The silence between Hannah and me has grown louder since that night. I can feel it every time I walk through the door and see her busying herself in the kitchen or folding baby clothes in the living room.
She doesn’t bring up what happened, doesn’t ask why I called her by Abigail’s name over and over again that disastrous wedding night. But I know she hasn’t forgotten. How could she?
And yet, Hannah tries. She’s always trying. Every meal she cooks is elaborate, plated like she’s auditioning for a food magazine. She hums softly as she works, as if she’s creating this vision of a happy, domestic life that we both know doesn’t exist.
At first, I avoided her efforts. I work late, taking on extra cases at the firm, and when I do come home, I retreat to the guest room, claiming exhaustion or the need to review documents.
But Hannah doesn’t give up.
One morning she places a perfectly cooked breakfast before me. She's been doing this every morning — eggs exactly how I like them, coffee at the perfect temperature, fresh—cut flowers on the table.
Her performance is flawless. Too flawless.
“Vincent,” she starts, her voice soft but firm. “We can’t keep living like this.”
I glance up from my barely touched plate, meeting her gaze. She’s nervous — I can tell by the way she twists her wedding ring around her finger — but there’s a determination in her eyes that catches me off guard.
“What do you mean?” I ask, though I already know where this is going.
“This… this isn’t a marriage,” she says, gesturing to the space between us. “We’re living like strangers, and it’s not fair. Not to me, not to you, and definitely not to our child.” Her voice hardens slightly. "We need to talk about this."
"About what?" The coffee burns my tongue, but the pain is welcome. Real.
"About us. About how you've been sleeping in the guest room for all that time. About how you barely look at me."
I sigh, leaning back in my chair. “Hannah, I — ”
"No, let me finish." She walks around the table, determination etched in every movement. "I know I'm not her. I know this isn’t how you imagined things. It’s not how I imagined them either. But this is our reality now, and we have to make it work."
Her words hang in the air, and for a moment, I don’t know how to respond.
“I’m not saying we have to be perfect,” she continues, her voice faltering slightly. “But we have to try. We owe that to our child.”
Our child. The words twist in my gut like a knife.
She pauses, then adds, “I think we should start sleeping in the same bed at least. It’s going to confuse the baby if we’re acting like we’re not even a real family.”
"What do you want from me?" My voice comes out rougher than intended.
"I want you to try. To really try." She kneels beside my chair, taking my hand and placing it on her stomach. "Our baby deserves parents who at least attempt to build something real."
That’s when something inside me snaps. The frustration, the guilt, the endless gnawing ache of missing Abigail — it all comes rushing to the surface.
I yank my hand away, standing so abruptly my chair crashes to the floor.
"You want something real?" The words pour out like poison. "You're not the woman I dreamed of marrying. You're not the future I planned. You're just a random stripper who—"
The slap echoes through the kitchen. Hannah's eyes widen, her hand flying to cover her mouth in shock at her own action.
The silence that follows is deafening.
"I'm sorry," she whispers, tears welling in her eyes. "I didn't mean—"
"No." I touch my stinging cheek. "I deserved that. What I said... it was cruel."
She backs away, wrapping her arms around herself protectively. At that moment, she looks so young, so vulnerable — nothing like the confident dancer who caught my drunken attention that fateful night.
"I know you love her," she says softly. "But can't you try to love me too? Even a little?"
The question hits me like a physical blow. Because she's right — this is my choice, my responsibility. I chose to marry her, to take responsibility for this child.
I can't keep punishing her for a decision I made.
"Okay," I hear myself say. "Okay."
"Okay what?"
"I'll move back to our bedroom. We'll... try. For the baby."
The smile that lights up her face makes my chest ache. Not with love — that still belongs solely to Abigail — but with something like hope. Maybe we can build something here, even if it's not what I originally wanted.
Swipe up to continue
Our house has been quieter lately, but not in the tense, suffocating way it used to be. It was different now — more... settled. For the first time since we started this uneasy arrangement, things seemed to be shifting.
Hannah had softened. She no longer pushed as much, no longer forced conversations or tried to win me over with over—the—top gestures.
I had started to notice her in ways I hadn’t before. Not just as the woman tangled in my life because of a mistake, but as someone who, in her own way, was trying.
When I came home from work, she didn’t bombard me with questions about my day; she gave me space but always offered a warm dinner and a quiet smile.
Somewhere in the routine of it all, a fragile bond began to form. It wasn’t love, not even close, but it was something — respect, maybe, or understanding. We started sharing small moments: laughing softly at a silly baby name suggestion, sitting in comfortable silence on the couch while she flipped through a parenting book.
There were nights I’d catch her talking to her growing belly, her voice soft and hopeful, and something inside me would ache. I’d think about the life we were trying to build — not for us, but for the child.
It wasn’t what I had dreamed of. It wasn’t Abigail. But for the first time, it felt like something real was beginning to grow between us, fragile as it was. And for now, that had to be enough.
It’s been a long day, one of those relentless ones at the office where the stack of paperwork seems endless. I hang my coat on the rack and loosen my tie, heading toward the kitchen for a glass of water.
As I approach, I hear Hannah’s voice. She’s in the living room, speaking on the phone. At first, I think nothing of it and keep moving, but something in her tone makes me pause just outside the doorway.
The keys slip from my fingers as I reach the front door.
"God, Melanie, you should see how he dotes on me now. Rich, handsome lawyer Vincent Austin, playing the perfect husband."
I freeze, hand on the doorknob.
"Of course he bought it! Men like him are so desperate to do the right thing." Another laugh, cruel and sharp.
“I mean, it hasn’t been easy,” she says, her words slightly muffled but clear enough. “Getting him to care about me, I mean. He’s so… distant. But I think I’m making some good progress in it.”
I frown, leaning against the wall. She’s talking about me.
“It’s frustrating,” she continues, letting out a huff of laughter. “But I’ll give him credit. He’s a good provider. More than I could’ve asked for, really. And let’s be honest, that’s all that matters, right?”
My chest tightens. What is she saying?
She laughs again, this time sharper, almost mocking. “It’s not like Oliver could’ve given me this life. That idiot could barely keep a job, let alone provide for me and the baby.”
My blood turns to ice. Oliver? Who the hell is Oliver?
"You should see the house, Mel. I'm living like a princess, really. I just have to get him to stop pining over her, and everything will be perfect.”
The words hit me like a punch to the gut. My stomach churns as the meaning behind them sinks in. She’s been using me all this time — manipulating me.
My briefcase hits the porch with a thud. Hannah's voice cuts off mid—sentence.
"I'll call you back," she whispers.
I'm through the door before she can move, finding her perched on our — my — leather sofa, phone clutched to her chest like a shield. Her face drains of color.
I step into the room, my movements sharp and deliberate. “Hannah.”
She jumps, nearly dropping her phone. Her eyes widen, panic flashing across her face as she stammers, “Vincent… I didn’t hear you come in.”
“That much is clear,” I say, my voice cold. “Who were you talking to?”
She fumbles for a response, clutching the phone to her chest. “It was just a friend. Nothing important.”
“Really?” I take a step closer, my gaze hard and unyielding. “Because it sounded pretty damn important to me.”
“Vincent, you don’t understand,” she starts, her voice rising with desperation. “It’s not what you think — ”
"Who's Oliver?"
She flinches. "You weren't supposed to be home yet."
"Answer the question." My voice sounds strange, distant. Like it belongs to someone else.
"You don't understand—"
"Oh, I understand perfectly." The rage builds slowly and steady, a gathering storm. "I understand you're a lying manipulator who destroyed my life for a meal ticket."
"That's not fair!" She stands, one hand protectively over her stomach — the stomach carrying a child that might not even be mine. "Everything I said about wanting us to work—"
"Pack your bags."
"What?"
"You heard me. Get out. Now."
Tears well in her eyes — fake ones, I realize now. Everything about her has been fake.
"You can't throw me out. I'm your wife. I'm carrying your child!"
"Are you?" The laugh that escapes me sounds borderline hysterical. "Because from what I just heard, that's as much a lie as everything else."
"You misunderstood—"
"DNA test." The words hit like bullets. "Tomorrow morning. If that baby isn't mine, I'll bury you in so many lawsuits you'll wish you'd never heard the name Vincent Austin."
Her mask slips for just a moment, revealing something cold and calculating beneath.
"And if it is yours?" Her voice turns silky. "What then?"
The question stops me short. What then? What if this one piece of her elaborate con turns out to be true?
"You can stay until the results come back," I manage through gritted teeth. "Guest room. Don't speak to me unless absolutely necessary."
"Vincent, please—"
"I lost everything for you." The words taste like blood in my mouth. "My fiancée, my love, my future, my self—respect — all because I thought I was doing the right thing. Taking responsibility."
Her silence is answer enough.
"If this baby isn't mine..." I step closer, watching her shrink back. "I will make you pay for every moment of happiness you stole from me. Every. Single. Moment."
I turn and climb the stairs to my office, legs barely holding me up. Behind me, I hear the soft sound of Hannah crying — real tears this time, maybe.
The first honest thing about her.
The whiskey bottle calls to me, but I ignore it. I need a clear head for what's coming. My phone sits heavy in my pocket, Abigail's number still memorized after all these months.
Would she even answer if I called? Would she care that our future was destroyed by a con artist's careful manipulation?
Some mistakes can be undone. Some wounds can heal.
But first, there will be blood.
Swipe up to continue
