"Inside," Tobias breathes against my mouth, pulling back just enough to speak. "Not here."
He takes my hand and I follow him through the dark house, both of us moving quietly past closed doors.
My heart pounds so hard I'm sure it'll wake someone. We reach his bedroom and he closes the door behind us, turning the lock with a soft click that sounds like a decision being made.
Soft lamplight casts golden shadows across the room. He turns to face me, and for a moment we just stand there, breathing hard, the weight of what we're about to do settling over us.
He crosses to me slowly, deliberately, then frames my face with both hands. "Look at me. Tell me you're sure."
"If you don't touch me right now, I might actually die."
"Such a dramatic little thing," he murmurs, but his control is already fraying. His thumb traces my bottom lip and I catch it between my teeth, watching his pupils dilate. "You have no idea what you've been doing to me, do you?"
"Show me."
Something snaps in his expression. The composed, respectable Tobias Murphy I've known for years disappears, replaced by someone raw and hungry.
His hands move to the zipper of my still-damp dress, drawing it down with agonizing slowness. His knuckles brush each vertebra and I shiver.
"Five years of watching you grow into this incredible woman," he says roughly. "Of telling myself you were too young, too innocent, too connected to my family."
The dress pools at my feet, leaving me in just underwear. His eyes rake over me and his hands visibly shake. "Fuck, Ava."
The curse on his lips makes heat flood through me. This is Tobias unleashed, without his perfect control.
"Do you know how many cold showers I've taken?"
His hands slide up my ribs, thumbs brushing the undersides of my breasts. "How many meetings I've sat through, trying not to think about you in those little skirts? That black one you wore last week—Christ, I had to excuse myself twice."
"I wore it for you," I confess, gasping as his mouth finds my neck. "I always dress for you."
He groans against my skin. "You're going to kill me."
Then he's everywhere at once—mouth on my throat, hands unclasping my bra with practiced ease. When his palms finally cover my breasts, skin to skin, we both moan.
He backs me toward the bed, laying me down like something precious before standing back to look at me.
"So fucking beautiful," he breathes, pulling his shirt over his head.
I've imagined this moment countless times, but the reality is overwhelming. His chest is broad, defined, with a scattering of dark hair. There's a scar along his ribs I want to ask about, want to trace with my tongue.
He joins me on the bed, his weight pressing me into the mattress as he kisses me again, deeper this time. His hand slides down my stomach, fingers slipping under the edge of my panties. When he touches me properly for the first time, I arch off the bed.
He works my body with shocking expertise, like he's studied exactly how to unravel me. His mouth follows the path of his hands, neck, breasts, stomach, until he's pulling my underwear down and settling between my thighs.
The first touch of his tongue makes me cry out, hands fisting in his hair.
"Quiet, baby," he says, but doesn't stop what he's doing. "Don't want to wake anyone."
I bite my lip hard, trying to muffle the sounds as he takes me apart with methodical precision. The pressure builds impossibly fast, and when I shatter, he has to cover my mouth with his hand to muffle my scream.
He watches my face with dark satisfaction as I come down, trembling.
"That's one," he says, crawling back up my body. "I'm going to make you come apart so many times you forget every reason this is wrong."
"Please," I breathe, pulling him down for a kiss, tasting myself on his tongue.
He stands to remove his pants, and I see all of him for the first time. He's perfect—all controlled power and masculine beauty. When he settles back between my thighs, the weight of him against me makes us both pause.
"Ava." His voice is strained. "This might hurt, baby. Tell me if you need me to stop."
"Don't you dare."
He pushes inside slowly, so slowly, watching my face for any sign of pain. There's a sharp stretch, a burning that makes me tense, and he immediately stops.
"Breathe," he coaches, pressing kisses to my face. "Just breathe. We have all night."
He distracts me with deep kisses, whispered praise, gentle touches, until my body relaxes enough for him to move deeper. When he's finally fully inside me, we both go still, overwhelmed by the connection.
"You okay?" he asks, voice wrecked.
"Perfect," I breathe. "You can move."
He starts with slow, careful strokes, letting me adjust. But as the discomfort fades into pleasure, I need more. I wrap my legs around his waist, pulling him deeper, and he groans.
"Ava, fuck…"
"More," I demand. "I need more."
His control snaps completely. The rhythm builds from careful to desperate, five years of suppressed desire unleashed. He hooks one of my legs over his shoulder, changing the angle, and I see stars.
"Look at me," he commands when my eyes flutter closed. "I want to see you when you come again."
His hand finds that sensitive spot between us, circling in time with his thrusts, and the dual sensation is overwhelming. The pressure builds impossibly higher until I shatter again, harder this time, my whole body convulsing.
He follows immediately, my name on his lips as he comes.
We collapse together, breathing hard, sweat cooling on our skin. He pulls me against his chest, pressing kisses to my hair.
"Sleep," he murmurs. "We'll deal with everything tomorrow."
I drift off in his arms, feeling complete for the first time in my life.
***
Dawn is just breaking when I wake, disoriented. Tobias's arm is heavy across my waist, his breath warm against my neck. For a moment, I let myself pretend this is normal, that I can wake up like this every morning.
I shift slightly to look at him. In sleep, all the careful control is gone from his face. He looks younger, peaceful. The early morning light catches the silver at his temples, and I can't resist reaching out to brush a strand of dark hair from his forehead.
His eyes flutter open, hazel and warm, crinkling at the corners as he focuses on me.
"Good morning," he murmurs, voice rough with sleep. His hand comes up to cup my cheek. "How are you feeling? Are you sore? Did I hurt you last night?" His thumb strokes my cheekbone. "I tried to be gentle, but…"
"You were perfect," I whisper, feeling my face heat. "I'm a little sore, but it's a good kind of—"
A sharp knock makes us both jolt awake.
"Dad? Are you awake?"
Chloe. Oh God, Chloe.
Pure panic shoots through my veins. We both freeze for a split second before Tobias launches out of bed, grabbing pajama pants from the floor. He gestures frantically at me to hide, and I scramble off the bed, still naked, clutching the sheet.
"Just a second, sweetheart," he calls, voice strained as he pulls on the pants.
I press myself against the wall beside the door, heart hammering so hard I'm sure Chloe will hear it.
The sheet slips slightly and I gasp, about to whisper that I need my clothes, when Tobias crosses to me in two quick strides. His hand clamps over my mouth, his eyes intense with warning before opening the door.
"Morning," he says, opening it just enough to block any view into the room. His palm is still firm against my lips. "Everything okay?"
"Yeah, I just... Have you seen Ava? She's not in my room and her car's still here."
This is it, I think wildly. This is how she finds out I fucked her father. Naked in his bedroom, his hand over my mouth, looking thoroughly debauched.
We're so screwed.
Swipe up to continue
I hold my breath, terrified she'll push past him, discover me naked in her father's bedroom. If it weren't for Tobias's hand, which was still powerfully squeezing my mouth, I would have definitely groaned in despair.
"I drove her home late last night," Tobias lies smoothly. "You have already passed out."
"Oh." Chloe sounds relieved. "That makes sense. Thanks for taking care of her, Dad."
"She will be okay." His voice softens. "You should text her later, check in."
"I will. Sorry to bother you."
"Never a bother, sweetheart."
The door closes with a soft click. We both stay frozen for several long seconds, listening to Chloe's footsteps retreat down the hall. Only when we hear her bedroom door close do we both exhale.
Tobias turns to look at me, and in the harsh morning light, the full reality of what we've done crashes over us. I'm standing naked in his bedroom, covered in his marks, having just lost my virginity to my best friend's father. My ex-boyfriend's father.
"Oh God," I whisper, starting to shake. "Oh God, what did we—"
"Hey, breathe." He crosses to me, cupping my face. "It's okay."
"It's not okay! Chloe almost…" I pull away, scrambling to find my clothes. My dress is wrinkled and still slightly damp from the pool. My underwear is somewhere in the sheets. "I have to go." I spot the window. "I'll go that way."
"Absolutely not. That's a twelve-foot drop."
"There's a trellis." I'm already pulling my dress over my head, not bothering with underwear. "I'll be fine."
"Ava, this is insane."
But I'm already pushing open the window, adrenaline making me reckless. "I can't walk through the house. What if someone sees me?"
"Then wait until…"
"I can't stay here!" The words come out too sharp, too panicked. I can see they hurt him, but I can't stop. I swing one leg over the windowsill.
"Ava, please, just wait—"
I'm already climbing out, barefoot, dress bunched in one hand as I navigate the trellis. It holds my weight for the first few feet, then I hear an ominous crack. My grip slips, and I fall the last three feet directly into his prized rose bushes.
"Fuck!" I hiss as thorns tear at my dress, scratch my legs.
"Are you okay?" Tobias's voice carries from the window, full of concern.
I pop up from the bushes, dress torn, hair full of rose petals, legs bleeding from tiny cuts.
I give him a mortified thumbs up, then take off running barefoot across the manicured lawn like an absolute lunatic, leaving the man I love shaking his head at the window, probably wondering what the hell he's gotten himself into.
***
My computer screen blurs as I stare at the same email for the fifth time, unable to process a single word. How am I supposed to work if my head is not?
"You look like hell."
I jump, nearly knocking over my coffee. Chloe stands beside my desk, arms crossed, studying me with those sharp eyes.
"Thanks. Really feeling the love."
"I'm serious, Ava. You haven't answered any of my texts, you're wearing your emergency concealer, the thick one, and you just jumped like I was a serial killer."
She perches on my desk, ignoring my attempt to look busy. "How about girl’s night at my place tonight?"
My stomach drops to my feet. "Chloe, I really don't think…"
"Tyler's staying at his friend's." She leans forward, concern replacing her usual snark. "It'll just be us, ice cream, and trash TV."
The genuine care in her voice makes guilt twist like a knife in my chest. Some best friend I am, sleeping with her father hours after she held me while I cried.
"I'll think about it, okay?"
I already know I'll turn the offer down. I simply can't show up at the Murphy house, can't sit on the same couch where everything started, can't pretend I don't know exactly what Tobias's bedroom ceiling looks like.
After Chloe leaves, I become an expert at avoidance.
I take the stairs instead of the elevator. Chart alternate routes to the bathroom that don't pass his office. Time my lunch break for when he has conference calls. Check the meeting room schedules obsessively to avoid any chance encounters.
For most of the day, it works. I manage to get through the morning without seeing him once, though I feel his presence like electricity in the air. Every time someone mentions his name, my body reacts—pulse racing, skin flushing.
By three o'clock, I think I might actually make it through the entire day. I'm reviewing documents in the supply closet-turned-filing room, the one place I know he never goes, when the door clicks shut behind me.
"You can't keep running from me."
"I'm not running." I keep my back to him, gripping the folder in my hands. "I'm working."
"Bullshit." The profanity surprises me—daytime Tobias rarely swears. Professional Tobias never does. "Every time I enter a room, you leave. You won't even look at me in meetings. You had Jordan deliver the grant proposal instead of bringing it yourself."
"Maybe I'm just being professional. Maintaining appropriate boundaries."
He laughs, but there's no humor in it. "Appropriate boundaries? Is that what we're calling this?"
He moves closer, and I back against the filing cabinet, finally forced to face him. He looks wrecked—tie loose, hair mussed, dark circles under his eyes that match mine.
"What do you want me to say?" The words burst out of me. "That I destroyed everything for one night? That I can't look at you because I'm disgusted with myself?"
His hands come up to bracket me against the cabinet, not touching but close enough that I can feel his body heat, smell his cologne. My treacherous body responds immediately, remembering exactly how those hands felt on my skin.
"Do you know what torture it's been?" His voice drops lower, rougher. "Sitting in those meetings, pretending I don't know exactly how you taste? Watching you avoid me like I'm something shameful?"
"Wrong. It was wrong, Tobias."
"Was it wrong when you begged me not to stop? When you said you'd wanted it for years?"
Heat floods my face. "That's not fair."
He leans closer, his breath fanning across my cheek. "Do you think I don't know how complicated this is? Do you think I haven't thought through every consequence? But I can't pretend it didn't happen. I can't pretend I don't want it to happen again."
"Tobias…"
"Tell me you don't think about it," he challenges. "Tell me you don't want this and I—"
Voices in the hallway, getting closer. "Mr. Murphy? The governor's office is on line two."
He steps back so fast I feel cold, his professional mask sliding into place instantly. Not a hair out of place, no sign of the intensity that was burning in his eyes seconds ago.
"Be right there," he calls, voice perfectly normal.
He looks at me one more time, and the heat in his gaze makes my knees weak. "This conversation isn't over."
Then he's gone, leaving me pressed against the filing cabinet, breathing hard, body aching for something I can never have again.
The ache between my thighs is even worse, the memory of how perfectly he filled me, how right it felt to fall apart in his arms. I press my legs together, hating myself for wanting him even now, even knowing how impossible this is.
Swipe up to continue
I shove files into my bag with unnecessary force, one eye on the elevator, praying it doesn't ding.
It's 4:47 PM—if I can just make it thirteen more minutes, I can escape without seeing him. My body still throbs from our encounter in the filing room, his words echoing: "This conversation isn't over."
"Ready?" Chloe appears at my desk, already with her bag and car keys. "I need to get out of here before I commit patricide."
"Patricide is killing your father," I correct automatically, standing. "You mean fratricide."
"Whatever. Murder. Of Tyler." She links her arm through mine as we head for the stairs. "Speaking of which, if that asshole tries to contact you, don't even read the messages. Just block and delete."
"Already did."
"Good. You deserve someone who actually shows up, Ava. Someone who puts you first."
She pushes open the stairwell door. "Tyler's always been selfish. Remember sophomore year when he promised to help with your mom's birthday party then bailed for a frat party?"
"Can we not do the greatest hits of Tyler's failures?" I ask as we descend. "I'd like to maintain some dignity."
"Dignity? Babe, you drunk-swam in your dress two nights ago. That ship has sailed."
Despite everything, I laugh. "Thanks for the reminder."
We push through the exit door into the parking lot, and my laughter dies instantly. Tyler's leaning against my car, looking like he hasn't slept in days—stubble, wrinkled clothes, red eyes that lock onto mine immediately.
"We need to talk."
"Absolutely fucking not." Chloe steps in front of me. "Move, bitch."
"This is between me and my girlfriend."
"Ex-girlfriend," I correct, voice tight. "We're done, Tyler."
"Ava, please." He pushes off the car, moving closer. "Just give me five minutes."
"She doesn't owe you shit," Chloe snaps. "Get out of the way."
"This doesn't concern you, Chloe. Fuck off already."
"My best friend concerns me. Now move before I call security, dickface."
I try to step around him to my car door, but he blocks me, desperation bleeding into anger. "You're not even going to let me explain? Three years, Ava. Three years together and I don't get five minutes?"
"You got months with Megan, apparently." My voice comes out steadier than I feel. "That's more than enough."
"That was a mistake." He runs a hand through his hair, agitated. "She means nothing. She's always been throwing herself at me, and I was drunk, and…"
"Oh, so it's her fault now?" Chloe laughs harshly. "Classic Tyler. Nothing's ever your responsibility."
"Stay the fuck out of this, Chloe!"
"Don't talk to her like that." My anger flares. "Don't you dare take this out on your own sister."
"I'm trying to talk to you! To fix this!" His voice rises, drawing stares from people leaving the building. "You're the one I want, Ava. You're the one I choose."
"You chose Megan. On my birthday." I try to push past him. "Now move."
He grabs my arm, not hard, but enough to stop me. "You can't just throw us away without even listening—"
"Let go of her." The voice cuts through the parking lot like ice.
Tobias stands ten feet away, still in his suit from meetings, looking every inch the composed administrator except for his eyes. They're focused on Tyler's hand on my arm with an intensity that makes my stomach flip.
"Someone alerted you?" Tyler drops my arm, turning to face his father. "Of course. Can't have a family conversation without Dad swooping in."
"This isn't a conversation." Tobias moves closer, positioning himself slightly between Tyler and me. "It's harassment."
"She's my girlfriend—"
"Ex," I interject.
"—and we're having a private discussion."
"In a public parking lot, after she's clearly asked you to leave." Tobias's voice remains calm, but I can see the tension in his shoulders, the way his hands clench slightly. "Step away from her car."
"Dad, this is none of your…"
"I said step away."
The air crackles with tension. Tyler glares at his father, something unspoken passing between them that makes my chest tight. For a moment, I think Tyler might actually swing at him.
"This is bullshit," Tyler finally spits, stepping aside. "You always take everyone's side but mine."
"I take the side of whoever's not acting like an ass," Tobias replies evenly.
I exhale, fumbling for my keys, ready to escape this nightmare…
"Well. Isn't this cozy."
Everyone freezes. A sleek black Town Car pulls into the administrative parking lot, and stepping out of it is a woman I've only seen in photos. Elegant, polished, looking like she stepped out of a fashion magazine despite the mundane setting.
Veronica Tucker. Tobias's ex-wife.
She removes her designer sunglasses, surveying the scene with sharp amusement. "Having a family meeting without me?"
"Mom?" Chloe's voice drops to arctic temperatures. "What the hell are you doing here?"
"Is that any way to greet your mother?" Veronica's smile doesn't reach her eyes. "Though I see manners are generally lacking today."
"Veronica." Tobias's entire demeanor changes, warmth replaced by something guarded and cold. "You should have called."
"And miss this charming welcome? I think not." Her gaze lands on me, assessing. "I don't believe we've met. You must be one of Chloe's friends."
"This is Ava," Tyler interjects, moving closer to his mother. "My girlfriend."
"Ex," Chloe and I say in unison.
Veronica's perfectly shaped eyebrow arches. "How interesting. The ‘ex-girlfriend’ causing all this commotion?"
"I was just leaving," I manage, voice small under her scrutiny.
"Don't rush off on my account." She steps closer, and I catch a whiff of expensive perfume. "I'm Veronica Tucker. I'm sure my family has mentioned me."
The way she says 'my family' feels proprietary, like marking territory. I glance at Tobias, whose jaw has tightened further.
"What are you doing here, Veronica?" he asks.
"I heard about your campaign for governor. Impressive." She turns back to him, dismissing me entirely. "A campaign like that needs family unity. A strong support system. I thought I'd offer my expertise."
"We don't need…" Chloe starts.
"I wasn't asking you, darling."
Veronica's voice remains pleasant, but there's steel underneath. "I'll be spending quite a bit of time here at the administration, Tobias. Your campaign needs a family presence, and I have some ideas about modernizing your image. We have so much to discuss."
"This isn't the time or place," Tobias says carefully.
"Oh, I think it's perfect. Tyler, you look terrible. Come, we'll have dinner and discuss your future." She glances at me again, calculating. "You should probably run along, dear. This is family business now."
The dismissal stings more than it should. I fumble with my keys again, desperate to escape.
"Ava…" Tobias starts, then stops, unable to say whatever he wanted with his ex-wife watching.
"I really do need to go," I mumble, finally getting my door open.
As I pull out of the parking lot, I see them in my rearview mirror—Tobias and Veronica facing off, Chloe looking murderous, Tyler gravitating toward his mother like he always does when he needs an ally.
Whatever happened between Tobias and me has to stay buried. Not just because of Chloe or Tyler, but because Veronica Tucker just looked at me like I was a problem to be solved.
And something tells me she's very good at solving problems.
Swipe up to continue