Catarina
Scanning the patio and pool for the source of the moans, my first thought is that it could be Tatiana, but that’s not possible—she’s completely out of it. These aren’t distressed sounds; they’re filled with intense passion.
My gaze is drawn to one of the lounge chairs by the pool. The underwater lights cast a faint glow, revealing a sight I missed earlier.
About twenty feet away, Gianni is engaged with a woman I don’t recognize. He’s kneeling at the foot of the chair, and she’s sprawled out before him. My face flushes with embarrassment, and though I know I should look away, I can’t. I watch as he moves his face toward her, his intentions unmistakable.
I press a hand to my mouth, trying to stifle a gasp. Gianni’s hands grip her thighs firmly as he goes down on her. A forbidden desire begins to stir within me. Gianni, always the epitome of sexiness, has been the subject of countless fantasies, but I’ve never seen him in such a raw, intimate moment. His usual persona—professional, commanding, and intense—now takes on a new dimension.
Jealousy and desire mix inside me as I observe him. The woman’s moans fill the air, and I can only imagine the sensation of his tongue on her. The scene is almost too much to bear.
“Oh god! Gianni. Yes! More!” she cries out, her pleasure clear in her voice.
Gianni’s experience and patience are evident. He’s a man who could undoubtedly bring intense pleasure. The sight of his strong, tattooed torso and dripping swim trunks adds to my growing heat.
My cheeks burn with shame, and I know I should leave. It’s wrong to watch, and they have no idea I’m here. But my feet won’t move. The fantasy of being noticed, of being in her place, consumes me. I watch as Gianni’s hands slide over her, his touch eliciting more cries of pleasure from her.
“Fuck. It feels so good,” she moans, her body trembling with ecstasy.
My heart races. I need to escape before I’m seen. They’re preoccupied now, but if they catch me, the embarrassment would be unbearable.
Move, now.
And yet, my feet remain frozen. My eyes are locked on Gianni, unable to look away. My nipples press painfully against the fabric of my nightshirt, and an intense, consuming arousal grips me, even though no one has touched me.
The woman continues to moan as Gianni skillfully pleasures her. Her legs are draped over his shoulders, and his actions are causing her to cry out with pleasure.
“Gianni… yes. Yes! Yes!” she breathes heavily.
I try to rationalize this as no different from watching explicit content online. I’m not doing anything wrong, right? He’s just my best friend’s father.
He pulls back from her breasts and slides a hand between her legs, exposing her completely. My breath quickens, and a wave of desire floods me. I’m astonished I haven’t made a mess on the seat.
Luciano has never touched me like this. Gianni’s intensity and the way he’s pleasuring her make me ache with longing. He inserts two fingers into her, stretching her, and I can almost feel those same fingers inside me. I watch his face, focused and intense, as he continues.
The urge to touch myself grows overwhelming, and when he leans back down, I have to bite my lip to hold back a moan.
I’m drenched in need, helpless against my desire for someone completely unattainable.
I shift uncomfortably, my thighs rubbing together, amplifying the ache. The only remedy seems to be giving in, but I can’t. It feels so wrong.
The patio lights catch on Gianni’s dark hair and bare skin. He’s usually so stoic and unyielding, but now his focus on the woman makes his intensity even more striking.
How many times have I dreamed of this?
Except, I was the woman he was fucking, taming, taking pleasure from. I wonder if the rumors are true? That he fucks as dirty as he fights.
It should be me.
My body he’s touching, licking, kissing.
My clit he licks while his thick, strong fingers ruin my pussy. I wish I could see his cock, but he’s still clothed from the waist down. In my fantasies, I’ve imagined his cock to be immense, his girth thick, thanks to the tempting outline in his suit pants.
I can’t count how many times I’ve caught myself staring at him. All I could think was… would he break me as he pushed inside? His massive cock becoming too much for my little pussy to handle. I shudder, the pressure in my core too intense to be ignored. The sight of his body, the moans of the woman he’s feasting on. It’s wreaking havoc on my fragile libido.
Oh god. I know I shouldn't be doing this. It's wrong, undeniably wrong. But I never claimed to be a saint, did I? The ache of desire is nearly unbearable, and I need to find relief. Even though it’s wrong, the need is consuming. Slipping a hand under my nightshirt, I mimic Gianni’s actions with the blonde, rolling my nipple between my fingers. The pleasure that follows is intense, filling me with an urgent craving. I imagine my fingers are his, the rough texture against my sensitive skin.
As I focus on Gianni’s other hand, moving rhythmically, the forbidden nature of it heightens my arousal. My instincts scream for me to flee, but I can’t bring myself to move.
Spreading my legs further, I prop one foot on the stool and slide my other hand beneath my thong. I part my lips, letting my tongue graze over them, and guide my fingers through my own wetness, imagining they are his.
This is so wrong. It feels filthy. What is happening to me?
I’ve struggled with my feelings for years, knowing this could jeopardize my friendship with Tatiana. But right now, I can’t stop. I don’t want to, especially when pretending I’m the one Gianni is pleasuring brings me such intense satisfaction. If I can experience this while watching the man I’ve fantasized about, I will.
“Don’t stop!” the woman gasps, nearing her climax. “Oh god, yes… just like that! I’m about to come! Please, don’t stop!”
As she cries out, her body convulses in the throes of an overwhelming orgasm. I watch in envy, having never experienced such intensity myself.
It’s all because of him—Gianni. If only he noticed me, if only he could make me feel the way he’s making that woman feel. My body tenses, my clit throbbing, my heartbeat pounding in my ears. I’m so close. I can feel the heat and wetness slipping down my thighs. My body is begging for something I can’t have. I press harder, faster, needing the friction just right. This is wrong, so wrong, but the pleasure is overwhelming.
My body is on the edge, every muscle wound tight. I can’t stop—oh god, I’m about to come, and it feels so incredible. My eyes flutter shut, goosebumps spreading across my skin as my hips lift, craving something more. And then, with a gasp, I shatter, a wave of euphoria washing over me. I wish so desperately that it was Gianni’s touch filling me.
A single name escapes my lips, barely a whisper. “Gianni…”
He shouldn’t be able to hear me. There’s no way he could. I’m hidden in the darkness. But as I slowly open my eyes, I see his head snap up. My heart races even faster, the remnants of my orgasm still coursing through me. In the dim light, our gazes seem to lock, though he can only see the sliding glass door.
The floor feels like it’s giving way beneath me as his lips curl into a knowing smirk. He must see something—something I didn’t think was possible. We’re locked in this moment, a moment I’ve yearned for, but never thought would happen.
My legs are weak, my chest heaving, and my fingers slick with the evidence of what I’ve done. I should be filled with shame, but instead, I’m overwhelmed by the thrill of his gaze on me.
He can’t see me. He mustn’t.
But the smirk on his face suggests otherwise. And I can’t shake the feeling that he’s aware of exactly what’s happening.
Swipe up to continue
Gianni
I must be imagining things because there’s no way I just saw what I think I did.
What a provocatively audacious girl.
Caterina isn’t as innocent as I had believed. I always thought of her as a model student with perfect grades, an early bedtime, and a rule-following nature. She seemed like the ideal sweet girl with a shy smile and a figure many men would covet.
To think I saw her as an innocent angel when she’s actually been a temptress in disguise. I can’t count how many times she’s stayed at our house or joined us on vacations, subtly enticing and provoking me from a distance.
It’s fucked up to acknowledge how many years I’ve spent reminding myself she’s my daughter’s best friend, not to mention the fact that she’s way too young to even consider touching. There have been many times over the years when those reminders are the only thing that kept me from throwing her to the floor and fucking her unconscious.
Where Caterina stands, my patience is razor thin. Sweet, beautiful Caterina with her luscious brown hair begging for my hands to sink into it. And damn, those big, innocent blue eyes, so full of kindness and sincerity. I’ve pictured them so often filled with tears that streaked her cheeks as I shoved my cock to the back of her throat, making her gag.
God, the restraint it took, the reminding myself that she’s too innocent to be tainted and defiled by a man like me. But now, none of those things matter. Before, there was a line in the sand, but now it’s been obliterated. Because there she is, sitting in my kitchen, playing with her pussy, touching her tiny clit, making herself come the same way the girl still clenched around my fingers has barely finished doing.
I know Caterina thinks I haven’t noticed how she’s looked at me before this, that I haven’t noticed her pretty blush when our eyes meet or when I occasionally catch her checking me out.
As if I could fucking miss it. As if she hasn’t commanded my attention for the last five years. There’s not a man alive who wouldn’t feel gratified by that attention, even if it’s nothing more than a fantasy that can never come to life. But I’ll be damned if we haven’t come dangerously close tonight.
Her chest heaves, and I’d bet if I looked in her eyes right now, I’d see her desire shining. Words can’t describe how fucking turned on I am, knowing she finished herself off to the sight of me finger fucking Chelsea.
When I withdraw my fingers, her pussy drips, her juices glistening against my skin. But it’s Caterina’s juices I crave. It’s Caterina I want out here with me, moaning and whimpering in the aftermath of pleasure.
And it’s enough to turn my desire into something closer to anger as I stand and pull my rock-hard cock free from my trunks. I angle myself enough to give the girl hiding in the shadows a show. I know she’s wondered about my size so many times. Is it as big as she imagined? As thick?
Yes, sweet, innocent Caterina. My cock is big enough to split you in two.
Fisting myself, I roughly stroke my thick cock and tug Chelsea upright until she’s sitting at the edge of the chair, her face level with my crotch.
“It’s your turn to make me come,” I mutter to her while really speaking to Caterina, since my gaze is still trained on the kitchen.
How fucked up is it that while I’m presently getting pleasure from someone else, all I can see is Caterina?
What a naughty girl. I imagine her tight pussy quivering all over her hand. I wonder if she’s a squirter. If she could take my entire length at once, or if she would beg me to go nice and slow, the fear of me fucking her hard enough to hurt, keeping her on the knife’s edge of pleasure and pain.
I watch her intently. She’s still there, hiding. Safe and protected by the dark. She hasn’t moved except to withdraw her hand from between her legs. What I wouldn’t give to lick her fingers clean before shoving my tongue up into her cunt, drinking up every drop of her release. I bet she tastes like honey, and I’m fucking starving.
“Mm, yeah,” Chelsea agrees before I cut her off, shoving my entire length past her glossy lips and deep into her throat. I’m not a selfish lover. I give, but I want the same pleasure when I receive. Chelsea lets out a choked groan, but it barely meets my ears. I’m too consumed by the sensation and the unbearable connection to the walking temptation still watching me.
Is this how you’d like it? Fuck. It’s not the woman sucking me that has me harder than I’ve been in my life. It’s the one in the shadows, the shy, timid one. Growling, I take Chelsea’s head in my hands, controlling every aspect of the experience.
Holding her in place, I thrust my hips into her; the head of my cock hits the back of her throat, drawing soft cries of dismay the faster I fuck her face.
In my mind, it’s Caterina’s face I’m fucking. Caterina’s pussy I still smell, thanks to the juices drying on my lips. For the first time, I’m giving in to the fantasy, allowing myself to visualize every aspect of the temptation that’s tormented me for years.
I imagine her body still quivering in the aftermath of her orgasm, her nipples peaked, her pussy slick and ready. How much does she wish she was in this chair, choking on my cock?
Fuck.
My balls tighten. The pleasure builds at the bottom of my spine. It’s rare that I’m so amped up that I’m ready to explode within minutes, but I’ve never experienced something like this.
“Fuck, your mouth is perfect,” I praise, but it’s Caterina I’m speaking to. “Suck me hard and deep.”
I press against Chelsea’s face. My balls rest on her chin, and I hold myself there, relishing in her struggle for control. After a moment, I show mercy and pull back, giving her a chance to catch her breath, all the while keeping my gaze on Caterina’s.
Those sweet, innocent blue eyes peer back at me. I want to see them fill with tears. I want to see her cheeks hollow, her lips swollen and wrapped around my cock while drool and cum dribble down her chin. The swirling thoughts are enough to push me over the edge.
I pull out of Chelsea’s wet mouth with a pop and take my cock into my hand, stroking myself faster. “Fuck, open your mouth and stick your tongue out. I’m going to come on your face.” It’s not a question but a demand.
Out of the corner of my eye, I see Caterina, the dirty little girl, sinking her teeth into her bottom lip. That’s what tips me over the edge. What sends a final surge of pressure through my balls and leaves me exploding. The muscles in my stomach tense, and my toes curl into the concrete under my feet. All I can see in my mind is Caterina. Innocent. Sweet. Her pretty face painted in my cum. God. I’m going to corrupt her so fucking good.
“Fuuuuuck,” I roar, as ropes of cum shoot from the tip, splashing across the face of the woman before me. Every drop of fluid belongs to the angelic creature in the kitchen, who unwittingly has revealed her true nature.
“Mmm…” The moaning near my knees pulls my attention away from Caterina. I would’ve forgotten about the blonde in front of me if it hadn’t been for the sound she just made. I came seconds ago, and my usual response sits on the tip of my tongue.
No matter what I do or how many dates I go on, I have yet to find a woman who doesn’t bore me. The moment I identified Caterina’s presence, everything else ceased to exist. I can’t leave Chelsea as she is, though. That would be a dick move.
“Stay here. I’ll get you a towel.”
I grab a towel from the stack by the pool to help Chelsea clean her face. As I glance back at the house, Caterina is nowhere to be seen, leaving me unsettled. Chelsea puts on the light cotton dress and sandals she wore earlier, and I lead her inside to finish freshening up in the bathroom.
I’m not surprised Caterina has disappeared from the kitchen. I can’t help but focus on the spot where she was sitting as I guide Chelsea to the powder room. While waiting for her to finish, I arrange for a driver to bring a car around.
My thoughts keep drifting back to Caterina. I imagine her hiding out in Tatiana’s room, waiting to see if I’ll confront her about what she saw. I chuckle to myself. I had anticipated they would be out late, stumbling back around dawn—something I would have done at twenty-one.
Had I known they’d come home so early, I might have reconsidered my actions by the pool.
Caterina’s responsible, sweet, and seemingly naive. I never expected her to be interested in watching. I wonder what other secrets she might have. An older, experienced partner could reveal to her a world of possibilities she hasn’t yet explored.
The thought of what I could teach her, what I could do to her, is almost overwhelming.
“There’s a car waiting for you outside,” I tell Chelsea as she exits the bathroom.
She smiles, her teeth gleaming. “I was thinking maybe we could have another drink. Sit, talk, and get to know each other a bit more.” Her hopeful expression is charming, but not enough to change my mind.
She’s attractive with her long blonde hair and slim figure, but tonight isn’t about her. She’s trying to delay the inevitable, but this night won’t end with her in my bed.
“I don’t want to be rude, Chelsea, but you know the deal,” I say, trying to sound as considerate as possible.
“I was hoping maybe this time would be different,” she replies quietly.
I don’t answer. What’s the point? Nothing will alter the outcome. I learned long ago that being wealthy and successful means every aspect of your life can be used against you, especially in matters of intimacy. No one wins when a woman tries to trap you with a child.
Chelsea gets the message and leaves without further protest. I close the door behind her and move on, but my mind is already elsewhere.
Swipe up to continue
Gianni
Women have their place, and once I’ve had my fill, I send them on their way. It might make me an asshole, but at least I make sure they’re satisfied before they leave.
I rake a hand through my thick hair, letting out a deep sigh. I can’t help but think about what would happen if I ever gave in to the years-long battle with my conscience and acted on my desire for Caterina. The idea of sending her away like all the others bothers me—not just for her, but especially for my daughter.
How could I look her in the eye and tell her I slept with her best friend and discarded her like yesterday’s news?
I walk barefoot through the first floor, my swim trunks sticking to my muscular legs.
A sudden urge to go to her almost overpowers me. My body says yes, but my mind says no. Our dirty little secret would remain hidden, something we’d both pretend never happened, especially for Tatiana’s sake. I can only imagine her reaction if she found out what went down tonight.
My daughter must never know, but Caterina is in for a shock if she thinks I won’t address what happened. Now that I’ve seen beneath her innocent facade, there’s no going back.
I’m consumed with desire, but I let my brain make the final choice and enter my study instead of continuing down the hall. The first thing I do is head for the bar and pour myself a drink, hoping to cool my overheated libido. What I need more than anything is to dull my senses and calm the desire threatening to harden me once again so soon after coming. Images of fucking her and filling her with my cum, of claiming her completely, filter through my head.
The first sip isn’t enough to rid me of the mental image of a pregnant Caterina, her body swollen, thanks to the life growing inside her. The life I placed there. It’s too enticing to dismiss that image, and I allow it to percolate in my imagination as I sip my scotch and pace the room.
Sweet, trusting Caterina. Glowing, radiant, carrying my child. How perfect would that be? The very idea spreads warmth in my chest that has nothing to do with the drink in my hand. A pleasure that goes beyond the physical.
If I didn’t already know I was going to hell for the things I’ve done, I’d certainly earn a spot thanks to the direction my thoughts are running. The girl is twenty years my junior. She has her entire life ahead of her.
A future. A fucking boyfriend. I grit my teeth at the last thought. I want to kill the bastard. He doesn’t deserve her.Yet he’s the one who has her.
And here I sit, imagining myself claiming her. Owning her body, impregnating her, allowing her to carry the evidence of my claim for the world to see. There is no worthwhile excuse for that.
I turn my attention to the dark, silent grounds visible through the picture windows behind my desk. Even in the quiet, I know there are always eyes on the lookout for any signs of trouble. Guards are a constant presence, not just for my own protection, but for my daughter’s. She shouldn’t have to suffer because of the dangerous world I’m part of.
My thoughts drift back to Caterina. How could I possibly consider involving her in this life? She’s so much younger than me. Could I trust her to keep my secrets or follow my commands for her own safety?
Opening myself up to her feels risky, especially given my past experiences. I’ve trusted only one other woman before, and it ended badly. The idea of Caterina being pregnant terrifies me, a nightmare I fear becoming reality. Yet, the desire to claim her, to make her mine, burns intensely within me.
The answer is simple. I couldn’t ever trust her. But that won’t stop me from entertaining the idea of storming into my daughter’s bedroom to find her. Dragging her down the hall to my bedroom so I can tie her to the bed and make sure she can’t escape while I feast on her pussy until she passes out.
No doubt she’d seize up in fear, terrified at the prospect of the big, bad, dangerous villain she’s secretly lusted after finally giving her what she’s desired all this time. I can almost hear her sharp, rapid breathing in my ear. The tiny gasps and barely stifled moans she’d make while I woke her body with my hands, lips, and tongue.
She would learn how dangerous it is to play with fire, to confess to the dark desires she’s entertained. It would’ve been better for both of us if she’d walked away tonight.
It’s too late now.
I’ll never forget the way she looked right fucking through me into the deep confines of my soul as she creamed on her fingers.
Fuck, my cock is hard all over again. I fall into my desk chair and set my drink aside in favor of pulling myself from my shorts. How long has it been since anyone or anything has excited me enough to get me hard so soon after coming? I honestly can’t remember. I’m that jaded, not to mention no longer as young as I used to be.
The ringing phone on my desk startles me, and unnecessary guilt pierces my chest the instant I identify the number on the screen. Of all the times for my ex to call. It’s like she knows I’m enjoying myself and wants to bring an end to it.
Sometimes, I wonder what I saw in her. How could I have been so blind? How did I miss the emptiness in her? An endless cave of screaming misery which she disguised with a tight body. I fell for it. Pussy will do that to a man, I suppose. A lesson I learned the hard way.
“Amalia,” I growl, cradling the receiver between my ear and shoulder. “To what do I owe the dubious pleasure?”
She’s silent long enough to make me wonder if she’s on the other end before muttering, “Oh, hello. I didn’t expect you to answer.”
I blink slowly. What the fuck? “You called at two in the morning, assuming I wouldn’t be awake to answer, huh? Why? So you could leave a voicemail like a coward?” It’s all too predictable. “Don’t you know better by now than to underestimate me?”
“How’s the weather up there on your high horse? I had a busy day and only now had the opportunity to call. I imagine Tatiana’s still out celebrating. How did the graduation go?”
“You realize you could’ve witnessed it for yourself, don’t you? She set a ticket aside for her loving mother to attend the ceremony.”
The silence on the other end of the call speaks volumes. My ex’s mind is not the mystery she wishes to believe it is. It infuriates her, knowing I find it easy to read her thoughts—or at least the selfish motivations at the core of her behavior.
While she silently scrambles for a worthwhile excuse, I prompt, “Let me guess. You forgot about it.”
“And what if I did?”
“If you’re so determined to avoid responsibility, then you’d need serious professional help. Our daughter tried reaching out to you multiple times.”
“Do you even understand how many—”
“If I can remember an event amidst everything else, you should certainly manage it.”
“Did you ever think it was you I was trying to avoid?” She has a knack for twisting any situation to her advantage. Is that the sound of her sniffling? Of course, it is. She’s a pro at manipulating the narrative.
“If I can put the past aside for Tatiana’s sake, so can you.” As she starts spewing more excuses, I cut her off with a growl. “Forget it. Tatiana didn’t need you today, and she’s probably figured out by now that she can’t count on you.”
She scoffs. “Oh, and you’re the perfect father?”
Not by a long shot. I’ve faltered in more ways than I care to admit. I’m not the picture-perfect, sentimental father you’d see on a sitcom. That’s not me.
But I hope my daughter knows she can rely on me, that my main concern is her well-being and happiness. I keep her shielded from the darker sides of my life, as many parents do when their work isn’t exactly family-friendly. I may not be the affectionate type, but I believe I’m a good parent.
“I’m a damn good parent, and we both know it. Even if I weren’t, at least I’m trying.” The line goes silent for a moment before I continue. “And since you’ve apparently forgotten so much, let me refresh your memory.”
I lower my voice to a threatening growl. “We both know you’re avoiding signing the paperwork you’ve conveniently forgotten. Here’s a nugget of advice: dealing with your stalling is less convenient than having you removed. Do you understand?”
“Is that a threat?” She laughs, but I can hear the fear in her voice. She knows I’m not entirely bluffing. If anyone knows what I’m capable of, it’s her. When it comes to protecting my daughter and my business, I’ll go to any lengths—even those that could land me in serious trouble.
“A little reminder,” I murmur. “Hear that ticking in the back of your mind? It’s not your biological clock—though that must be screaming by now. It’s the ticking that started the moment those papers arrived at your door. My offer isn’t going to get any better. This is your last chance. Sign them, or you’ll see just how unpleasant I can be.”
“Ooo, I’m trembling,” she taunts.
“The clock is ticking,” I reiterate, ignoring her attempts to provoke me. I have more pressing concerns than getting dragged into a petty argument. I end the call abruptly and head to the private bathroom in my office to relieve myself. Amalia is a chapter I can’t completely erase from my life, though she did give me Tatiana—the greatest gift I’ve ever received.
But she’s part of the past.
My thoughts quickly shift: does this mean Caterina is the future?
I catch my reflection in the mirror. Hot water steams up the glass as I watch the battle unfold between the angel and devil on my shoulders. The lines on my forehead show the weight of my struggle.
This feels fundamentally wrong, on a level deeper than anything I’ve done before.
No matter how hard I try, I can’t get Caterina out of my mind. The idea of having her won’t leave me. It was hard enough resisting her before I saw her watching me.
Now? The word “impossible” comes to mind.
Swipe up to continue