Sawyer's POV
My mom has made enough food for twelve people. There are four of us at the table.
She cooks when she's nervous, so today we have roast chicken, mashed potatoes, green beans, homemade rolls, a salad nobody will touch, and a pie cooling on the counter.
She's been at it since I got back from campus, moving around the kitchen in her good dress with her hair actually done for once, and I know — I know in my gut — that whatever tonight is about, it's bigger than dinner.
Richard Ellory sits at the head of the table in the chair my father used to sit in before he went to prison. He's wearing a button-down like this is a date, and he keeps touching my mom's arm when she passes him.
Cade is late, obviously. He walks in twenty minutes past seven with wet hair and a smile that makes my mom light up and makes me want to put my fist through the wall.
"Sorry I'm late, Mrs. Drum. Practice ran over." He kisses her on the cheek.
He actually kisses her on the cheek, and she laughs and waves him toward the table like he's her son instead of the person I found balls-deep in a random dude six hours ago.
He sits across from me and catches my eye. His mouth twitches.
I look at my plate and start eating. The parents fill the silence.
"So how's the first semester treating you boys?" Richard cuts into his chicken. "Cade says the swim team's looking strong this year."
"Strongest roster we've had since I joined." Cade doesn't even look up from his plate. Somehow that's worse than bragging. "Coach thinks we've got a real shot at regionals."
"That's wonderful." My mom beams at him from across the table like he just announced he cured cancer. "Sawyer, are you thinking about joining any teams?"
"No."
She blinks. Richard fills the silence by reaching for the rolls.
"Sawyer's more of a solo athlete," Cade says, and the way he says it — casual, almost kind — makes my skin prickle. He glances at me with that helpful, supportive expression he puts on for parents. "I've seen him running laps around the track at six a.m. He's fast."
I stare at him. He's seen me running at six in the morning. Which means he's been watching me, and he wants me to know it.
"Is that true, honey?" My mom's face lights up. "You should look into track. Richard, didn't you say the track coach is—"
"I'm not joining track, Mom." I stab a piece of chicken hard enough that the fork scrapes porcelain and everyone at the table flinches except Cade.
Cade just watches me with that patient, entertained expression, like a kid poking a wasp nest to see how many stings he can take before it stops being fun.
"I'm just saying, if Cade thinks you're—"
"I don't care what Cade thinks." It comes out louder than the table is ready for.
My mom presses her lips together and reaches for her wine glass. Richard clears his throat and puts his hand over hers.
"Linda, this chicken is outstanding." Richard smiles at my mom and puts his hand over hers, and I want to break every one of his fingers. He's comforting her from me. "Is that rosemary?"
"Rosemary and thyme. It's a new recipe." She's recovering, smoothing over the crack I just put in the evening. She's good at that. Years of practice. "So, Cade." She passes him the rolls with a warm smile, redirecting. "How's the social life? Anyone special?"
I freeze with my fork halfway to my mouth.
Cade leans back in his chair and grins. "Actually, yeah. There's this guy I've been seeing. Nothing serious yet, but he's..." He pauses like he's searching for the right word, and his eyes flick to mine for half a second. "Closed off." He takes a bite of his roll and chews slowly. Swallows. "But I'm patient. He'll come around."
My grip tightens on my fork so hard the metal bites into my palm. I stare at my plate and think about the locker room. The guy pressed against the lockers. Cade's shorts around his thighs. The way he looked at me while he kept going.
Who is he talking about? That guy? Someone else? Why the fuck do I care?
"Oh, that's wonderful," my mom says, and she means it. There's no hesitation, she's genuinely happy for him. "What's he like?"
"He's tall. Dark hair. Athletic." Cade twirls his fork between his fingers, casual. "Broody, though. When he walks into a room, everyone tenses up because they don't know if he's going to talk to them or punch them." He smiles at my mom. "But that's what I like about him. He's real. No bullshit. You always know where you stand."
He's describing me. He's sitting at my mother's dinner table, eating her food, and describing me to her face, and she's nodding along like it's sweet.
"He sounds like a handful," Richard says with a chuckle.
"Oh, he is." Cade's eyes slide to mine across the table. "But the difficult ones are always worth the effort, right, Mrs. Drum?"
My mom actually laughs. "That's what I keep telling Sawyer."
I put my fork down. My appetite is gone.
"What about you, Sawyer?" Cade tilts his head. That same infuriating tilt from the locker room. "How's Megan?"
The table goes quiet. My mom jumps in before I can open my mouth. "Sawyer and Megan didn't work out." She puts her hand on my arm, gentle and protective. "He just needs to find the right girl. There's no rush."
"No rush at all," Cade agrees. His voice is warm and sincere. "The right person shows up when you least expect it."
I watch my mother nod along. She's listening to Cade Ellory talk about fucking guys, and she's fine with it. She's smiling.
If my father were here — if Dale Drum were sitting in that chair instead of a prison cell — he would have grabbed Cade by the throat and slammed his head into the wall and told him what happens to boys who talk like that in his house.
My father was a monster. But at least he never would have sat here and smiled while —
I stop the thought. Bury it. But not fast enough, because my brain has already circled back to Cade in the locker room — shirtless, sweating, his shorts low on his hips.
I pick up my glass of water and drain it in one go.
Richard clears his throat. The whole energy at the table shifts. My mom straightens in her chair and her hand finds Richard's on the table, and I watch their fingers lace together with a feeling in my chest like someone just cracked my ribs open.
"Boys, we have some news." Richard looks at my mom and she nods at him with shining eyes and a smile I haven't seen on her face since before my dad put his first hole in the drywall.
Fuck no.
No. No, no, no, no, no.
"Linda and I have been together for several months now, and we've decided..." He squeezes her hand. "We're getting married."
You must be fucking kidding me.
My mom raises her left hand. There's a ring on it. Small diamond, silver band. She's been hiding it all evening.
The room tilts.
"We've found a house near campus," Richard continues, his voice thick with the optimism that makes me want to scream. "Neutral territory, fresh start for everyone. Four bedrooms, big yard. Boys, your rooms will share a jack-and-jill bathroom so you won't have to fight over the main one."
My eyes snap to Cade's across the table.
For one second — one honest, unguarded second — I see something real on his face. His smile drops. His jaw tightens. His blue eyes meet mine and I see my own horror reflected back at me, sharp and immediate and genuine.
He didn't know. He's just as blindsided as I am, and for that single second we're on the same side of something, united in the understanding that our parents have just locked us in a cage together and thrown away the key.
Then the second passes.
Cade's mouth curves into a slow smile that says I'm going to enjoy this.
"That's amazing, Dad." Cade turns to my mom and his voice is pure warmth. "Welcome to the family, Mrs. Drum."
Richard beams across the table at both of us. "You two will finally get to be real brothers."
Swipe up to continue
* Two months later *
Cade's car is already in the driveway when I pull up.
Of course it is. His boxes are probably inside already, labeled in clean handwriting, stacked by room. Mine are in the back of my mom's minivan, held together with duct tape.
The courthouse wedding was two weeks ago — small, no fuss, over before I figured out what to do with my hands. Now I'm hauling the leftovers of my father's shitshow into Richard Ellory's fresh start and pretending I belong here.
The place is a two-story near campus. White siding, blue shutters, a yard with an actual fence. Everything about it screams normal, which is how I know it's bullshit.
I carry the first box through the front door and there he is — Cade Ellory in gray sweats and a white t-shirt, crouched over a box in the living room, sorting his shit.
He doesn't look up when I walk in. I don't say hello. We move through the house without crossing paths. He takes the upstairs hallway, I take the kitchen.
He carries his shit to the left bedroom, I carry mine to the right. I know exactly where he is at every second. His footsteps above me, the creak of his bedroom door, the sound of tape ripping off his boxes.
I track him through the ceiling like a dog tracking a scent because I want to know where he is so I can be somewhere else.
It lasts about an hour before the distance closes. Over a fucking shelf.
"That's my side." I'm standing in the upstairs hallway with a box under my arm, staring at Cade's swimming trophies already lining the built-in shelf between our bedroom doors.
The shared shelf my mom specifically said was for both of us.
Cade leans against his doorframe with his arms crossed. "I got here first."
"Move them." I set the box down on the floor with enough force to make the trophies rattle on the shelf.
"Make me." His voice is quiet and patient and absolutely fucking delighted.
"Boys!" My mom's voice floats up from the stairs, bright and desperate. "Can you two come help with the dresser? Richard threw his back out."
I head downstairs. Cade follows. The dresser is solid oak, heavy enough that it takes both of us to lift it, which is exactly what my mom wanted. I can see it in her face — the hopeful look, the fragile smile. She thinks shared labor will fix us.
Foolish of her.
We get it through the front door. Down the hallway. To the base of the stairs.
"Your end's slipping," Cade says.
"My end's fine. Lift higher."
"I am lifting higher. You're dragging your side."
We make it four steps up. Five. On the sixth, our hands shift on the grip and his fingers brush mine.
The contact lasts less than a second but my body clocks it like a fire alarm — heat shooting from the point of contact straight into my gut, the same sick warmth from the bathroom floor, from the party, from every moment his skin has touched mine.
I jerk my hand back so fast the dresser lurches sideways. "Don't fucking touch me."
Cade rebalances the weight. His voice drops low enough that only I can hear. "Why does it bother you so much?"
"Because I don't want your hands anywhere near me. Is that complicated?"
"A little." He tilts his head. "Most people don't flinch that hard from an accident. Makes a guy wonder what you're afraid of."
"I'm not afraid of anything. Especially not you."
"Then why are you shaking?"
I look down at my hands. He's right. They're trembling on the grip and I hate him for noticing.
"Runs in the family, doesn't it?" Cade's voice goes soft, almost gentle. That's how I know the knife is coming. "Your dad used to shake like that right before he hit your mom. Think she sees it too?"
Every molecule of air leaves my lungs.
"Shut your mouth," I demand.
"Must be hard." He hasn't raised his voice once. He's calm and measured. "Living in that man's skin. Looking in the mirror and seeing his face staring back. Knowing that no matter how far you run, you're still Dale Drum's—"
"Your mom died eight months ago and you didn't shed a single tear." The words rip out of me like shrapnel. "I saw you at that funeral. And your dad? Your dad moved on so fast her body was barely cold before he put a ring on my mother's finger." I lean in close enough to see his pupils contract. "How long did Richard really wait, Cade? Was your mom even in the ground?"
Cade's expression doesn't change. His face stays perfectly still, like I didn't just drag his dead mother into a fight on a staircase.
But his eyes go flat. The blue drains out of them until they're just glass.
"Interesting," he says quietly. His mouth curves. "You memorized my face at my mother's funeral. Were you watching me, Sawyer?" He leans closer. "That's a lot of attention for someone you hate."
I let go of the dresser.
It slides down four steps and hits the landing with a crack that splits the oak down the middle. My mom gasps from the bottom of the stairs.
Cade doesn't move. I grab the front of his shirt and haul him toward me. He grabs mine. We're locked together on the narrow staircase, faces inches apart, his breath on my mouth, my fist twisted in his collar so tight the fabric cuts into my knuckles.
"Say that again." Our faces are close enough that I can see the blood vessels in his eyes, can smell the sweat on his skin. "Go on. Give me a reason to smash your face. "
I can't believe it.
Cade leans in.
His eyes drop to my mouth like he's reading something written on my lips, and then drag back up to meet mine. He gives me a smile that makes me want to cave his skull in.
"All that anger, Sawyer." I can feel his whisper in my own chest. "Imagine what you'd fuck like if you stopped fighting it."
I slam him into the wall so hard the banister shakes. His skull bounces off the plaster and he laughs, and I pull my fist back to break his face open when Richard's arms wrap around my chest from behind and drag me backward.
"Enough!" Richard's voice fills the staircase. "Both of you, enough!"
My mom stands at the bottom of the stairs with her hand over her mouth and tears running down her face. She's not making a sound. That's worse than screaming.
Richard positions himself between us. His face is red and his jaw is set and for the first time since I've known him, he doesn't look gentle. He looks like a father.
"Your mother and I —" He looks at me, then at Cade. "We lost people. You two are going to help us build something here or you're going to be difficult. And let me warn you, I hate difficult. I need to know right now which one it's going to be."
I look at my mom. She's gripping the banister with both hands, knuckles white, chin trembling. She looks the way she looked the night my dad got arrested — small and broken and holding onto the nearest solid thing to keep from collapsing.
"I'll try." My voice comes out raw. I say it for her. Only for her.
"Cade?" Richard demands.
Cade straightens his shirt. Runs a hand through his hair. The mask slides back into place so smooth it would be impressive if it wasn't terrifying. "Of course, Dad. Whatever you need."
Richard exhales. My mom wipes her face and tries to smile. Nobody looks at the broken dresser.
I go upstairs, walk into my room, close the door, then cross to the jack-and-jill bathroom and lock it from my side.
I stand there with my forehead against the door, breathing hard, trying to get his voice out of my head.
'Imagine what you'd fuck like if you stopped fighting it.'
The words play on a loop behind my eyes and my body won't stop buzzing — this low, sick hum under my skin.
That's adrenaline. That's what that is.
It has nothing to do with the image my brain just flashed without my permission — Cade underneath me, not on a staircase but somewhere else, somewhere horizontal, with that same filthy smile on his face while I —
I slam my fist into the door so hard the hinges rattle.
No.
Fuck that.
Fuck him.
I'm not this.
I will never be this.
The handle rattles from the other side once. Then it stops.
I don't move from the door for a long time.
Swipe up to continue
Cade's POV
I'm two hundred meters into a butterfly set when Coach blows the whistle and I realize I've been smiling underwater for the last five laps.
That's new.
I pull myself onto the wall and push my goggles up. The pool is loud — splash, echo, the squeak of kickboards, Coach yelling at the freshmen to fix their turns. Beside me, Tyler surfaces and shakes his head like a dog.
Tyler Park is my vice-captain, six feet of Korean-American muscle with a buzz cut and a jawline that gets him laid every weekend.
He's the closest thing I have to a friend on this team, which means I've studied him enough to mimic the friendship convincingly and he's too straightforward to notice the difference.
"Dude, what the hell are you on today?" he asks cheerfully. "You just smoked the rest of us by a full body length."
"Clean living," I say. "Early bedtimes, lots of vegetables."
"Bullshit." He grins and hauls himself onto the deck. Water runs down his chest and pools in the lines of his abs. I've fucked guys who look like Tyler. They bore me before I finish. "You're getting laid. That's the only thing that puts that look on someone's face."
From two lanes over, Marsh cups his hands around his mouth. "Ellory's in love! Someone call the campus paper!"
"I don't do love, Marsh." I say it with a grin so he thinks I'm joking. "I do enjoy entertainment."
Tyler snorts and throws his cap at me. "You've got two settings, Ellory — dead behind the eyes and balls deep in someone. There's literally nothing in between." He drops onto the bench and stretches his legs out. "So which one is it? That guy from the party? The blonde?"
"Nobody you know." I pull myself out of the water and grab my towel, dragging it across my face.
The chlorine stings and I let it. I like small discomforts — they remind me I have a body, which is something I forget when I'm not bleeding or fucking or pinning Sawyer Drum to a hard surface.
"So there is somebody." Tyler leans forward on his knees, studying me with that earnest, uncomplicated expression that makes him so easy to manage.
He genuinely wants to know. He thinks we're friends and friends share these things. It's almost sweet.
I sling the towel over my shoulders and give him the smile that ends conversations — warm, open, just enough teeth to make people feel like they got an answer when they didn't get shit.
The truth is I don't know what I'm on.
Since moving day, there's something in my chest that won't settle. Not anxiety — I don't get anxious. Not happiness — I've studied happiness in other people, and I can replicate every visible component, but the thing itself has never turned over for me.
This is different. It's a hum. Low and constant, like a frequency I've never picked up before. It started when I heard the lock click on Sawyer's bathroom door.
I tested the handle on purpose. I wanted — no, needed — to know if he'd lock it. A locked door means he already thought about what happens if it opens.
You don't barricade yourself against something you're not afraid of.
I wonder what he was wearing. Boxers? Nothing? I've never seen Sawyer without a shirt on.
I've seen the shape of him through fabric — the hard cut of his shoulders when he carries boxes, the line of his spine when he bends over the kitchen counter, the way his sweats hang off his hips just low enough to show that strip of skin above the waistband.
But I've never seen him bare. He walks from his bedroom to the bathroom fully dressed, like he knows I'm counting the inches of exposed skin and he's determined to give me nothing.
It makes me want to rip the clothes off him with my teeth.
The hum in my chest gets louder.
"Ellory, you sticking around for drills?" Coach's voice from across the pool.
"Heading out early, Coach. Got a physical therapy session."
I don't have a physical therapy session. I have something better in my locker.
The locker room clears out fast. Tyler and the others head for the showers, still arguing about whose relay split was slowest.
I let myself watch for a few seconds at their bare backs and wet skin. Marsh has a tattoo on his ribs I haven't noticed before. Tyler's got a bruise on his hip from a bad flip turn.
None of it does anything for me.
Then I picture Sawyer in this room, pulling his shirt over his head, the dark trail of hair on his stomach tensing as the cold air hits him, and my cock stirs against my thigh so fast I have to turn toward my locker and adjust myself.
Now, that is the difference.
I wait until the last of them filters out before I spin the combination to my locker.
My phone is on the top shelf. Not my main phone, the other one I bought with cash at a gas station off the highway. Prepaid with no name.
I open Tinder.
The profile smiles back at me — a girl named Kaylee with a black bikini and her middle finger up at the camera.
The photo is a stock image I found on a dead Instagram account, cropped and filtered until it looked real enough to fool someone who wanted to believe it.
The bio says three words: No strings attached.
Sawyer matched with her the morning after the party.
I scroll through the chat history. It's long now — almost two weeks of messages.
Sawyer is performing a desire for a girl who doesn't exist, typing things like 'I'd pin you against the wall' and 'I'd put my mouth between your legs'.
He's good at it. Practiced enough that the sentences flow naturally, and if I didn't know what I know — if I hadn't felt his body respond to mine on a bathroom floor — I might actually believe him.
But I do know. So instead of seeing a guy sexting a girl, I see Sawyer Drum rehearsing for a role he can't play, typing with one hand and probably staring at the ceiling with dead eyes, willing his dick to cooperate with the fiction.
I bet it didn't cooperate. I bet he was soft the entire time.
I scroll to the latest message. Sent this morning, 2:47 a.m.
It's a photo.
Sawyer's hand wrapped around his cock, hard and flushed and thick, the waistband of his boxers shoved down.
No face — just his hand, his stomach, the dark trail of hair below his navel. The lighting is bad, taken in his bedroom with the lamp on. His bedroom. Twelve feet from mine.
I stare at it. My mouth goes dry. I run my thumb along the edge of the screen, tracing the line of his hip bone, and something primal and ugly shifts in the pit of my stomach.
Something sharp sits behind my sternum like a hook yanking inward, and my jaw tightens without my permission.
My thumb hovers over the screen and my grip on the phone hardens.
I've only ever seen this expression on other people — the clenched teeth, the narrowed eyes, the way their whole body goes rigid when someone touches what they think is theirs.
What I feel is… jealousy?
Huh. That's new too.
This picture means he was actually thinking about someone when he got hard enough to wrap his hand around his cock and take a picture.
So who was he thinking about?
Megan? No, she dumped him the second she tasted my cock.
The girl from class who keeps touching his arm in the hallway?
I've seen her do it. I've watched him let her, stiff and dead-eyed, like a mannequin someone forgot to switch on.
No, not her. She couldn't get him hard with a gun to his head.
I save the photo. His arousal belongs to me whether he likes it or not. He just doesn't know it yet.
I lock the phone and slide it back onto the shelf behind a stack of textbooks. Close the locker. Spin the dial.
Tyler pokes his head around the corner, hair dripping. "You coming to the Halloween party at Delta Sig this Friday?"
"Wouldn't miss it." I pull my shirt over my head and give him the easy grin. "I've got plans."
"Hot date plans?"
"Something like that."
He disappears back toward the showers, and I sit on the bench with my elbows on my knees and let myself think about what's coming.
I've got a game planned for my dear stepbrother, and I bet he won't like it.
Swipe up to continue