[Maddie’s POV]
I'm watching Emily only for strategic reasons.
That's the story I'm telling myself, anyway, and I've always been excellent at stories. Know your competition. Anticipate her moves. Study her weaknesses before she can exploit yours.
The problem is that my attention keeps snagging on things that have nothing to do with strategy.
The line of her throat when she tilts her head back to stretch. The way she bites her lower lip during difficult sequences. The way her ass looks in those practice leggings that should be illegal in at least forty-eight states.
It's fucking irritating.
It's deeply, profoundly irritating, and I can't seem to make it stop.
She's running through her footwork sequence again, and I should be cataloging technical flaws but I can’t stop noticing the flush that spreads across her cheekbones when she pushes herself.
The tendons in her forearms. The flex of her thigh muscles. The set of her jaw.
Then she does this thing where she arches her back during a spiral, and my brain just... stops. Like someone pulled the plug.
"Maddie!" Jenna's voice hits me like a bucket of ice water. "Are you even listening?"
She's waving her phone in my face, showing me something from the new Prada collection. I haven't actually looked because I'm too busy having a sexuality crisis over my former best friend's hip flexibility.
"Gorgeous," I say automatically. "Love the... details."
"Right? It's from spring’s preview. Daddy's friend got me early access."
She launches into a story about private shopping and salespeople who recognize her by her follower count, and I make appropriate rich-girl noises while my eyes track Emily across the ice.
She skates past us toward the water station in front of me, she's close enough that I can smell her—clean sweat and something floral underneath. She pauses to drink, throat working, and I'm having thoughts that would make a nun blush.
"My mom's been looking at their resort collection," I offer, because silence would be suspicious. "Something about a trunk show next month."
My actual mother has never attended a trunk show in her life. She clips coupons and shops end-of-season sales and pretends we don't notice the worry lines deepening around her eyes every time tuition bills arrive.
This is the game I play now. Ice princess with the trust fund and the perfect life.
Never mind that my designer bag is a really good fake from Canal Street.
Never mind that my "trust fund" is actually two part-time jobs and a scholarship I can't afford to lose.
Never mind that underneath all this carefully constructed perfection is just Madison. The girl who wore hand-me-down skates and whose dad still has grease permanently embedded under his fingernails.
I could play this game blindfolded. One-upmanship disguised as friendship, status measured in designer labels and casual name-drops.
I hate every second of it. I'm also very, very fucking good at it.
But then Emily, who probably eavesdropped, opens her mouth and ruins everything.
"Hey, Maddie," she says, casual as a grenade. "Did your dad switch careers?"
The words land like ice water down my spine. Jenna's eyes light up like a shark sensing blood in the water with immediate, predatory interest.
No. No no no no no.
The question is seemingly out of nowhere. Except I see her logic perfectly.
And not only I.
"He considered it," I say, my smile perfectly calibrated. "But the family business took off, and you know how it is. Hard to walk away from success."
The family business. That's a nice way of describing my father's auto repair shop.
Her expression flickers with something like confusion, but she doesn't push. Just takes another drink and skates away, leaving me to deal with Jenna's laser focus.
"You two have history," she says, voice honey-sweet and laced with venom. "Childhood besties. How adorable."
"Ancient history. We were kids." I examine my manicure like this conversation is beneath me. "She barely remembers anything real."
Lie. She remembers everything.
She remembers the girl you killed to become Maddie.
She remembers everything and that ignites something ugly inside me.
The rest of practice passes in a blur of drills and corrections. I hit every mark, land every jump, smile at Coach's feedback like the model captain I'm supposed to be.
I wait until the locker room empties too slowly. Girls filter out in twos and threes, chattering about weekend plans and dining hall food. I take my time, organizing my bag, checking my phone. Waiting.
Finally, it's just Emily and me.
She’s at her locker, back to me, humming something under her breath like she doesn't have a care in the world.
Like she didn't just casually mention my father's business in front of Jenna, whose father literally owns half of downtown and whose mother chronicles their wealth on Instagram like it's her job.
"What the fuck was that?"
My voice cuts through the quiet like a blade. Emily turns slowly, and meets my eyes with that steady, unafraid gaze that makes me want to shake her.
"What was what?" She leans against her locker. "You'll have to be more specific."
"You know exactly what." I step closer, hands clenched. "Asking about my dad's 'career switch' in front of everyone?"
"Oh, that." She shrugs. "It was a simple question. I remembered him talking about maybe going into consulting or something."
"Bullshit." The word comes out sharp. "You knew exactly what you were doing."
Emily studies me for a moment, head tilted, before her expression shifts, understanding dawning.
"Holy shit." She laughs, but it's not kind. "You're actually pretending he did switch careers, aren't you? What did you tell them? That he's some big shot now? Investment banking? Tech startup?"
My silence is answer enough.
"Oh my god, Madison." She draws out my full name like it tastes bitter. "You're really selling the whole rich girl fantasy, aren't you? Designer clothes, family business success story... Let me guess, you've got a trust fund too?"
"Shut up."
"Does anyone know?" She pushes off her locker, moving closer. "The Maddie who wore hand-me-down skates until they literally fell apart? Who brought PB&J every day because the rink snack bar was too expensive?"
"I said shut up."
But she's right in front of me now, eyes blazing.
"God, you must be exhausted. Keeping up this charade every single day."
Something in me snaps.
I grab my skate from the bench, and before I can think, before I can stop myself, I'm pressing her back hard against the lockers. The blade comes up, stopping just below her throat.
"Listen very carefully," I whisper in her face, and my voice shakes with rage. "You're going to forget everything you think you know about me. About my family. About my past. Because if you don't, if you say one more word about any of it, I will end you."
Emily's eyes are wide, but there's no fear in them. If anything, she looks... intrigued?
"You're going to cut me, Maddie?" Her voice is low, rough. "Right here, in the locker room?"
The blade trembles slightly in my hand. We're so close I can feel her breath on my face, see her pulse jumping wild in her throat. One of her hands comes up, wraps around my wrist.
Not pushing the blade away. Just... holding. Her voice is steady, maybe a little breathless, when she speaks again.
"How exactly are you going to end me? Social assassination? Mean girl tactics? Or are you actually planning to kill me?"
"I have ways," I manage, but my hand is trembling now.
"No, you don't." She shifts slightly, and somehow we're even closer. "You're all talk, Madison. All performance. Just like everything else about Maddie Reyes."
"You don't know me anymore."
"I knew you better than anyone." Her voice drops, goes soft in a way that's worse than anger.
"That girl doesn't exist," I whisper.
Emily’s thumb brushes against my pulse point and there’s something like sadness, or loss maybe in her eyes. "Was it worth it?"
The question hangs between us, and for one horrible moment, I want to tell her the truth.
That I hate who I've become. That I'm drowning in my own lies. That seeing her again makes me remember what it felt like to be real.
I drop the skate and it clatters against the floor, the sound echoing in the empty room.
"Stay away from me," I say, stepping back. "And keep your mouth shut about my past."
I leave without waiting for her response. My hands are shaking. My pulse is doing something erratic and unwelcome. I push through the locker room door and walk fast toward the exit, not running, never running.
I'm furious at Emily for existing, for remembering, for standing there like she could see straight through every wall I've built.
But I'm more furious at myself.
For starting this charade years ago. For not knowing how to stop. For the way my body betrayed me in that moment, leaning toward her like she was something I wanted instead of something I needed to destroy.
Swipe up to continue
[Emily’s POV]
Move-in day arrives with aggressive sunshine that feels like a personal attack.
I'm dragging my sad collection of belongings across campus, already regretting every life choice that led to this moment. The housing assignment clutched in my sweaty hand reads: Room 412, Bennett Hall. Roommate: 1.
Just a number. Not even a name.
Well, at least I’m not gonna be sharing a room with the entire team.
Bennett Hall is one of those ivy-covered brick situations that looks great in the brochures and feels like a Victorian prison in real life. Fourth floor, no elevator. Of course.
By the time I reach room 412, I'm sweating like I've run a marathon in hell. I unlock the door, bracing myself for the standard dorm horror show—mysterious stains, that specific smell of institutional despair, possibly a ghost or two.
Instead, I find... aesthetic?
One side of the room already looks like a lifestyle blogger's wet dream.
A year's worth of someone's life, tasteful and curated—coordinated bedding, framed photos, a small succulent on the desk that somehow looks expensive.
The bare side waits for me like an afterthought.
I claim my territory and start unpacking. Clothes in the tiny closet. Toiletries on my shelf. The physical act of arranging possessions is meditative. This is my space now. I can make this work, whoever my roommate turns out to be.
Then I hear the door open behind me. I turn, and the universe reveals its punchline.
Maddie stands in the doorway, iced coffee in hand, frozen mid-step like someone hit pause on a video. Her expression cycles through recognition, disbelief, and something almost like fear before settling into careful blankness.
A long, horrible silence stretches between us.
We stare at each other. Time stops. Somewhere, God is laughing his ass off.
"You have got to be fucking kidding me," I say, because apparently my mouth has elected itself spokesperson for this disaster.
"This is my room." Her voice could freeze hell. "I had a single last year. This is a mistake."
"Well, unless I suddenly can't read, this paper says 412." I wave my housing assignment like a white flag that's actually a declaration of war. "Surprise, roomie."
She's already pulling out her phone, fingers flying across the screen. "I'm calling housing. Right now. This is not happening."
I watch her pace while she talks, using her phone voice—the one that sounds like she's about to ask to speak to a manager. Watch her face go from determined to desperate to defeated as whoever's on the other end delivers what is clearly not the news she wants to hear.
She hangs up and stands there for a moment, looking like someone just told her she has to live in a room with her worst enemy.
Which, I guess, is exactly what happened.
"Let me guess," I say, going for casual and landing somewhere around bitter. "We're stuck with each other?"
"Until spring semester. At the earliest." Each word sounds like it's being forcibly extracted from her soul. "They're at capacity."
Of course we are.
"So we're stuck." I state the obvious because someone has to.
"Apparently." The word sounds like it costs her something to say. Like admitting defeat in a war she didn't know she was fighting.
I try to be mature about it. Really.
I suggest boundaries, schedules, a DMZ down the middle of the room. Maddie responds in monosyllables, already constructing an invisible wall between us that might as well be made of concrete and spite.
But my eyes keep wandering to her side of the room.
A pink throw blanket draped over her chair. Motivational prints in rose gold frames. Then I notice a stuffed otter, perched on her perfect pink bedding like it owns the place.
A fucking stuffed otter.
"Since when do you like otters?" I hear myself say.
Maddie stiffens, her hand freezing mid-gesture. "What?"
"The otter." I point at the offending plushie. "It's cute, though I don't remember you being into them. And all this pink. Very interesting choices for someone who once declared—and I quote—'Pink is for ones who have no personality.' Age eleven."
Her face does this thing where I can actually see her remembering. See the exact moment she realizes I haven't forgotten a single fucking thing about her.
The mask slips for just a second, and there's my Madison—caught, exposed, real.
Then Maddie slams back into place.
"People change, Emily. It's called growing up." Her voice is arctic. "Not that you'd know anything about that."
"Excuse me?"
"You heard me." She crosses her arms, fully committed to this fight now. "Still running from mommy's expectations? Still so desperate to escape that you'd transfer schools just to avoid dealing with your actual problems?"
The words hit like a slap with a side of brass knuckles.
She remembers.
Every secret I told her, every fear I shared when we were kids and she was my whole world—she kept them all. And now she's weaponizing them like emotional grenades.
"At least I'm not cosplaying as someone else," I snapped back. "At least I don't need to lie about who my dad is or where I come from for people who don't actually care about me. Pink throw blankets, Maddie? Rose gold frames? This room looks like a Pinterest board threw up."
"Better than looking like someone who peaked at middle school and never recovered."
"Peaked?" I'm fully yelling now. "Sorry I didn't realize the goal was to become completely fucking unrecognizable. Who are you trying to impress? Jenna? The other girls who talk behind your back the second you leave?"
"You don't know anything about my life here."
Her voice is defensive, brittle around the edges.
"I know you're lying to everyone. I know your dad still owns an auto repair shop, not some 'family business' that 'took off.' I know you used to cry when your mom made you wear dresses. I know—"
"Stop." Her voice cracks. Actually cracks, and for a moment she looks exactly like the twelve-year-old who hugged me goodbye and promised to write. "Just fucking stop."
"Why? Because the truth is inconvenient for Maddie Reyes, team captain?" I can't stop now, even though I've gone too far. "Because you've spent so long pretending to be someone else that you forgot who you actually are?"
"You don't get to do this." Her eyes are bright, furious. "You don't get to show up after eight years and act like you know me. That girl doesn't exist anymore. I killed her. I had to."
I try to interject, while something like pain flickers in her eyes, but she bulldozes right through it.
"You want to know what's really pathetic?" Her voice is rising now too. “You're still exactly the same. Still running from your problems. Still pretending you don't need anyone. Still so scared of connecting that you hide behind your skating like it's a fucking personality."
I open my mouth to defend myself, but she's not done yet.
"At least I'm trying to be someone!"
She's in my space now, close enough that I can see tears gathering in her eyes that she won't let fall.
"At least I built something, even if it's all bullshit! What have you built? What do you have besides a triple axel and a chip on your shoulder?"
The silence that follows is thick enough to choke on.
We're standing inches apart, both breathing hard, and I can feel the heat radiating off her skin. Can see her pulse jumping in her throat. Can catalog every freckle she's tried to cover with foundation.
"I had you," I say quietly. "I had my best friend. And then she decided I wasn't worth keeping."
Maddie stumbles back like I've physically pushed her. For a moment, she looks absolutely wrecked. Then she grabs her bag with shaking hands.
"I can't." She's backing toward the door. "I can't be here right now."
"Madison."
But she's gone, the door slams behind her before I can say something else.
I stand there for a long time, replaying every word, cataloging all the ways we hurt each other. The stuffed otter watches me from her pillow with glassy eyes, a silent witness to whatever just happened.
That night I lie awake in the dark. Maddie's side of the room is empty, her bed untouched.
Somehow, her absence is louder than any argument we could have.
Swipe up to continue
Living with Maddie Reyes requires the kind of precision usually reserved for defusing bombs or performing open-heart surgery. Except with significantly more passive-aggressive Post-it notes and a complex shower schedule.
We've developed an unspoken system that would impress military strategists and communicate like two strangers forced to share a prison cell, which isn't far from the truth.
The stuffed otter on her bed has become my nemesis. I swear it judges me with its glassy little eyes every time I accidentally look at Maddie's ass in those yoga pants she sleeps in.
Which is often.
Which is a problem and makes me question everything I thought I knew about myself.
Today at the rink, Coach Marquette has gathered both teams—figure skaters on one side, hockey players on the other.
It looks like an athletic West Side Story, minus the snapping and the murder. Everyone stands in uneasy clusters, eyeing the other team like we're about to be asked to share desserts.
Territorial mammals pretending to be civilized.
"Annual pre-season showcase," Coach announces, clipboard clutched like a weapon. "Donors, scouts, university board members. Each singles skater performs a short pairs routine with a hockey partner. It's a biennial tradition."
She pauses, letting this sink in while the fluorescent lights hum overhead like nervous witnesses.
The hockey guys lumber in looking lost without their armor, and I try to focus on them. Any of them. That one's cute, right? Tall, broad shoulders, the kind of guy I usually go for.
Feel something, I command myself. Feel literally anything.
Nothing. It's like looking at furniture with good bone structure.
"This year," Coach continues, "showcase performances will determine a new team captain."
The words land like stones in still water.
I watch Maddie's spine straighten, her fingers tightening almost imperceptibly on the boards. Her position isn't guaranteed anymore. The throne she's spent so long building suddenly has termites.
"Choose your partners," Coach continues. "Make it work."
The pairing frenzy begins immediately. Maddie moves like a heat-seeking missile toward hockey team captain Derek. Six feet of conventional attractiveness and the personality of wet cardboard.
Ava mentioned him briefly, as Maddie’s boyfriend, showed me a pic—he’s the type of handsome that you immediately forget.
He drapes himself around her like an expensive accessory someone forgot to remove the price tag from. They look like a catalog photo for privilege. His hand rests on her hip with the casual possessiveness of someone marking territory at a party.
"You're the triple axel girl."
I turn to find a guy with artfully messy black hair and the kind of smile that probably gets him out of speeding tickets. He's cute in that non-threatening way that makes mothers trust him with their daughters.
"Chris Nakamura," he says, extending a hand.
"Emily Harper."
"I volunteer as tribute." He grins wider. "Before you end up with Tyler, who has the grace of a caffeinated moose."
I glance at the remaining hockey players. One of them is literally wobbling on his blades like a newborn giraffe discovering gravity. Another seems to be having a quiet argument with his own feet.
"You make a compelling argument."
"I'm a philosophy major. Compelling arguments are my only marketable skill." He's friendly, a little awkward, seems genuinely nice.“Fair warning—I'm better at Kant than skating, but I promise not to drop you or discuss metaphysics mid-routine."
"Deal." I agree to the partnership before my brain can manufacture reasons to refuse and Chris looks relieved.
We shake on it, and I try not to notice Maddie watching us from across the rink.
***
That night, I'm organizing my desk when Maddie storms in.
"This is fucking BULLSHIT," she announces, throwing her bag with enough force to make the otter bounce in protest. "I've been captain for a YEAR. A whole year of my life dedicated to this team, and now one stupid showcase determines everything?"
"Sounds rough," I say, not looking up from my color-coded note cards.
"Don't." She whirls on me, eyes blazing. "Don't you dare act like you don't care. You want it. I can see it in your stupid face every time Coach compliments you."
"My stupid face?" I finally look up. "That's the best you've got? My stupid face?"
"Your... your stupidly talented face!" She's pacing now, like a caged cat. "Coming here with your perfect triple axel and your 'Oh, I'm just here to skate' act. You're trying to take everything I built!"
"Maddie." I put down my cards. "I literally just want to skate, qualify for Nationals and not die during competitions. Your queen bee throne is safe."
"Oh, fuck off," she hissed, all righteous fury and swinging ponytail. "Like you're not thrilled. Little Emily Harper, here to steal everything I've built with your “great talent” and your puppy dog eyes."
"Puppy dog eyes?" I spin in my chair to face her. "That's rich coming from someone who bats her eyelashes at Coach like she's auditioning for a mascara commercial."
"At least I don't throw myself at the first hockey player who shows interest." She's moved closer, hands on her hips. "Chris Nakamura? Really? He's like if vanilla ice cream was a person."
"Jealous?" The word slips out before I can stop it.
"Of what? Your disaster of a partnership?" She laughs, but it's sharp. "Please. Derek actually knows how to lead. Unlike your philosophy major who probably overthinks breathing."
"Right, because Derek's such a prize." I stand up, and suddenly we're too close. "Tell me, does he schedule his cheating around your practices, or does he just not care enough to hide it?"
Her face flushes red. "Excuse me?"
"You heard me. Everyone knows he hooks up with half the sophomore class. But sure, keep pretending he's your perfect boyfriend."
"At least I HAVE a boyfriend." She steps closer, and I can smell her perfume that still doing things to my brain. "What's your excuse? That perfect Emily isn't as straight as she pretends to be?"
The words hit like a slap and my whole body goes rigid. "What?"
"Oh, come on." She laughs, but it's sharp. "The way you look at me? The way you get all tense when I'm near? Classic baby gay panic."
"I'm not… I've only dated guys. Multiple guys."
"Right. And how'd that work out?" She moves even closer, backing me against my desk. "Did any of them make you feel anything? Or were you just going through the motions?"
"Fuck off, Maddie."
"Hit a nerve?" She's so close I can feel her body heat. "It's okay, you know. Very common. College awakening and all that."
"I'm not having any kind of awakening."
"No?" Maddie reaches up, traces a finger along my collar, and my skin burns like she's branding me. "Then why are you shaking?"
Something in me snaps.
I grab her wrists, spin us around, and push her backward. She stumbles, falls onto her bed, and before she can recover I'm over her, pinning her wrists beside her head with probably more force than necessary.
"You talk too fucking much," I hiss.
Her eyes go wide, all that cocky confidence evaporating. We're pressed together from chest to hip, and I can feel her rapid breathing, see her pulse hammering in her throat.
"Emily…"
"What's wrong?" I lean closer, our faces inches apart. "Not so confident now? Where's all that theory about me being gay?"
She tries to move her wrists but I hold firm, and something flashes in her eyes—heat, surprise, something else that makes my stomach flip dangerously. "I was just…"
"What? Teasing? Playing your little games?" I shift my weight and she gasps, actually gasps, and fuck, that sound goes straight through me. "Your boyfriend treats you like furniture, so you pick fights with me because at least it makes you feel something?"
We're both breathing hard, and her face is inches from mine and I can see her pulse racing in her throat and feel her breath on my lips and my entire body is having some kind of system error because this is not… I don't…
Never with girls.
But God, she's so close and her eyes are so dark and her lips are parted and everything in me is screaming to close that gap and…
"Emily." Her voice is barely a whisper.
The sound of my name breaks whatever spell we're under and I scramble backward so fast I nearly fall off the bed.
Maddie sits up slowly, hair messed up, cheeks flushed, looking absolutely wrecked.
We stare at each other across three feet that feels like three miles. My body is still buzzing, skin too tight, heart trying to escape through my ribs.
What the fuck just happened?
Swipe up to continue