Of all the bars in this city, I picked the one where I ruined my life.
Brooke is already at our table when I walk in, two martinis sweating on the dark wood, red hair piled in a messy bun that took forty-five minutes to look effortless.
She's thirty-five, three divorces deep, and the most honest person I've ever met, which is probably why we've been best friends since college. She's the only person who's seen me ugly-cry, blackout-drunk, and stupid in love, sometimes all in the same night.
And she already knows about the Jonah situation.
"Of all the bars in the city, babe." She gestures around the room. "You really couldn't pick anywhere else?"
"It's close to my office."
"It's where you picked up your boy toy, babe. Don't play dumb." She slides my martini across the table. "Now tell me everything."
I called Brooke from the car this morning. Told her the short version — I slept with a stranger, he's my new assistant, Nolan doesn't know.
She screamed so loud I almost swerved into oncoming traffic because Brooke Richardson is also the only person who knows that I've been faking orgasms for twelve years and quietly losing my mind.
"It was one time," I say, sitting down. "It's handled."
"Handled." She sips her martini. "Babe, you fucked a stranger and he turned out to be your new assistant. In what universe is that handled?"
"It gets worse." I take a long sip. "I tried to fire him today."
Brooke's glass stops halfway to her mouth. "You what?"
"But I gave him a second chance." I drink again. "He starts fresh tomorrow."
Brooke sets her drink down. "You gave him a second chance because you want to fuck him again."
No I don't. I absolutely do not.
"Brooke."
"Sloane." She mirrors my tone. "You don't give second chances. You fire people for using the wrong font."
I drink the rest of my martini in one go. Brooke watches me with patience.
"How's the sex with Nolan?" she asks.
"We had make-up sex this morning."
"And?"
And I felt absolutely nothing. And I faked it. Again. And I lay under his arm afterward staring at the ceiling wondering if this is it for the rest of my life.
"It was fine."
"Fine." Brooke's eyebrows disappear into her hairline. "Babe, you just had the best sex of your life with a man who isn't your husband, and you went home and had fine sex with the man who is. Do you hear yourself?"
"What am I supposed to do? Leave Nolan because a stranger was good in bed?"
"I'm saying there are options between leaving Nolan and pretending nothing happened." She leans forward. "Have you ever considered an open marriage?"
I almost choke on an olive. "A what?"
"An open marriage. You keep the life, the house, the stability. But you fuck other people. It's not as insane as it sounds."
"It sounds completely insane."
"Right. Because you've been with one man since eighteen." She points at me with her cocktail stick. "You have a twelve-hour flight to Greece with your hot assistant. That's a lot of time to think about whether you want to spend the rest of your life faking it or actually feeling something."
I don't want to think about Jonah at thirty thousand feet in a confined space where I can't leave.
"I'm not having an open marriage," I say.
"You'll change your mind." Brooke smiles the smile of a woman who is always, infuriatingly, right.
A crash cuts through the noise. Glass breaking. We hear a girl's voice, high and scared.
I turn and see a man in his forties, thick neck, drunk, crowding a girl who can't be older than twenty. She's backed against the bar, face white, and he's got one hand next to her head, leaning in.
Before either of us moves, someone crosses the floor, gets between them, and puts a hand flat on the drunk's chest. The drunk stumbles back. The man says something low and the drunk's face shifts from horny to scared in four seconds. He backs off.
"Holy shit." Brooke leans forward, eyes locked on the man. "Look at him. That's exactly my type. Tall, built, hero complex. I would climb that man right now."
I'm already sinking lower in my seat because I recognized him the second he stood up. The buzzed hair. The shoulders. The way he moves.
Jonah turns away from the drunk and scans the room, and his eyes find me like a heat-seeking missile. He stops. The surprise lasts about a second. Then his mouth does the almost-smile that makes my stomach flip and my brain fill with static.
Don't come over here. Don't you dare come over here.
He comes over.
"Oh my God." Brooke grabs my arm under the table. "He's coming this way. Do I look okay? Sloane, is he coming to our table?"
"Brooke." My voice is dead. "That's Jonah."
Her head whips toward me. Then back to him. Then back to me.
"That's Jonah? That's your assistant?" She looks at him again. "That's the man you almost fired today? Sloane, what the fuck is wrong with you?"
"Evening, Ms. Norcott." Jonah stops at our table. Hands in his pockets, easy stance. Professional smile that doesn't reach his eyes but goes somewhere much lower. "Didn't expect to see you here."
You're in the bar where we met. Of course I'm here. Where else would my subconscious drag me on the worst day of my life?
"Jonah, this is Brooke. Brooke, Jonah."
Brooke extends her hand and holds his a beat too long. "So you're the new assistant." She looks him over in a way that is absolutely not subtle. "Sloane's told me about you."
"Good things, I hope." He glances at me. The glance lasts too long.
"Mostly." Brooke sips her drink. "She's been having a rough time lately. Trouble in paradise, you know. Marriage stuff. She could really use someone who pays attention to what she needs."
I kick her under the table. She doesn't flinch.
"I'm doing my best." Jonah says it to Brooke but he's looking at me. "Some bosses are harder to please than others."
I will kill both of them. I will kill them and bury them under this bar and nobody will ever find the bodies.
Brooke makes room and Jonah sits down. She asks him about work, about where he's from, whether he's single. She is shameless and relentless. Jonah answers with easy charm. He's good with women, which… obviously.
My body remembers in high definition.
"So you two are going to Greece together." Brooke's eyes sparkle with the specific evil she reserves for ruining my life. "Twelve hours. Just the two of you."
"It's a business trip," I say. "Strictly professional."
"It's Santorini." Brooke shrugs. "Nothing is strictly anything on that island. People go there married to one person and come back in love with another. It's in the water."
Jonah catches my eye across the table. Holds it too long. I look away first.
I can smell his cologne from here. I hate that I know what his skin tastes like underneath it.
Jonah checks his phone. "I should go. I need to double-check the travel arrangements for Santorini before tomorrow." He stands. Looks at Brooke. "It was nice meeting you."
"Oh, the pleasure was all mine." Brooke hugs him, stepping up on her toes. "Take care of my girl in Greece, okay?"
"Always." He turns to me.
The hug is short and professional. His arms wrap around me lightly, barely touching, the kind of hug you'd give a colleague at a Christmas party.
But his mouth finds my ear and his voice drops to the register I only heard in a hotel room, low and private and meant for no one else.
"I can still taste you, Sloane." His lips brush my earlobe. "I hope my room is right next to yours."
Well, fuck.
He's my assistant. He books the travel. He picks the rooms.
He's going to put himself right next to me and there's not a damn thing I can do about it that wouldn't require explaining why I care.
Swipe up to continue
Jonah carries my bags.
Both of them. Plus his own. He loads the overhead bin, steps back to let me into the window seat, and sits down beside me without touching the armrest between us.
I can feel the heat of his arm through the gap without either of us making contact, and it's already unbearable.
I fall asleep somewhere over the Atlantic. When I wake up, there's a blanket over me that I didn't put there and a bottle of water in the seat pocket that wasn't there before. Jonah is reading something on his laptop, and he doesn't look at me.
Nolan wouldn't have noticed if I was cold. Nolan wouldn't have noticed if I was on fire.
Stop comparing them. He's your assistant. This is his job.
We land in Santorini and the heat hits me like a wall. Jonah has a car waiting — rented it before we left, mapped the route to the hotel, loaded our bags into the trunk before I've finished putting on my sunglasses.
He opens the passenger door and waits.
"I can drive," I say, reaching for the keys.
He pulls them out of reach. Holds them at his side and looks at me with that steady green gaze that makes my jaw tighten.
"You slept three hours on a twelve-hour flight. Sit down."
It's not a suggestion. It's the same voice he used in the hotel room when he told me to stay, and we both know it.
The air between us thickens. His eyes drop to my mouth for half a second and then he opens the passenger door and holds it there, waiting, and the silence says everything neither of us is allowed to say on a work trip in a parking lot in broad daylight.
I sit down and hate that some broken part of me likes being told what to do by this man and only this man.
He drives. I watch Santorini unfold through the window — white buildings stacked on cliffs, the Aegean so blue it looks fake, bougainvillea spilling over every wall.
It's the most romantic island in the world and I'm sitting next to a man I can't touch, driving to a hotel where our rooms share a wall.
At the hotel, he checks us in. Carries the bags up. Opens my door, sets my suitcase inside, and hands me the key card without lingering.
"Dinner at Baxter's is at seven. I'll be in my room if you need anything."
He's being professional. Doing exactly what I told him to do — keep it clean, keep it at work, don't cross the line again.
And he's executing it flawlessly, which is somehow worse than if he'd leaned in and whispered something dirty. Because part of me — the part I'm trying very hard to suffocate — was waiting for him to suggest lunch. A walk or something.
Anything that would give me a reason to be near him for another hour. He didn't. And now I'm standing in my hotel room annoyed at a man for respecting the boundary I set.
My skin is humming like he just put his hands on me.
I shower and change, standing in front of the mirror in a dress I told myself I packed for the meeting and not for him.
The fabric is thin and the neckline is lower than what I'd normally wear to a business dinner and I know exactly why I chose it and I refuse to admit it.
Jonah knocks at six-forty-five. White linen shirt, sleeves rolled to his forearms, tan pants that sit on his hips in a way that makes me want to commit a crime. I open the door and his eyes land on me and he inhales sharply through his nose.
"You look nice," he says. And that's all he says.
No edge. No double meaning. No mouth near my ear. The man who whispered about adjoining walls at the bar is standing in front of me being respectful and it's making me insane because I wore this dress for a reaction and he's giving me professional courtesy instead.
Why are you being good? I didn't ask you to be good. I mean I did, but I didn't mean it. I mean I did mean it. Fuck.
"Let's go," I say, pulling the door shut behind me.
Isaac Baxter's house is built into the cliffside overlooking the caldera — white walls, open terraces. His money doesn't need to announce itself.
He greets us at the door with a handshake for me and a slap on the back for Jonah like they've known each other for years. Grace, his wife, is warm and soft-spoken and pulls me into the kitchen before I've finished taking off my shoes.
"Wine?" She's already pouring. "Isaac talks business at the table. You and I will drink in the kitchen and let them bore themselves."
I like her immediately.
The dinner is loud. Three kids — Joaquin, who's maybe eight, a girl around five whose name I miss, and Nathan, who can't be older than three.
They're everywhere. Sticky fingers on the table, juice spilled twice, Nathan screaming because Joaquin stole his bread.
Isaac doesn't flinch. Grace moves through the chaos like water, wiping hands, cutting food, redirecting tantrums without raising her voice.
I talk business with Isaac between interruptions. The resort acquisition, the terms, the timeline. He asks about my company and I tell him I built it from nothing, how it's mine and mine alone.
Isaac nods like he understands. Grace squeezes my hand under the table. Then Nathan drops his blocks and starts wailing and I turn to look and my breath stops.
Jonah is on the floor.
He's cross-legged next to Nathan with a pile of wooden blocks between them, building something that looks like a lopsided castle.
His hands are patient, placing each block slowly so Nathan can see, letting the boy knock it down, starting over without a flicker of frustration.
Nathan puts a block on top and it holds and Jonah says "Good job, buddy," and the kid's whole face lights up like he was handed the sun.
Joaquin climbs onto Jonah's back. Jonah doesn't shrug him off. Just keeps building with Nathan while carrying the older boy's weight like it's nothing, and he's laughing and he looks actually, genuinely, stupidly… happy.
Nolan would never.
The thought hits me so hard I have to look away.
"He's good with them." Grace has appeared beside me, wine glass in hand, watching Jonah like she knows what matters. "Does he have kids of his own?"
"No, I guess." My voice sounds wrong. "He's twenty-five."
"Twenty-five and that patient?" She looks at me. "That's rare. Most men his age can't sit still for five minutes. He looks like he was built for it."
Built for it. The words stick in my throat like a bone.
I watch Jonah lift Nathan onto his hip while Joaquin hangs off his arm, and I think about every conversation I've had with Nolan about children.
The first time I brought it up — year three, over dinner — and he said "Not yet." Year five: "We're not ready."
Year eight: "Do you really want to give up everything you've built?" Year twelve: "Sloane, we talked about this. I don't want kids. I thought you agreed."
I agreed because I loved him. Because he said it with such certainty that I assumed he was right and I was wrong. Because I spent fifteen years molding myself around his preferences and calling it compromise.
Watching Jonah build a block tower for a three-year-old, I'm not sure any of it was ever true.
I'm not sure I don't want children. I'm not sure I ever didn't.
"Grace." My voice is quiet enough that only she hears. "How did you know you wanted this? The kids, the chaos."
She smiles. "I didn't. Isaac did. And then I held Joaquin for the first time and I understood." She looks at me with gentle, knowing eyes. "You don't have to decide now. But don't let someone else decide for you."
Nathan falls asleep on Jonah's shoulder during dessert. Jonah holds him like he weighs nothing, one arm cradling his back, the other reaching for his wine glass.
He catches my eye across the table and something that looks like this could be our life passes between us.
I'm going to talk to Nolan about kids when I get home.
Swipe up to continue
The last meeting gets canceled at nine in the morning. Isaac's lawyers need another week to review the terms, which means there's nothing left to do on this island except sit in a hotel room ten feet from a man I can't stop imagining naked.
Santorini is designed for lovers. Every terrace has two chairs. Every restaurant has candlelit tables for two.
Every sunset is framed by couples pressed together against whitewashed walls, her hand on his chest, his mouth on her neck. I've been watching them for four days and each one feels like a knife twisting slowly between my ribs.
I book the first flight home.
Four nights sharing a wall with him and he hasn't knocked once. Hasn't texted. Hasn't shown up at my door with that look in his eyes and his sleeves rolled up and his voice dropped low.
He booked our rooms side by side — I know he did, I checked — and then he just… didn't do anything. Didn't even try anything. Was polite at breakfast. Professional in meetings. Said goodnight in the hallway.
What the fuck was the point?
He put himself ten feet from me every single night and then lay there on the other side of that wall doing absolutely nothing while I pressed my ear to the plaster like a crazy person trying to hear if he was awake.
I showered with the bathroom door open because some sick part of me wanted him to hear the water running. I wore a thinner nightgown than I needed to. I left my balcony door open so the breeze would carry my perfume toward his room.
None of it worked. Or all of it worked and he just didn't act on it, which is worse because that means he's choosing not to touch me and I can't figure out why and it's making me lose my fucking mind.
Is this what he does? Wind me up and walk away? Put himself close enough that I can smell him and hear him and feel his presence and then just... wait?
Wait for what? For me to crack? For me to be the one who knocks on his door and admits I've been wet since we landed?
I'm not doing that. I'm not giving him the satisfaction.
I book the first flight home because the meetings are done and there's no reason to stay and I refuse to spend one more night on this island with my hand between my thighs and his name in my mouth.
The flight back is twelve hours of torture. He's in the seat next to me, arm on the rest, his sleeve rolled up and I can see the veins in his forearm and the lean muscle underneath and I want to trace them with my tongue.
He falls asleep somewhere over the Mediterranean and his head tips toward me and for twenty minutes his face is six inches from my shoulder and I can feel his breath on my bare skin and I don't move.
Don't shift. Don't breathe louder than necessary. I just sit there marinating in my own pathetic want like a woman possessed.
Kiss me. Wake up and kiss me. Put your hand on my thigh and slide it up and don't ask permission.
What the fuck is wrong with me?
He wakes up and straightens. Doesn't acknowledge how close he was. I pretend I was reading.
Then we land. He has the car waiting because of course he does. Loads the bags. Opens my door and drives.
It's dark. The highway is quiet and the dashboard glows green and the silence between us has weight, full of things neither of us is saying.
"You were good with Isaac's kids," I say, because the silence is killing me and this feels safe. Or safe enough.
His hands shift on the wheel. "I have four siblings. Sunday dinners every week, cousins everywhere. You don't really get a choice about being good with kids when there's always one climbing on you."
"Four siblings?"
"Three brothers, one sister. Mia." Something softens in his voice when he says her name. "She's nineteen now. I helped raise her. My mom worked double shifts at the hospital — nights and weekends — so I was the one making lunches, helping with homework, and braiding hair."
He laughs, quiet and real. The same laugh I heard on Isaac's living room floor with Nathan on his shoulder.
"Sunday dinners were mandatory. My mom would cook all day Saturday — Dominican food, enough for twenty people even when there were only eight of us. The kitchen would be a disaster and the house would be loud and someone was always fighting or crying or both, and it was…" He pauses. "It was everything."
I listen and I feel the gap between his life and mine crack open wider with every word.
Nolan never wanted Sunday dinners. Never wanted noise or mess or anyone who needed something from him.
Our holidays are quiet. Our weekends are separate rooms. The loudest sound in our house is the TV he leaves on so he doesn't have to hear the silence between us.
Jonah grew up in a house full of people who showed up for each other. I married a man who can't show up for me.
"Do you want kids?" The question leaves my mouth before I can stop it and lands in the dark car like a grenade with the pin already pulled.
Jonah glances at me. "Yeah." No hesitation. No qualifiers. "Not right now. But yeah. That's the whole point, isn't it? Building something that outlasts you."
'Building something that outlasts you.'
Nolan builds nothing. He just consumes my energy, my patience, my years, and gives back silence and two-minute sex and the crushing certainty that this is all I'll ever have.
Jonah pulls up to my house. Kills the engine. The dashboard goes dark and the car goes quiet and all I can hear is his breathing and mine.
He turns to look at me.
The streetlight catches the green of his eyes and the sharp line of his jaw and his mouth — God, his mouth, the mouth that's been between my legs, the same one that's inches from mine right now in a dark car in front of the house I share with my husband.
My hand is on the door handle. I don't pull it.
The distance between us shrinks. I can feel his breath on my face — warm, steady, smelling like the coffee he drank on the plane. His eyes drop to my mouth. My fingers tighten on the handle.
Kiss me. Don't kiss me. Kiss me and I'll kiss you back and then I'll never stop and everything I've built will burn.
He leans closer. His hand moves from the steering wheel to the console between us, fingers brushing the edge of my wrist. Barely touching, asking.
I almost let it happen. My body tilts toward him like gravity shifted and he's the new center and my lips part and I can feel the heat of his mouth before it reaches mine…
I pull back.
"Goodnight, Jonah."
My voice sounds like someone else's, steady and final. This is how a woman who makes good decisions is supposed to sound, which I am not, but I can pretend.
He doesn't argue or push. Just nods slowly, and something dims behind his eyes.
"Goodnight, Sloane."
My first name. I could fire him for the familiarity.
Instead, I grab my bag and open the door. Walk to the front porch on legs that feel like they belong to someone else. Key in the lock. Turn.
The living room light is off.
But the room isn't dark.
There are dozens of candles, scattered across the coffee table, the mantel, and the floor. The warm light flickers across the walls and for one disoriented second I think Nolan did this for me — planned a surprise, set the mood, is trying to be the husband I've been begging him to be.
Then I see the couch.
Nolan is on top of a woman. His shirt is off. Her legs are wrapped around his waist. Her head is tipped back and her red nails are dug into the cushion and she's making a sound I recognize because I've faked it a thousand times — that breathless, performative moan that means nothing.
But she's not faking it. Her back is arching and her body is moving with his and the candles are throwing shadows across both of them and I stand in my own doorway watching my husband fuck another woman on our living room couch.
Then she turns her head and the candlelight catches her face.
Alisha Grant. My friend. My business partner. The woman whose travel agency I helped build with my own money and my own name and my own connections.
My bag hits the floor.
Alisha's eyes find mine.
The moan dies in her throat.
Swipe up to continue