[Renet's POV]
"Are you still depressed and self-medicating with illegal substances, Mr. Carter?"
The recorder between us catches every syllable. Good. My magazine sent me to write a puff piece on the NHL's newest golden boy: a reputation-laundering fluff job before his big brand deal.
And Henry Carter has no idea that the woman sitting across from him is the same girl he bullied into eating lunch alone for an entire semester of senior year.
He doesn't recognize me. That's the best part.
Seven years ago I was five-foot-nothing with frizzy hair and braces, invisible enough that even the cafeteria ladies forgot my name. Henry Carter and his hockey buddies made sure I was visible just long enough to humiliate.
I spent every year since rebuilding from scratch. New body, new career, new spine. Same fury, same hard drive full of his digital skeletons: finsta screenshots, his mother's accidentally-posted prescription receipts, seven years of dirt in neat little folders.
I'm also his biggest anonymous hater online. The account that rips him apart under every post. And he's sitting three feet from me without a clue.
He blinks just once, slow and confused, and god, he got hotter since school. Broader jaw, sharper cheekbones, same stupid brown eyes that make my pulse hammer.
And then the mask slips back on. The corner of his mouth tugs up into a devastating smile. That probably is the reason his reputation needs some whitening: too many girls, too many broken hearts.
I wanna wipe that smirk off your ugly mug.
"That's a hell of a question." He leans back in his chair, relaxed and nonchalant. I track his protruding veins, and look away immediately. "Where'd you even get that information from?"
"From trusted sources." I hold his gaze and keep my pen still. Steady hands, steady voice. The girl who used to stammer in his presence is buried under years of hard work and therapy.
"You have great sources then, I guess." He rolls the water bottle between his palms. "To answer your question, no. Never was, really."
Liar, I think as bitterness and hurt rises in my throat. He's always been a liar, it seems, unnecessarily cruel and impulsive.
I smile and write something meaningless in my notebook. Let him think he's winning. "Your former teammates described your high school years as 'turbulent.' Would you say that's accurate?"
He purses his lips momentarily and immediately forces himself to relax. I've watched this face on live broadcasts of hockey games and in comment sections long enough to read every micro-expression he makes.
I'm hitting too close to home, and he doesn't want me to know it.
"I'd say every teenager's life is turbulent." His voice stays easy, lightweight. He pauses for a second, runs his hand through his dark curly hair, then smirks again. "Mine wasn't special. Wouldn't you say the same about yours?"
Fucking bastard. It was you who made my teenage life turbulent, and you know that damn well.
"I'd say some of us had it worse than others." I flip to a fresh page instead. "Multiple reports link your name to substance-related incidents during senior year. Your school nearly expelled you. Care to comment?"
"Those reports are inaccurate, unverified, and honestly? A little boring." He uncaps the water bottle, drinks and takes his time. "Sounds like you've been reading my favorite online critic. Comments under every post, really committed to the bit."
My pulse kicks up, but I keep my expression bored. I wait three seconds before I speak. "Sounds like you've got a fan."
"More like a stalker." He laughs, shaking his head, genuinely amused. "Anonymous account, posts under everything I do. Knows things about me that even my agent doesn't. My manager thinks it's some bored teenager. I think it's funnier than that."
My heartbeat fastens in stupid anxiety and rage. There's no way he'd know, but my body acts like he knows already. And the fact that he treats it like a punchline makes me want to reach across this table and break his perfect nose.
"Okay-okay, moving on." Henry finally relents, holds up both his hands, and my eyes track the length of his fingers. The hell are you looking at, Renet? "Ask me something nicer and maybe I'll be nicer back."
I will myself to look him in the eyes.
"The Orion sponsorship." I pivot fast because I need him relaxed for the paragraphs I'll write later. "Rumors are everywhere. A big nutrition brand and a new hockey star. Their last guy got dropped after DV charges, so now they're shopping for a new face. Official or not?"
"Not yet, but we're close." His eyes light up, the brown warmer than it has been. "But I'm honored, I really am. You know how important proper nutrition is, especially for athletes. To be the face of such a big brand means a lot."
Except you won't get it.
Three months ago Henry was caught sneaking out of a club with a model while his influencer girlfriend livestreamed her heartbreak to two million followers. The internet ate him alive, sponsors started ghosting, and now this interview is supposed to be his redemption arc. Because companies like Orion don't appreciate scandals.
"Big opportunity, too." He shifts forward, elbows on his knees. "For both of us, right? Cover story for your magazine, clean image for my sponsors. Everybody wins."
Everybody except you once I write what a piece of shit you actually are, Henry.
"So you need me to make you look good?"
I know the answer, but having him say it out loud, on the record, is even better than knowing.
"I need you to tell the truth." He holds my gaze one beat too long. I don't blink, don't look away, because breaking first is losing. "The truth looks pretty good on me, Renet."
My name in his mouth drags down my spine like a nail. I feel every single vertebra light up before I can shut it down.
Of course he knows my name. His manager would've sent it over with the press briefing. It doesn't mean he remembers me. Relax.
Except I remember him saying my name with so much warmth that it settled into my chest, and I swallowed it like an idiot. For a moment I believed we could genuinely be friends, or even something more.
And I remember the cruelty too. How he'd call my name across the school halls the way you'd call a dog that pissed on the carpet. Daring me to turn around so he could make me wish I hadn't.
I flinched with my whole body back then. I don't flinch now. "I'll be the judge of that."
"I'm counting on it." He winks, actually winks. Fucking show off.
I close my notebook with a snap and shift to wrap-up questions. Five more minutes of easy material, and I am good to go.
The article will gut him.
"Thank you for the interview, Mr. Carter. That's all." I stand and tuck the recorder into my bag. My heels click on the tile as I organize my things, already composing the lede in my head, when his voice comes from too close behind me.
"Renet?"
His voice hits the back of my neck first, and every hair on my arms stands up. I turn and up closer he's even more devastating. Towering over me that I need to crook my head back, hands in his pockets and head slightly tilted. The same tilt, the same brown eyes, almost the same height that made me feel small in hallways.
"You've changed a lot since high school," he says quietly.
I freeze on the spot, my hands gripping the straps of my bag.
He remembers me, he remembers me, he remembers me… He recognized me. Fuck!
Swipe up to continue
[Henry's POV]
When she freezes, I realize I've miscalculated. Idiot.
'You've changed a lot since high school' was supposed to land as a compliment, maybe even an olive branch. But Renet Giles is staring at me with her mouth open.
And I'm staring too, because the girl I remember was hiding her pretty curves from others under oversized clothes and flinched when people looked at her.
Dark blonde hair skimming her shoulders. Pencil skirt that's been ruining my concentration for the last forty minutes. She kept crossing and uncrossing her legs while she asked me about drug abuse, and I lost track of my own answer twice.
Her collarbones are sharp under the studio light, and her mouth does this thing when she's not satisfied with my response, a tiny press of the lips that I've been clocking.
She's annoyingly, distractingly hot, and she's holding a recorder with my name on it.
Her fingers go white around the straps of her bag.
I don't get it. She spent half this interview poking at my high school years, so it's not like she forgot we went to the same school. Why is she looking at me like that?
"I didn't think you recognized me." Renet finally replies, after clearing her throat and pushing her hair back. "Thanks, I guess. Would that be all, Mr. Carter?"
Didn't think I recognized her? Does she think I'm fucking blind?
I cock an eyebrow questioningly, but she doesn't seem interested in explaining, already turning away to leave before I even have a chance to push.
"Let me take you to dinner." The words leave my mouth smoothly. "Somewhere nice, off the record."
And now she'll blush and stammer before finally saying yes. All of them do.
Because I'm Henry Carter. I'm the captain, the star of the team, five magazine covers this year, and a smile my publicist once called annoyingly effective. Women don't say 'no' to me.
"That's a generous offer." She adjusts the strap on her shoulder. Her face doesn't change; her voice is level. I don't even notice the slightest redness on her face. "But I don't mix personal and professional. I'm sure you understand."
What the hell?
I freeze on the spot and look over her again and again, searching for a crack in her facade and not finding any.
Did she just… reject me?
"Come on, it's just dinner." I keep my voice light and easy. "Two old classmates catching up. No recorders."
"We're not old classmates. We're a journalist and a subject." She zips her bag shut with a clean, final sound. "Have a good evening, Mr. Carter."
Mr. Carter.
She's doing it on purpose. She knows me well enough as Henry, but she chooses to be difficult.
"At least think about it." I try the grin, the one that closes deals and gets phone numbers on cocktail napkins. "One dinner. You pick the place."
"I don't need your permission to pick a restaurant." She meets my eyes, and the look is so steady and completely unmoved, that my confidence does stutter. "Goodbye, Henry."
She turns and walks toward the door, posture perfect. My eyes follow her: the sway of her hips, the way her skirt shifts against her thighs with every step, the straight line of her back. I'm still looking when the door closes.
Get a grip, Carter. She just told you no.
This is impossible. Absolutely unbelievable.
I recognized her the second she walked in for the interview. Different hairstyle, different body, different energy, but I still knew. The freckle below her left ear, the tilt of her chin, those stunning blue eyes—that stayed.
And I expected worse from her, honestly.
One day she went to the principal back in school and ran her mouth. About the weed that helped me relax, about Mom's pills in my locker that was the only thing that stopped my brain from self-destruction, about secret parties.
All of that nearly cost me my spot on the team, my scholarship, my escape from the shit of the family I was part of. My future. Everything.
Everyone knew it was her. My ex Marissa saw and heard everything.
I spent a semester making Renet miserable for what she did to me, so I'd braced for an ambush now. But aside from a few sharp questions she kept it clean. Almost gentle when she steered toward lighter topics because I bet she could tell I was tense.
So the scoreboard reads: Carter zero, Giles two.
She got my guard down without me noticing and turned me down without breaking a sweat. At this rate she'll have my PIN code by Thursday.
My phone buzzes on the table. I grab it and drop into the chair, scrolling past texts from my manager Dave, and ones from my annoying teammate Briggs asking if the interviewer was hot.
But at the bottom of my DMs sits my favorite parasite. A message from the anonymous hater account.
Came in just seconds before the interview.
Burninhell: Saw the announcement. Can't wait for this interview to expose your ass. Fingers crossed the journalist has a spine to expose everything.
Me: Dreaming never hurt anyone. Keep at it, champ!
I snort, hitting send. The reply is instant, three dots bouncing, then:
Burninhell: Don't need to dream, Carter. You're one bad headline away from selling protein shakes at mall kiosks.
I almost smile. Whoever this is, they've been at it for years: every post, every game, every announcement gets a comment dripping with venom. My manager begs me to block them, but I can't. Something about our consistency is almost comforting.
My phone rings, and the name on the screen kills whatever's left of my amusement.
Dave.
I pick up on the second ring.
"How'd it go?" Wire-tight voice, all business and absolutely no fun. "She ask anything problematic?"
"She brought up high school." I stare at the ceiling. "Depression, substances, the whole greatest hits."
"Henry." He genuinely sounds like my mom when he says my name like that. Except I'm not shivering in my boots anymore. "Tell me you handled it…"
"Denied everything, stayed charming and cocky." I spin the water bottle cap on the table. "She backed off, moved to the Orion stuff."
"Good." I hear the click of his pen. "Orion's board meets Friday. Sponsorship is greenlit pending the article: positive coverage, clean image. That's the deal, remember? No more scandals or the sponsorship is off the table."
Of course I fucking remember.
Almost a month of me being a saint. No clubs, no girls, no late nights. No doing anything that helps with distraction. Not anything that makes the darkness stay in the back of my mind or this whole career worth having in the first place.
I've been playing hockey since I was six. I bled for it, broke bones for it, lost a family over it. And now the reward is sitting in my apartment alone eating chicken breast and pretending I don't exist outside the rink.
"So I need her to write nice things about me." I close my eyes and pinch the bridge of my nose. "Shouldn't be hard. I'm very likable."
Except for Renet Giles apparently.
"You're occasionally likable and frequently a liability." Not even a courtesy laugh. "Three more weeks, Henry. No headlines and you'll be good."
"I'm always a saint, Dave." I say it deadpan, leaning back until the chair creaks under me. Already bracing.
"You're never a saint. That's why we need the damn article." He pauses, and the sharpness drains out, replaced by tiredness. "This isn't just money, Henry. It's your brand, your team, and frankly, my mortgage. Don't screw it up."
He hangs up without goodbye. That means he's genuinely scared, and Dave scared is a bad omen for everyone.
I set the phone down and stare at the wall. Thinking about her.
I know I bullied her in high school, I'm not proud of it exactly. But she deserved my despise at the time for what she did to me, so I figured we should've been even.
She tried to torch my future, I made her last semester hell, then we graduated and went separate ways. Life goes on, right?
Except the woman I met today didn't look like someone who considers us even.
What if she hasn't forgiven anything?
Swipe up to continue