"Prove me wrong, then." His smile widens. "Come to the party. Let me buy you a drink."
I laugh, and my hand finds his arm like it belongs there. His bicep is solid under my palm, warm and real and wonderfully uncomplicated.
"You're very confident for someone who hasn't seen me in years," I say, pitching my voice just loud enough to carry.
"Some things are worth being confident about."
Then I hear a sharp crack that cuts through the library's whispered ambiance.
Caleb's pen lies broken on his table. His hand is clenched in a fist, knuckles white, jaw tight enough to crack teeth.
He's still staring at me. At my hand on Lucas's arm. At the space between our bodies that keeps getting smaller.
"I'll think about it," I tell Lucas, but I'm not looking at him anymore.
I'm looking at Caleb as he stands abruptly, his chair scraping against the floor with a sound like nails on glass. He doesn't pack up his things. Doesn't grab the broken pen. Just turns and walks out, movements sharp with barely controlled violence.
My hand is still on Lucas's arm.
And my pulse is racing for entirely the wrong reason.
Swipe up to continue
The cruelest lies are the ones we tell ourselves about what we want.
Steam clings to my skin as I stand in front of the fogged mirror, towel wrapped tight around my body. My hair drips onto the tile floor, each drop marking time I'm wasting.
He texted again while I was in the shower. Three messages in twenty minutes.
Lucas: Can't wait to see you Friday.
Lucas: What's your costume? I'll coordinate if you want.
Lucas: You're going to have fun. I promise.
He's sweet. Persistent in a way that feels like warmth instead of pressure. Normal in a way I've forgotten people can be.
This is good. Lucas is good. Lucas is exactly what you need—Caleb without the emotional terrorism.
This is what you should want. This is what healthy looks like.
Except that's the problem, isn't it? Lucas is Diet Caleb.
Same great taste, zero psychological damage. Same broad shoulders and athlete's build, same easy confidence that comes from knowing your body can do whatever you ask of it.
But where Caleb's presence feels like a blade pressed against my throat, Lucas feels like sunlight. Safe. Uncomplicated.
A replacement, my therapist would probably call it. Redirecting unhealthy fixation toward a healthier target.
I'm not fixated on Caleb. I'm not.
But if I were, hypothetically, Lucas would be the perfect antidote. Same packaging, none of the poison.
My thumbs move across the screen as I type back.
ME: Keeping the costume a surprise. But I'll find you.
His response is instant, like he's been staring at his phone waiting:
Lucas: I'll be counting the minutes, pretty.
Pretty. He called me pretty.
A normal, sweet compliment that doesn't come with layers of mockery attached. My mouth curves into an actual, genuine smile—the kind that would probably give Caleb an aneurysm if he saw it.
This is what normal feels like. This is what I deserve.
I push open the bathroom door, eyes still on my phone, still composing a reply that sounds flirty without trying too hard.
"Well, fuck me sideways. That's a face I've never seen before."
I nearly jumped out of my skin and my towel.
My head snaps up from the screen and I see Caleb sprawl across my bed like he owns it. One arm propped behind his head, the other holding up a pair of my underwear.
The pink cotton ones with little strawberries that I bought specifically because they're the opposite of sexy.
Anti-lingerie. A monument to not giving a fuck.
"Texting lover boy with that dopey-ass smile?" His gaze flicks to my phone, then back to my face. Pathetic doesn't even begin to cover it, princess."
"What the fuck are you doing in my room?" My voice comes out steadier than my pulse, which is currently attempting to break the sound barrier. "Get. Out."
He doesn't move. His eyes travel from the underwear to me, cataloging the wet hair plastered to my shoulders, the towel that suddenly feels paper-thin.
It's a look that feels like being undressed when I'm already basically naked.
"These are tragic, Serena. Truly. Like, seek-help levels of unsexy." He reaches for my laundry basket. "Let's see what else you're hiding in here."
I cross the room in three steps and the basket tips as I shove it away from him, spilling clothes across the carpet, while my phone clatters to the floor somewhere in the chaos.
My chest heaves. I'm too aware of everything—the terry cloth barely covering me, his proximity, the way his gaze hasn't stopped tracking the lines of my body since I walked in.
"I said get out."
"Are you wearing these to the party?" He stretches the pink cotton between his fingers again, examining the strawberries with theatrical disgust. "Please say yes. I need to see Lucas's face when he discovers what's underneath."
Heat crawls up my neck and settles in my cheeks. "Give those back!"
"Granny panties with fruit on them." He whistles low. "Bold strategy for a girl trying to lose her V-card."
"I'm not trying to—" I cut myself off because engaging is exactly what he wants.
His grin widens, shark-like and satisfied.
"Oh, you're definitely trying. That dumb smile you just walked in with? The sad little hair flip in the library? Touching his arm like you learned flirting from a WikiHow article?" He tosses my underwear aside. "It's physically painful to watch."
"Get off my bed!"
"Lucas Bennett." He ignores me, leaning back against my pillows like we're having a casual chat. "That's your big play? You really think that golden retriever boy is interested in you?"
"Unlike some people, Lucas is actually capable of basic human decency."
"Lucas is capable of fucking anything with a pulse, sure. But interested?" His laugh scrapes against my nerves. "Serena. Sweetheart. Look at yourself."
The word sweetheart curdles in the air between us.
"You used to be friends with him." The observation escapes before I can stop it. "Best friends, actually. What happened?"
His expression flickers, just for a moment, before the mask slides back into place. The change is so brief I almost miss it, but I've spent too long studying his tells.
"People grow apart." His voice goes flat, carefully emptied of meaning. "It happens."
"That's not an answer."
"It's the only one you're getting." He stands abruptly, and the air in the room tightens. "Ancient history isn't really my thing."
There's a wound there, buried beneath the deflection.
I file that knowledge away for later.
"But we're not talking about me. We're talking about you and нou're going to show up in some tragic little costume and follow him around all night like a stray dog."
He swings his legs off my bed and stands, and back on familiar ground now, cruelty flowing easily.
"And he's going to ditch you the second someone hotter walks by."
"You don't know anything about—"
"I know you." He steps closer, and I hate myself for not stepping back. "Nineteen years old and never been fucked. You think that's an accident? You think guys just haven't noticed you?"
My feet root themselves to the carpet despite every instinct screaming retreat.
"They've noticed." His voice drops low, intimate in a way that feels like violation. "They're just not interested. There's nothing there to want."
Each word lands like a precision strike, designed for maximum damage.
"Lucas asked me." I force the sentence through numb lips. "Not the other way around."
"Lucas is working an angle. Probably a bet with his frat brothers." He's close now, close enough that I can smell his cologne—cedar and amber and memories I've tried to bury. "Probably wants to see if the pre-law princess is as frigid as everyone says."
I hate that I recognize this scent.
I hate that my body catalogued it without permission.
"Go ahead. Prove them right. Make a fool of yourself in front of the whole school." His smile sharpens into a blade. "Actually, do go. I could use the entertainment from stories and photos after the party."
He’s not going? At the party?
"I'd rather humiliate myself in front of everyone than spend another second with you."
"Then we're both getting what we want."
He moves past me toward the bathroom, and his shoulder connects with mine hard enough to make me stumble. The contact burns through the thin cotton of my towel.
"Wear the ugly underwear." He pauses at the threshold, not looking back. "It'll match the rest of you."
The door clicks shut behind him and I don't move for a long time.
My fingers find the strawberry underwear crumpled on the carpet, and I clutch them against my chest like armor. The cotton is warm from his hands, and I despise that I notice.
What was that look?
Right before he left—right before the bathroom door closed between us—his expression shifted into territory I didn't recognize. Not cruel. Not mocking.
Almost desperate.
I sink onto my bed, legs folding beneath me. The mattress still holds the impression of his body, still carries traces of his warmth.
When did his shoulders get so broad?
When did he become so much higher than me?
The thoughts surfaces unbidden, bringing others in its wake. The sharp new angles of his jaw. The way he moves now with a confidence that wasn't there before, predatory and assured.
I've been noticing for months, if I'm honest with myself. Cataloguing changes in his body the way I catalogue his footsteps through walls.
My fingers twist in the pink cotton, knuckles going white.
Get out of my head, Thornton.
Get out.
GET. OUT.
Swipe up to continue