[Renet's POV]
* Present time *
Burninhell: So how does it feel to sit across from a journalist who's smarter than you?
I hit send and pull up the interview transcript on my laptop. My apartment is quiet—just the fridge humming and two screens glowing. One for the article that will end Henry Carter, one for the chat where I watch the fucker squirm.
I'm not one to toot my own horn, but I just can't resist the temptation.
Now you're the show off. Cut it off.
HenryCarterOfficial: bold of you to assume she's smarter than me
HenryCarterOfficial: but she was definitely prettier than expected though
My fingers freeze over the keyboard.
Prettier than expected. He's talking about me to me, and the compliment crawls under my skin. My face heats up, and thank the universe he can't possibly see it.
Oh god, fucking men. I would've been surprised if he noticed literally anything else.
Burninhell: Of course that's what you noticed. A woman asks you real questions and all you're looking at is her face and tits
HenryCarterOfficial: i noticed plenty: she's sharp, tougher than I thought she'd be
My chest squeezes momentarily from the absence of sarcasm or deflection, feels with warmth from the compliment. But I swallow it before it can settle.
This is the same guy who called me Braceface in front of the entire east corridor, weaponizing the ammunition from other people, those who didn't give me any hope and shared their secrets with me.
Burninhell: Tougher than you thought?
Burninhell: Wow, your bar for women must be underground
HenryCarterOfficial: why do you hate me so much?
HenryCarterOfficial: genuine question, been trying to figure it out for months
The question blinks on my screen and my throat tightens with anger.
Because you took the only person who trusted you and crushed her.
Because you're a complete dick, and you deserve to know that.
I want to type it so badly my hands tremble above the keys, but that would hand him the map straight to my front door. I swallow the truth and let my thumbs pick something else.
The truth can wait: I'm a journalist, and I know damn well how to manipulate information. Not that I'm going to. I'm an honest person.
Burninhell: Maybe I just have taste.
HenryCarterOfficial: taste in what? ragebaiting athletes on a tuesday night?
Burninhell: Someone has to keep your ego from reaching orbit.
HenryCarterOfficial: see, that's the thing, my little stalker
HenryCarterOfficial: you actually make me laugh. most haters are boring
HenryCarterOfficial: seriously though. what do you look like? I bet you're hot. angry people are usually hot
He's… flirting with me? With the anonymous account that drags him under every post, every game highlight, every sponsorship announcement? He asked me on a date four hours ago, and now he's charming the faceless stranger who tears him apart for sport?
Both of them are me, of course, but he has no idea.
I sit back and press my knuckles against my mouth. The irony is so absurd it's almost funny, except nothing about Henry Carter has ever been funny to me for years.
Burninhell: I'm not here to entertain you, Carter.
HenryCarterOfficial: and yet you keep replying ;)
HenryCarterOfficial: alright then. sleep well, little stalker
My phone buzzes before I can think of something cruel enough. My editor's name fills the notification bar, and I close the chat immediately switching to Colleen Webb in seconds.
"Renet!" Colleen's voice is warm through the speaker, half-laughing already. "How's my favorite workaholic doing?"
"I'm here, I'm here." I tuck my legs under me on the couch and drag the laptop closer, the draft of two pathetic paragraphs glaring at me. "The Carter interview went well. Could've gone better, but he gave me enough to start."
"Define 'enough.'" She swallows audibly. "Because 'enough' from you usually means you've already got the guy half-undressed on the page."
"He denied everything about high school, pivoted to Orion whenever I pushed too hard." I scroll through my notes, past the timestamps and the shorthand only I can decode. "He's media-trained, but sloppy about it. There are gaps."
"Gaps are good. Gaps are where the story lives." I hear her shift in her chair, probably pulling her feet up onto the seat. "So what's the plan? One sit-down won't cut it for a person piece this big."
Her voice is practical now, editor-mode kicking in under all that warmth.
"I'll need multiple sessions, shadow him at a game or two, talk to people in his circle."
My voice stays steady, professional. My pulse ticks up anyway, because more sessions means more time near Henry Carter.
"I want this to feel dimensional," I add, before she can jump in. "Not just a Q&A with a pretty face slapped on the cover."
"Love that. Seriously, love it!" Colleen's enthusiasm is genuine, and I feel a pang of guilt so brief I almost miss it.
It's definitely not going to be what you expect…
But he's also the one who's gonna suffer the most.
"Timeline-wise, we've got about six weeks before this needs to go to layout." Her voice shifts practical again. "That enough for your masterpiece, or should I start biting my nails now?"
"Six weeks is plenty," I assure her, and it is.
It is enough to write a good article about the guy you barely know.
It's especially enough to write a reputation-ruining article for the guy who made your high school hell for no reason. I promised myself in the mirror countless times that I'll get him ruined, because that's what he deserves.
And I promised that I won't stop at nothing, and if it comes with a career boost? Even better. Fuck this guy.
The only downside is the six weeks of proximity to Henry Carter that I'd rather avoid.
Needs must, Renet. Be a big girl about it.
"Your preliminary notes have real cover potential, and I don't say that lightly." She pauses, and her voice goes softer. "I'm proud of you for landing this one. Don't overthink it."
"It's not a big deal, Colleen." I force a lightness I don't feel, because it absolutely is a big deal. The biggest since that day in the hallway, and my pulse already skyrocketed, while I barely started. "I'll deliver something worth the cover. Promise."
"I know you will. That's why I picked you." She says it simply, no fanfare, and the trust in it sits heavier than any pep talk. "Go get some sleep, okay? You sound wired."
She hangs up before I can argue, and the quiet floods back into the apartment.
I set the phone on the cushion and pull up the chat window with a weird anticipation in my gut. Henry sent two more messages while I was gone.
HenryCarterOfficial: you still there?
HenryCarterOfficial: guess even my biggest hater has a bedtime
My fingers find the keys while Colleen's voice is ringing in my ears—cover potential—and I need to remember what exactly I am doing here.
Burninhell: Some of us have jobs, Carter. Not everyone gets paid to chase a puck in circles.
HenryCarterOfficial: ouch. for the record, they're very precise circles
I bite my lip hard enough to hurt. I hate that he's funny, hate that my mouth twitches reflexively, before I remember that I'm smiling with him, and not at him. Which is just not how this whole arrangement is supposed to work.
Burninhell: Must be nice, making millions while the rest of us contribute to society.
HenryCarterOfficial: you know what's weird? i look forward to these, is that pathetic?
I stare at the screen and my head reels.
He looks forward to the messages from his hater? He's even more of a desperate nutso than I thought.
Burninhell: Extremely pathetic. Seek help.
HenryCarterOfficial: already talking to you. basically the same thing
I close the chat, lock my phone and hide it under the pillow, while my heart tries to beat out of my chest.
He really needs to check his head. And I need to check my heart…
Swipe up to continue
[Henry's POV]
"You concussed or just stupid today?" My teammate's voice pulls me out of my thoughts.
I missed the puck several times during drills, and Briggs finally has had enough. He skates up to me, his eyebrows halfway to his helmet, awaiting my reply.
"Working on it." I slap the puck toward the net and miss again. My arms do the motions, but my head is still in that interview room. My last message sits on read for three hours now, and I've checked twice during warm-ups like a goddamn teenager.
It's not the rejection that's eating me. It's the way she looked at me the entire interview, cool, unbothered, uninterested.
All while I sat there hyper-aware of every time she shifted in her chair, the whisper of her stockings crossing, the way she wet her bottom lip before asking me about drug abuse like she was asking about the weather.
The woman that she is…
The cold shoulder should piss me off. Instead I keep replaying the angle of her throat when she tilted her chin up to dismiss me, the slow curve of her mouth when she knew she'd cornered me, and the way my entire body leaned toward her.
The absolute zero she gave me when I asked her out should've been the end of it. Yet, it sits under my skin like a bruise I keep pressing.
She behaved like I was boring. Like I'd have to work a lot harder than that.
I haven't had to work for anyone's attention in years. And now I can't stop thinking about how to get hers.
Coach blows the whistle for a water break and I coast to the bench, yanking my gloves off. My phone sits in my bag, and I shouldn't, I absolutely should not… But my fingers are already pulling up socials, typing her name.
Renet Giles. Verified. Twelve thousand followers, modest for someone with her bylines.
I scroll through her grid and my thumb slows. Press event in a black dress, chin lifted. The neckline is low and seducing, the curve of her neck so inviting…
Get it together, Carter, you're not a vampire or some shit.
This is not the same girl. The Renet I remember barely spoke above a whisper and flinched when people raised their voices. This woman stares down professional athletes without blinking.
I tap through her published work.
A profile on a disgraced Olympic coach that led to a federation investigation. A long-form piece on contract manipulation in the NBA, syndicated nationally. Every article is surgical—she finds the weak spot and presses until the whole thing cracks.
Smart, persistent, and she doesn't mind drawing blood.
My stomach drops, because this is the woman that's been handed a microphone and invited to examine my past without my full agreement.
Not that anybody forced me, but it was my manager's decision first and foremost. And it might end up… not in my favor. Not even because of the highschool bullshit, but because Renet is a professional. And professionals dig deep enough to find bones.
She treated me like I was ordinary. My name, my stats, my face, none of it registered. Every other woman mirrors back some version of what I want to see. Renet held up a blank wall and dared me to keep talking.
She wants me to chase her. That's what this is.
I don't follow her from my main, or even my personal account. I create a new one: blank profile, no photo, a username I generate by mashing the keyboard.
Unhinged, and I know it. I tap follow anyway, because I want to watch without performing, without my name making her guard go up higher.
A notification from my main account pulls me out of it.
It's comments on my latest post, and I already know who it's from before I look.
Burninhell: Nice interview prep. Love the rolled sleeves, very "casual and relatable"
Burninhell: Did they coach you to spin the water bottle too, or was that improv?
The water bottle. I did spin it: a nervous habit I didn't think anyone clocked. That's not something you'd get from the magazine's announcement post. Someone in that room talked, a photographer or a stylist's assistant lingering in the hallway.
One of the magazine people running their mouth.
Annoying, not alarming. I make a mental note to ask Dave who had access and let it go, because thinking about the interview circles me right back to Renet.
Her sharp questions, her steady pen, the absence of warmth in her blue eyes…
I need to see her again.
The article will land on Orion's boardroom table, and if she's carrying a grudge, everything I've built sits in her hands. I also need her to trust me, and I need her to look at me without that cold measuring distance. Like I'm not just a story she's writing.
"Carter!" Coach's voice cracks across the rink. "Skating or scrolling? Pick one."
"Skating, Coach." I toss the phone into my bag and push off the boards, running plays that have nothing to do with hockey.
Practice ends at six and I'm pulling tape off my shins in the locker room when Dave walks in. His face adorned with that careful almost-smile that means he's got news he's trying not to jinx.
"Orion called." He leans against the doorframe, arms crossed. "Preliminary approval on the sponsorship."
Relief loosens my shoulders instantly. "Seriously? Dave, that's huge!" If they are not waiting on the article to decide, that means they trust my reputation however battered it is, which means…
"It's conditional, though." He holds up a finger, killing my celebration before it starts. "The deal activates after the article publishes. Positive coverage, clean narrative will be the trigger."
Of course.
Why would I anticipate anything else? Nothing in this world comes 'just because'.
"So I still need Giles to write nice things about me." The bitterness hurts my tongue. I should've expected it, and I'm upset all the same. I pull the tape free and ball it up. "Already working on it."
"Working on it how?" His eyes narrow. "If you're planning to flirt your way through this, I need you to understand: Orion is ten million, multi-year. It funds your contract negotiation, keeps the front office happy, and pays my salary."
"I know what's at stake, Dave." I keep my voice level, but irritation prickles along my neck.
He sometimes tries to act like my father. Which is ironic, considering both the reality of who my father is. And the fact that I'm twenty six while Dave is twenty eight.
Hypocrite.
"Do you? Three blown partnerships in two years." He counts on his fingers. "Nightclub photos. The model's podcast. The X fight with the ref's wife…"
"The ref's wife started it," I mutter, and he doesn't laugh.
"No scandals, I mean it." He points at me. "No parties, no tabloid girls, no DMs that can be screenshotted. Six weeks. Be boring. Be a fucking monk."
"What about the journalist?" The question leaves me before I can stop it, and Dave's expression stills.
"What about the journalist?"
"We went to school together." I try to sound casual and hear myself failing. "I'm thinking I should build some rapport, make her comfortable. For the article, of course."
Dave stares at me for a long, measuring beat. "Build rapport. With the woman your entire career depends on."
"Professionally," I add, and even I don't believe it.
"If you sleep with the journalist, I will personally end your career before she gets the chance." No smile, no warmth. "Fix whatever you need to fix, but fix it carefully. And if at any point you feel yourself getting stupid, then call me."
He leaves without goodbye. I sit alone on the bench, half-undressed, staring at Renet's profile still glowing on my phone.
He's right.
The smart move is to keep it professional, give her the interviews, smile for the camera. But I'm definitely not the smartest when I open our text thread. My single unanswered message glows at the bottom. I ignore it and type a new one.
Me: since you won't do dinner, how about coffee? my treat, your rules. i promise to only be 40% charming.
Swipe up to continue
[Renet's POV]
Henry Carter is standing outside the pharmacy holding a coffee, when I almost walk straight into his chest.
"Renet!" He grins, broad and stupid and far too pleased with himself. "What are the odds?"
His unread message still sits unanswered on my phone and now here he is. Holding coffee, on my block. I grip my grocery bag tighter and take a full step back.
The odds are that you're a freak, Carter.
"Are you stalking me?" I keep my voice sharp, half-joking, half not. "Because that's not a great look for your article."
"Relax, I live six blocks from here." He gestures east with one of the cups. As if I don't already know that. "My dentist is right there, root canal consultation."
"I absolutely do not need those details." I keep my voice flat, scanning for an exit.
The crosswalk is behind him, my car is a ten-minute walk I'd rather do alone.
"Where are you headed?" He falls into step beside me before I give permission, and his arm brushes mine and the contact sends shivers down my skin. I flinch sideways, clutching the grocery bag between us.
He's as clingy as a horny dog. It's honestly embarrassing.
"Errands—dry cleaner, post office, prescription." I don't look at him. "Nothing worth your precious star time."
"Perfect, I'm heading that direction." He sips his coffee, casual and unhurried. "I'll keep you company."
"I didn't ask for company."
I search for something cutting enough to make him leave, but his expression is so openly cheerful that my usual arsenal feels clumsy. I can't send him away without looking petty, without giving him ammunition to call me hostile.
But then a colder thought slithers in.
He's off the record, relaxed.
And people say the most damning things when they think nobody's writing it down.
"Fine." I start walking and he matches my stride immediately. "But if you slow me down, you're on your own."
"Wouldn't dream of it." He nods, agreeing way too easily for my comfort.
The dry cleaner is first. He waits outside, leaning against the window, and when I come out with my garment bag he takes it from my hands before I can protest.
"I'm a big girl, Henry." I reach for it, and my fingers close around the hanger at the same time his do.
His hand covers mine completely, warm, dry, and so much bigger that my knuckles disappear under his palm. Neither of us lets go. One second. Two.
His thumb shifts against my fingers, the smallest movement, barely there, and heat crawls up my wrist and into my chest like a lit fuse.
I release the hanger like it burned me. "I can carry my own dry cleaning."
"Never said you couldn't." He keeps walking, garment bag swinging, voice steady but his jaw tight, and I press my tingling fingers into a fist inside my pocket. "But my arms are free and yours aren't, so this is just math."
Don't smile. Do not smile.
I press my lips together and stare at the sidewalk. He's performing, and I refuse to be charmed by a man whose cruelty I still feel in my sleep.
"So…" He nudges the conversation open again as we cross the street. "Tell me something about Renet Giles that isn't in a byline."
"I hate small talk." True, and a deflection. I'm just efficient like that. "Your turn, tell me something the article shouldn't include."
"That's a tricky question, isn't it?" He laughs, genuine and loud, and two women on the sidewalk turn their heads. "Alright, I cried at my sister's wedding. Best man speech destroyed me, and Briggs still has it on video."
"Briggs… your teammate?" I ask, already knowing the answer from years of digging through his tagged photos.
"My teammate, my roommate, my emergency contact, and the guy who will absolutely show you that video if you ask." He looks at me sideways, brown eyes bright in the sunlight. "He can't keep a secret, which makes him a terrible friend and an incredible source."
"I'll keep that in mind." My voice stays level, but inside I'm calculating.
Briggs is close enough for real stories, loose enough to share them. Henry just handed me leverage without realizing the weight of it.
The post office line is long, and Henry stands next to me. His arm is right behind my shoulder, not touching, but close enough that the heat of him seeps through the thin fabric of my shirt and into my skin.
He tells me about Briggs supergluing his hand to his locker before a playoff game, and I bite the inside of my cheek hard to not laugh.
"You're smiling," he says, nudging my shoulder.
"I'm grimacing, there's a huge difference." I step an inch sideways to reclaim the distance, but not before I see his gaze drop to my mouth and drag back up, slow enough that we both know I caught it.
"There really isn't." His voice is lower now, rougher at the edges, and my gaze drops to the curve of his jaw before I drag it back to the counter.
Stop ogling him. Stop noticing that he's ogling you back.
He holds the pharmacy door and tells me about his worst game: a shutout against Tampa, open net, benched for the third period. The self-deprecation is so sharp it sounds rehearsed, except his ears go red, which means it isn't. I lean in.
As soon as I realize that I lean in, I pull back.
"You're making yourself sound bad on purpose," I say, narrowing my eyes at him. "What's the angle? Nobody gives away ammunition for free."
"No angle." He shrugs, shoulder almost touching mine. "I'm bad at plenty of things. Might as well own it before someone else does."
The honesty stuns me for half a second.
What a surprising self-awareness from someone stuck so far up in his own ass!
I recover before he can notice. "Careful, I might put that in the article."
"Go ahead." He meets my eyes and doesn't look away. "I'd rather you print the truth than whatever version you think will sell."
He's quiet and I'm quiet too, unsure how to react to it. It sounds real, uncomfortably so.
It's another trick of his. Definitely is.
When my errands were done, we ended up standing on the corner where I turn left and he goes straight, the silence stretches warm and almost good. As soon as I identify the emotion, it sends ice through my blood.
Not with him. Absolutely not with him, anyone else but him, Renet!
"I should go." I grab my garment bag from his arm, harder than necessary. "Thanks for the free labor."
"Anytime." He smiles, easy and unbothered.
I turn before my face can betray anything and walk fast, then faster, until I can breathe. When my phone buzzes, I pull it out the second later, grateful for the distraction.
Colleen: Your prelim notes are INCREDIBLE, this could be our cover, Renet.
Colleen: I mean it!!
Guilt twists in my stomach, ugly and unwelcome, because the notes she's praising are designed to destroy a man I just laughed with on a sidewalk.
Remember the hallways. Remember Tyler. Remember everything.
I shoot short "thanks" to Colleen and open the anonymous account, thumbs moving before the guilt can settle.
Burninhell: Saw your latest fan pics. The haircut's giving desperate mid-life crisis. Burninhell: You're only 26, Carter. Maybe act like it?
The reply comes fast, and there's no venom in it, no comeback. Just exhaustion I feel and match through the screen.
HenryCarterOfficial: rough day, honestly. feel like I'm talking to walls lately
HenryCarterOfficial: nothing's working, nobody's listening, and now you're coming for the hair too
I read it twice and my stomach drops. He sounds tired, and the pit deepens because I know exactly which wall he's been talking to. Me.
I lock the phone and press it against my thigh.
You don't feel sorry for him. You don't.
A new notification chimes. An account I don't recognize, no photo, no posts, following four people whose profiles are also mostly empty, DMed me.
user_29xkjm7: how was your day, pretty? hopefully the following you today everywhere prick didn't ruin it
My blood goes cold. Someone saw me with Henry, and is now doing the same thing I do to Henry.
Well, karma's a bitch, Renet. And apparently, so are you.
Swipe up to continue