Caterina
“Let me make sure I’ve got this right,” Tatiana says, leaning over the center console, her elbow squeaking on the leather while she tries to steady a glass of champagne.
She flicks her blond hair out of her face, eyes glossy with all the toasts she insisted we attend. “You just graduated, and your boyfriend of five years didn’t show up to the ceremony… and didn’t spend the night with you after?”
I press my teeth together, a smile that isn’t a smile. Her bluntness always lands like a slap—accurate, stinging, impossible to ignore. Five parties later, I feel like I clapped for everyone else’s shining life while mine hovered at the edge, dim and not entirely mine.
“He had to work early,” I say, repeating the line Luciano feeds me when he wants to be unassailable. “He’s trying to be responsible.”
“An adult asks for the day off for something important,” she says, shrugging. “He knew your date for months. I don’t buy it, Caterina.”
There’s no answer that will satisfy her or soothe the ache I’ve already rehearsed in private. I don’t know why I stay. Fear of the empty space if I let go? Habit dressed up as loyalty? Hope that’s thin as thread?
“Hey,” I say, pivoting because I can’t stand the mirror she’s holding up. “His absence means I get you all night. And… your boyfriend isn’t joining us either.”
Her smile falters. “Yeah. We’re both unlucky.” A beat. “He had other things to do.”
She doesn’t elaborate. Maybe he didn’t either.
Roger turned the wheel, guiding us onto the long road to the Rossetti estate. My stomach tightens the way it always does when we approach this place—like the air changes density. The stone wall rises out of the dark; a guard lifts the gate with a nod. On the other side, the world is manicured and watchful. There’s so much land that even the bodyguards live in little houses like chess pawns along the perimeter.
It’s my favorite stage for a fantasy I never speak aloud.
Gianni Rossetti. Dangerous in the way that makes men careful and women straighten without meaning to. My father—Detective, capital D—calls him a headache with a smile that doesn’t reach his eyes. He says Rossetti Explosives is the clean suit draped over a mess of mob ties. He warns me. He always warns me. And still, the thought of Gianni’s voice, rough and low, has lived under my skin since I was a teenager and realized power wasn’t just a word, it was a temperature.
Tatiana drains her glass and blinks at me. “What were we talking about?” She taps her chin. “Right. Luke the jerk.”
“He’s not a jerk,” I say, out of reflex.
Maybe if I repeat it enough, it’ll be true. Maybe words can sand down edges.
“He is,” she insists. “It’s your graduation day, your once-in-a-lifetime. He knew your dad invited him to dinner. He couldn’t make one night happen?”
“He had to cover a shift,” I say, softer. “The gym is a big investment. If he wants to take it over, he has to be serious.”
“Serious people still show up for the person they love.” She burps, mortified, then laughs. “Sorry. I just hate watching you get hurt.”
“I’m not hurt,” I lie, because the hurt is strange—dull where it should be sharp. What does it mean when a person you’ve built a future with can’t pierce you? What does that say about the future?
The driver parks in front of the main entrance like we’re arriving at a quiet hotel. He’s already out, opening the door with a little bow that Tatiana always pretends to hate. I grab my overnight bag and step aside so she can climb out without flashing the world. She sways.
We slip into the cool quiet of the house. Peace lives here—polished floors, expensive restraint, the hum of expensive machines behind the walls. My father’s house is small and warm and crowded with questions. This one holds its breath.
“Should’ve eaten,” Tatiana mutters, leaning heavier.
“You had half a sandwich.” I park her on a kitchen stool, fish out a granola bar and water, and press them into her hands. “Help yourself before your stomach files a complaint.”
Then we climb the hall, our footsteps echoing. “Is your dad home?” I ask, trying not to sound like I’m asking about the weather and also the storm.
“He’s working,” she whispers. “Always.”
He said after lunch he’d be late. He’s always late. Not the careless kind—late like he belongs to a thousand hungers and this house is only one of them.
Rossetti Explosives looks legal on paper. The paper lies in neat stacks while men with guns live on the property. My father’s mouth flattens every time he says the name. He wants handcuffs. He gets press releases.
In the bathroom, I sit Tatiana on the closed toilet lid and slide a cotton pad over her lash line. She sighs, eyes half-closed. “I don’t deserve you, C.”
“Don’t start.” I smile and keep my hand gentle. “We take turns. That’s how friendship works.”
“No sickness tonight,” she promises, trying for a joke. It lands fragile and sweet.
I get her into pajamas, then into bed. By the time I’m finished washing my face and brushing out my hair, the room is silvery with moonlight. I slide into my side of the bed. The mattress dips; Tatiana turns toward me.
“It’s just me,” I whisper.
“I know,” she says, a small, sleepy smile. “Sorry.”
“For what?”
“For giving you a hard time about Luciano. You’re right. Christopher isn’t a prize either.” Her voice thins. “Sometimes I don’t even think he likes me.”
It startles me. Tatiana’s armor is flashy, but it’s armor all the same.
“I’m sure he does,” I say, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. “What’s not to like?”
“You know what I mean. He’s hot and cold. One minute I’m the only person in the room. The next I’m… noise.” She stares past me. “It’s confusing.”
“How long has it been like that?” I ask, because if he’s making her small, I want a list and a plan.
“Not long.” A beat. “I’m worried there’s someone else.”
“Someone else?” I blink. “He’d be an idiot. If he is, better to know.”
“I’m hoping France fixes us,” she murmurs, eyes closing. “A month together.”
“I hope so,” I say softly, though a month can magnify whatever already exists. If he hurts her in another country, there won’t be enough air in the world.
Her breathing evens. I lie awake, pulse still loud from the day. I did it—I graduated. Dad was incandescent. “You’re lucky to have a job lined up,” he said, pride tightening his voice.
Lucky. The word sits oddly. Economics felt safe. Safe job. Safe boyfriend. Safe future. Safe is a room where nothing breaks—and nothing catches fire. Lately I keep wondering who decided I don’t get flames.
It’s like I’m performing a play someone else wrote. I can pace faster or slower, but the set pieces don’t move. The exit is painted on.
Enough. A snack, some tea, a breath in the dark.
I slide out of bed without waking Tatiana and pad into the hall. I try not to think Gianni’s name, but it’s too late—the syllables are a key I keep hidden under my tongue. He has a presence that makes rooms correct themselves. He rarely smiles with his mouth, but sometimes the lines beside his eyes soften like a secret only he hears. Tattoos under his cuffs. A scar along his knuckle. The way he watches the world like he already knows the end of it. I have imagined standing close enough to feel the heat of him and what it would be like to be chosen by a man who never needs to explain himself.
He will never know. He’s my best friend’s father, decades older, a man my father would arrest if he could. The crush is a private religion—no congregation, no confession.
The kitchen is dim, the patio lights beyond the sliding doors casting a faint glow across the marble. I open the fridge. Everything is symmetrical and fresh. I consider tea, then reach for a yogurt smoothie like I’m choosing ease over ritual. I twist off the cap and sit at the island, tracing the grain of the wood with my fingertip.
“Safe,” I mouth, and the word feels like a small, locked box.
Then I hear it.
Not a voice. A sound that erases everything else—low, breathless, unmistakable. A moan. Another follows, longer. The hairs at the back of my neck rise. I hold the bottle midway to my lips and forget to breathe.
Somewhere in this quiet, curated house, someone is not being safe at all.
Swipe up to continue
As we walk to Tatiana’s room, our footsteps echoing on the polished floor, she answers my unspoken question about her father.
“He’s working. Always working,” she whispers. “He said he had important things to do tonight. I doubt he’s even home yet.”
He’s always working. After lunch, he mentioned he’d be home late, so Tatiana is probably right. Running a business like Rossetti Explosives, which appears legitimate but is deeply entwined with mob activities, must be exhausting. The layers of protection around the family’s dealings frustrate my father, who can only watch from the sidelines.
Once we reach the bedroom, I guide her into the bathroom and sit her on the closed toilet lid so I can remove her makeup. Her eyes are half-closed, but she gives me a grateful smile, likely relieved she won’t wake up with mascara smudged on her face. “I don’t deserve you, C.”
“Don’t say that,” I reply as I soak a cotton ball with makeup remover and gently wipe her eyes. “We’re friends, and that means being there for each other, even when it’s just holding your hair back while you’re sick.”
Her lips curl into a shy smile. “No sickness tonight.”
I return her smile as I finish cleaning her face. Then I help her change into pajamas and settle her into bed before changing into my own sleepwear.
“It would be wise to eat something before you...” I stop as I see her asleep, her soft snores filling the room. I place the granola bar and two Advil on the nightstand. I had hoped to find some relief from my frustration with my boyfriend through drinking tonight, but taking care of Tatiana, as she has taken care of me, kept me in check.
With Tatiana asleep, I use the restroom, wash my face, and brush out my long, brunette hair. The only light in the room comes from the moon shining through the windows, and I let out a deep sigh. I have a strange longing for the dark, a desire to escape the reality of what it hides.
When I climb into bed on my side, Tatiana stirs. “It’s just me,” I whisper.
“I know. I’m not that drunk,” she responds, turning to face me and fluffing a pillow under her head. “I’m sorry.”
“For what, being drunk?”
“For giving you a hard time about Luciano. You’re right,” she admits with a sigh. “Christopher isn’t much better. Sometimes, I don’t even think he likes me.”
It’s unusual for her to be so vulnerable, and her admission reveals that it’s been bothering her for some time.
“I’m sure he does like you,” I reassure her, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear and patting her cheek. “What’s not to like about you?”
“You know what I mean. He’s so inconsistent. One minute he’s loving and sweet, and the next he acts like I’m a burden. It’s confusing and hurtful.”
I feel a pang of concern for her. “How long has this been happening?” Christopher has always seemed distant—quiet and reserved, almost perfect. But if he’s treating her poorly, that needs to be addressed.
She looks away, then meets my gaze again. “Not long. I’m worried he might be seeing someone else.”
“Someone else?” I’m taken aback. This is the first I’ve heard of this. “I don’t think he’s foolish enough to let go of someone like you. And if he is, maybe it’s for the best.”
“I’m hoping our trip to France will fix things,” she says, her eyes closing as sleep starts to take over. “A whole month together.”
“I’m sure things will work out,” I say softly, though I wonder if spending a month with a detached boyfriend is the best plan. I’d hate to see him abandon her in another country, and if he hurts her... I can only imagine the fallout from her father and Roger.
With that on my mind, I know sleep will be elusive. Plus, I’m still wired from the whirlwind of parties, socializing, and the fact that I graduated. I did it. I smile at the thought, feeling a deep sense of pride. But despite that achievement, I feel emptier and sadder than I expected.
I worked hard, earned good grades, applied for internships, and went through interviews. My father was beaming all day, bragging about my upcoming job.
“You’re very fortunate to have secured a job so quickly,” he said.
But I don’t feel fortunate. I feel trapped, like my life is on a track with only one direction. I chose a career in economics for its safety—safe job, safe boyfriend.
Safe. Safe. Safe.
I’m technically in control of my life, but it feels more like I’m performing a carefully rehearsed play. I can only adjust the speed, but the direction remains fixed—there’s no changing course or turning back.
With a sigh, I try to reason with my own frustration, knowing that overthinking will only make me more miserable. I push back the covers, getting out of bed slowly to avoid waking Tatiana. Maybe a cup of tea and a snack will help clear my mind.
As I step out of Tatiana’s room, my thoughts shift. I try not to dwell on Gianni—where he might be or who he might be with. The truth is, I’ve nursed a secret crush on him for years, but he’s unaware of it, and it’s unlikely anything will ever come of these unspoken feelings. He’s my best friend’s much older, captivatingly mysterious father, and that’s where it ends.
The stark reality hits me: Gianni will never know how I feel. I have Luciano and a secure job lined up. I should be content, but instead, I feel restless. Is it wrong to yearn for happiness when it seems so elusive? It can vanish as easily as cotton candy dissolves under a drop of water. I’ve always been taught to seek stability and security—a mantra my father has repeated for as long as I can remember.
“Happiness comes after securing the basics and more. It comes from feeling safe,” I can almost hear my father’s deep voice saying.
The kitchen is dim when I reach it, illuminated only by the patio lights filtering through the sliding glass door. I navigate to the fridge, trying to push aside thoughts of Gianni. He probably doesn’t even know I exist beyond being Tatiana’s friend.
I open the fridge to find it stocked with fresh produce. I consider making tea but am drawn instead to a pre-made yogurt smoothie.
Despite my mood, I grab the smoothie and settle onto a stool at the island in the middle of the kitchen. The space is sleek and elegant, with its gray and blue tones and dark wood accents. It’s a far cry from the cozy, two-story home my father owns.
As I twist off the cap and take a sip, my enjoyment is abruptly interrupted by a sound. Not a voice, but a series of moans, unmistakable and intense.
Swipe up to continue
Scanning the patio and pool for the source of the moans, my first thought is that it could be Tatiana, but that’s not possible—she’s completely out of it. These aren’t distressed sounds; they’re filled with intense passion.
My gaze is drawn to one of the lounge chairs by the pool. The underwater lights cast a faint glow, revealing a sight I missed earlier.
About twenty feet away, Gianni is engaged with a woman I don’t recognize. He’s kneeling at the foot of the chair, and she’s sprawled out before him. My face flushes with embarrassment, and though I know I should look away, I can’t. I watch as he moves his face toward her, his intentions unmistakable.
I press a hand to my mouth, trying to stifle a gasp. Gianni’s hands grip her thighs firmly as he performs oral sex. A forbidden desire begins to stir within me. Gianni, always the epitome of sexiness, has been the subject of countless fantasies, but I’ve never seen him in such a raw, intimate moment. His usual persona—professional, commanding, and intense—now takes on a new dimension.
Jealousy and desire mix inside me as I observe him. The woman’s moans fill the air, and I can only imagine the sensation of his tongue against her. The scene is almost too much to bear.
“Oh god! Gianni. Yes! More!” she cries out, her pleasure clear in her voice.
Gianni’s experience and patience are evident. He’s a man who could undoubtedly bring intense pleasure. The sight of his strong, tattooed torso and dripping swim trunks adds to my growing heat.
My cheeks burn with shame, and I know I should leave. It’s wrong to watch, and they have no idea I’m here. But my feet won’t move. The fantasy of being noticed, of being in her place, consumes me. I watch as Gianni’s hands slide over her, his touch eliciting more cries of pleasure from her.
“Fuck. It feels so good,” she moans, her body trembling with ecstasy.
My heart races. I need to escape before I’m seen. They’re preoccupied now, but if they catch me, the embarrassment would be unbearable.
Move, now.
And yet, my feet remain frozen. My eyes are locked on Gianni, unable to look away. My nipples press painfully against the fabric of my nightshirt, and an intense, consuming arousal grips me, even though no one has touched me.
The woman continues to moan as Gianni skillfully pleasures her. Her legs are draped over his shoulders, and his actions are causing her to cry out with pleasure.
“Gianni… yes. Yes! Yes!” she breathes heavily.
I try to rationalize this as no different from watching explicit content online. I’m not doing anything wrong, right? He’s just my best friend’s father.
He pulls back from her breasts and slides a hand between her legs, exposing her completely. My breath quickens, and a wave of desire floods me. I’m astonished I haven’t made a mess on the seat.
Luciano has never touched me like this. Gianni’s intensity and the way he’s pleasuring her make me ache with longing. He inserts two fingers into her, stretching her, and I can almost feel those same fingers inside me. I watch his face, focused and intense, as he continues.
The urge to touch myself grows overwhelming, and when he leans back down, I have to bite my lip to hold back a moan.
I’m drenched in need, helpless against my desire for someone completely unattainable.
I shift uncomfortably, my thighs rubbing together, amplifying the ache. The only remedy seems to be giving in, but I can’t. It feels so wrong.
The patio lights catch on Gianni’s dark hair and bare skin. He’s usually so stoic and unyielding, but now his focus on the woman makes his intensity even more striking.
How many times have I dreamed of this?
Except, I was the woman he was fucking, taming, taking pleasure from. I wonder if the rumors are true? That he fucks as dirty as he fights.
It should be me.
My body he’s touching, licking, kissing.
My clit he licks while his thick, strong fingers ruins my pussy. I wish I could see his cock, but he’s still clothed from the waist down. In my fantasies, I’ve imagined his cock to be immense, his girth thick, thanks to the tempting outline in his suit pants.
I can’t count how many times I’ve caught myself staring at him. All I could think was… would he break me as he pushed inside? His massive cock becoming too much for my little pussy to handle. I shudder, the pressure in my core too intense to be ignored. The sight of his body, the moans of the woman he’s feasting on. It’s wreaking havoc on my fragile libido.
Oh god. I know I shouldn't be doing this. It's wrong, undeniably wrong. But I never claimed to be a saint, did I? The ache of desire is nearly unbearable, and I need to find relief. Even though it’s wrong, the need is consuming. Slipping a hand under my nightshirt, I mimic Gianni’s actions with the blonde, rolling my nipple between my fingers. The pleasure that follows is intense, filling me with an urgent craving. I imagine my fingers are his, the rough texture against my sensitive skin.
As I focus on Gianni’s other hand, moving rhythmically, the forbidden nature of it heightens my arousal. My instincts scream for me to flee, but I can’t bring myself to move.
Spreading my legs further, I prop one foot on the stool and slide my other hand beneath my thong. I part my lips, letting my tongue graze over them, and guide my fingers through my own wetness, imagining they are his.
This is so wrong. It feels filthy. What is happening to me?
I’ve struggled with my feelings for years, knowing this could jeopardize my friendship with Tatiana. But right now, I can’t stop. I don’t want to, especially when pretending I’m the one Gianni is pleasuring brings me such intense satisfaction. If I can experience this while watching the man I’ve fantasized about, I will.
“Don’t stop!” the woman gasps, nearing her climax. “Oh god, yes… just like that! I’m about t
o come! Please, don’t stop!”
As she cries out, her body convulses in the throes of an overwhelming orgasm. I watch in envy, having never experienced such intensity myself.
It’s all because of him—Gianni. If only he noticed me, if only he could make me feel the way he’s making that woman feel. My body tenses, my clit throbbing, my heartbeat pounding in my ears. I’m so close. I can feel the heat and wetness slipping down my thighs. My body is begging for something I can’t have. I press harder, faster, needing the friction just right. This is wrong, so wrong, but the pleasure is overwhelming.
My body is on the edge, every muscle wound tight. I can’t stop—oh god, I’m about to come, and it feels so incredible. My eyes flutter shut, goosebumps spreading across my skin as my hips lift, craving something more. And then, with a gasp, I shatter, a wave of euphoria washing over me. I wish so desperately that it was Gianni’s touch filling me.
A single name escapes my lips, barely a whisper. “Gianni…”
He shouldn’t be able to hear me. There’s no way he could. I’m hidden in the darkness. But as I slowly open my eyes, I see his head snap up. My heart races even faster, the remnants of my orgasm still coursing through me. In the dim light, our gazes seem to lock, though he can only see the sliding glass door.
The floor feels like it’s giving way beneath me as his lips curl into a knowing smirk. He must see something—something I didn’t think was possible. We’re locked in this moment, a moment I’ve yearned for, but never thought would happen.
My legs are weak, my chest heaving, and my fingers slick with the evidence of what I’ve done. I should be filled with shame, but instead, I’m overwhelmed by the thrill of his gaze on me.
He can’t see me. He mustn’t.
But the smirk on his face suggests otherwise. And I can’t shake the feeling that he’s aware of exactly what’s happening.
Swipe up to continue