Zara’s POV
"What do you mean she's staying in my room?"
My father doesn't stop walking. I have to match his pace down the hallway, half-jogging to keep up, which is exactly how he likes his conversations — on his terms, at his speed.
"It's temporary. Just until we finish the guest wing."
"Temporary? Dad, her suitcase is next to my bed. Her clothes are in my closet. I woke up this morning to the sound of her breathing three feet from my face."
"Then you'll both have to manage."
Manage.
For twenty years, everything on this property has been mine — the stables, the arena, the horses, the schedule. I've never shared a single thing because there was nobody to share with.
And now I'm supposed to manage?
"She can sleep in the guest cottage. Or the study. Or literally anywhere that isn't—"
"She's staying in your room, Zara." He checks his watch without breaking stride. "I also need you to let her use Rembrandt for training."
I stop walking so fast my shoes squeak on the tile. He doesn't even glance back.
Rembrandt. My horse.
The one I spent three months earning — three months of patience, standing still, letting him come to me. My father handed him over like a welcome basket without asking me.
"You gave her my horse?"
"He's not your horse. He belongs to the ranch." He finally slows at the top of the stairs. Turns to face me. "About Maxine — I need you to be nice to her. Please."
Please. My father doesn't say please.
He says do it and you do it. The fact that he added that word means this matters to him. Not me — the situation. The new wife watching how his daughter behaves.
"I don't need another scene like the one with Lydia," he adds.
Three years ago, I made his girlfriend cry at a dinner party. She packed her bags the next morning. My father didn't speak to me for two weeks. Not as punishment — he genuinely forgot I existed.
Two weeks of being invisible to the only person whose attention I've spent my whole life earning.
I can't go through that again. I'd rather swallow glass than spend another two weeks pretending I don't exist in my own house.
"Fine," I say, and I hate how small my voice sounds.
"Good girl." He turns back to the stairs. Already gone.
Two words and I'm his again.
Twenty years old with an Olympic medal and I still roll over for a pat on the head.
So now I'm standing at the arena fence at seven in the morning with my coffee going cold, watching Maxine Walsh warm up on my horse, after sleeping in my room, wearing boots she left in my wash stall. And I'm trying not to lose my mind.
She's good. She's annoyingly, effortlessly, infuriatingly good.
I want to throw my coffee across the arena.
Her seat is natural — not trained, not drilled, just there. The horse reads her before she finishes asking. She's sloppy in places, but the raw talent underneath is obvious.
I trained for fifteen years to make my body do what hers does without thinking.
"She's something, isn't she?" Ashton leans against the fence beside me.
He's the only person I let into my space. The one who brought me a cupcake when my father forgot my birthday, the one who noticed my back was getting worse before I told anyone.
"She drops her left hand every time," I say.
"Sure. But watch her passage."
I don't want to watch her passage.
"I've been thinking…" Ashton says, and I already don't like his tone. "A friendly match. You and Maxine. Short program, scored on basics. Good way to see where she's at."
I look at him. "You're joking."
"Why would I be joking?"
"Because I don't compete with amateurs. It's embarrassing."
"It's training, Zara. Not the Olympics."
"I've been to the Olympics."
"Which is why it shouldn't bother you." He grins. That easy, warm grin that usually makes me feel like the world isn't completely terrible. Right now it makes me want to throw my coffee at him.
Maxine trots over to the fence, barely out of breath, cheeks flushed, looking annoyingly alive.
"Was that okay?" she asks Ashton. Then she glances at me. "Hi."
I don't answer.
Don't say hi to me like we're friends. You're sleeping in my room and riding my horse and I'm supposed to smile about it.
"Perfect timing," Ashton says, grinning at her. "I was just telling Zara — friendly match. Short program. What do you think?"
Her eyes light up. She looks at me like I'm a birthday present. "Seriously? Oh my god, yes. I would love that."
"I didn't agree to this," I say.
"Scared?" Maxine tilts her head. Always smiling.
I set my coffee down so hard it splashes. "Excuse me?"
"If I had a bronze medal and someone asked me to compete against a nobody, I'd probably say no too. Safer that way."
She's goading me. And it's working because the idea of backing down from this girl who's been here five minutes makes me want to scream.
"Fine." I set my coffee on the fence post. "Twenty minutes. I'll get my horse."
When I ride into the arena on Monarcha, Maxine is already in position on the school horse. She's sitting taller now. Focused. The fidgeting is gone.
Good. At least make it interesting.
Ashton calls the program. We ride side by side — working trot, collected trot, extended. I keep my eyes forward but I can feel her next to me.
At the first halt, Maxine catches my eye. "Your horse is gorgeous."
"I know."
"What's his name?"
"Monarcha."
"What does it mean?"
"It means focus on your own ride."
She snorts — a weird, ugly laugh that catches her off guard. Something twitches at the corner of my lips and I kill it before it gets anywhere.
We move into canter work. My half-passes are clean, my transitions sharp.
Maxine's timing is off on the flying changes — but on the final centerline she adjusts her seat and the horse collects like he's been doing this for years. The piaffe is rough, but it's there.
She found a piaffe on a school horse in a training match. I've seen girls train for years without finding that.
She just — did it. Like it was nothing.
Ashton claps once. "Beautiful! Both of you. I'd call that a tie."
It wasn't a tie. I was better. My technique was cleaner, my transitions tighter. A tie means he's being generous to her, which means he's being unfair to me.
"Let's get a second opinion." Ashton waves toward the arena entrance and my blood goes cold.
My father is standing at the gate. Arms folded. I have no idea how long he's been watching.
"Ben, what do you think? Who took it?"
My father looks at Maxine. Then at me. Then back at Maxine.
"The new girl has something," he says. "Real instinct. Reminds me of how I used to ride before my injury."
He compared her to himself. He never compares me to himself. I'm his project, his investment, his product. She gets to be his reflection.
"Zara, your centerline was a half-second late on the final transition. Watch that."
A correction.
He gave me a correction while he gave her a compliment.
Twenty years of training and the best he can do is tell me what I did wrong while telling a stranger she reminds him of himself.
Maxine is looking at me. I can feel it — her eyes on the side of my face, watching me absorb this. She sees it. She sees exactly what just happened and I want to disappear into the ground.
I gather my reins. Straighten my spine. Force my voice flat.
"Good match. I need to take Monarcha out — he gets restless if he doesn't trail ride after arena work."
I turn my horse toward the exit before I do something stupid — like drag this girl off her saddle in front of the one person whose please is still ringing in my ears.
"Wait for me!"
Maxine's voice rings across the arena. I don't turn around. I press Monarcha into a trot and head for the tree line.
She follows me. Of course she does.
Swipe up to continue
Maxine’s POV
"You shouldn't have followed me."
Zara doesn't turn around when she says it. Her back is straight, her reins loose, her horse moving through the trees like it knows this trail by heart. Probably does.
Probably walks it every day with a girl who'd rather be alone than admit she's hurting.
I pull my horse up beside her. The trail is barely wide enough for two and our boots are almost touching in the stirrups.
I can see the mud on her heel, the crease in her leather, the way her calf sits perfectly still against the saddle.
Everything about this girl is controlled and precise and untouchable. And I'm riding next to her with my pulse doing something stupid because our feet are three inches apart.
"I know," I say.
"Then why did you?"
Good question. I don't have a real answer.
I just — when her father said that thing about Maxine having real instinct, I watched Zara's face.
She didn't flinch. Didn't blink. But something behind her eyes just… switched off. Like a light going out in a window. And my legs moved before my brain caught up.
I can't say any of that. Pushing Zara emotionally is like sticking your hand in a wasp nest — you know what's going to happen and you do it anyway.
"I've never been on a forest trail before," I say instead. "Thought it'd be fun."
She doesn't respond. We ride in silence for a while. Branches creak overhead. Somewhere behind us, a bird does something loud and dramatic in the undergrowth.
The light through the canopy makes everything gold and green and soft, and Zara looks like she belongs in it — like the forest grew around her.
Stop staring at her. What is wrong with you?
"So what was your father like?" Zara says it without looking at me. "You said he got you riding lessons for your birthday."
My breath catches.
She remembered. From the first day — that throwaway line I said while she was speed-walking me to the stables. She was acting like she wasn't listening, but she heard every word.
"He was the best person I've ever known." And then I can't stop. "He drove me to every competition in this beat-up truck that smelled like coffee and dog hair. The AC didn't work so we'd roll the windows down and show up with our hair looking insane."
Zara's eyes flick to me. She doesn't interrupt.
"He learned to braid horse tails from YouTube," I say, laughing a little. "Sat on the bathroom floor practicing on my hair for, like, two weeks straight. My head was so sore but he was so proud when he finally nailed a fishtail braid."
I continue while I can have this moment.
It’s the first time I've talked to someone about him since he left.
"He used to clap at the wrong moments. Like, the judge would be scoring and you'd hear this one guy in the crowd going whoo! and everyone would turn around. Every time."
Something shifts in Zara's face. Not a smile — but the muscles around her mouth soften.
"He sounds embarrassing," she says.
"He was the most embarrassing person alive." My voice cracks. I clear my throat. "I miss him every day."
Zara nods once. Doesn't say sorry. Doesn't say she understands. Just nods, like she's taking it in and filing it somewhere.
"What about your mom?" she asks. "She seems… quiet."
"She is now." I shrug. "She wasn't always. After Dad died, she kind of… I don't know. Folded. She stopped cooking, stopped going out, stopped checking on me. Then she met your dad and suddenly she had a reason to get dressed in the morning."
"Lucky her," Zara says. Flat. But I catch the edge underneath.
We ride for another minute. I fill the silence because I always do — I tell her about my old barn, my school friends who stopped texting after I moved, the fact that I've never been to a party with more than twenty people.
"Wait." Zara actually turns to look at me. "You've never been to a real party?"
"Define real."
"More than twenty people, alcohol that isn't stolen from someone's parents, and at least one person you regret talking to the next morning."
"Then no."
Zara raises an eyebrow so high it almost disappears under her helmet. "Have you ever been drunk?"
"Once. At prom. I had two beers and fell asleep in my friend's car."
Zara stares at me like I just told her I've never seen the ocean. "What about boys?"
My face goes hot. "What about them?"
"Have you… done anything? With anyone?"
"Sure, I've kissed boys," I say, and it comes out way too fast and way too defensive.
"Kissed," she repeats. "Just kissed?"
My face burns. "Yes, just kissed."
She tilts her head, studying me like I'm a dressage test she's trying to score. "Did you actually want to kiss them, or did you just think you were supposed to?"
The question hits somewhere I didn't expect. My hands tighten on the reins.
"I wanted to," I say. But even I can hear how unconvincing it sounds.
Zara's lips twitch. "If things never really worked with guys… have you ever considered that maybe guys aren't the problem?"
"What do you mean?"
"I mean…" She shifts her horse closer. Our knees touch. She doesn't move away. "Have you ever thought about girls?"
My entire face is on fire. "I… that's… I don't…"
"Relax, Maxine. It's a question, not a proposal."
She reaches over and tucks a loose strand of hair behind my ear. Her fingers graze my neck — slow, deliberate. My whole body locks up. Every nerve from my scalp to my toes lights up like a circuit and I forget how to breathe.
Then she pulls her hand back. Straightens in her saddle. The softness vanishes from her face like someone flipped a switch and the Zara from the stable is back — cold, perfect, untouchable.
"There's a Halloween party tonight," she says, looking straight ahead. "Some people from the circuit. You should come."
My brain is still stuck on her fingers on my neck. "I… what?"
"A party. Tonight. I'm inviting you." She pauses. "Unless two beers at prom is still your speed."
My neck is still tingling where she touched me. Thirty seconds ago her fingers were on my skin and now she's asking me to a party like nothing happened.
Like she didn't just turn my brain inside out on purpose and then put her mask back on.
Is this a game? Is she messing with me? Is she going to do that thing again where she's warm for one minute and then looks at me like I'm a stain on her boots?
But I don't know anyone else here. And for about forty-five seconds on this trail, Zara Walsh was almost a real person with me.
"Fine," I say. "I'll come."
"Good." She kicks her horse into a trot without looking back. "Wear something that isn't ripped jeans."
I watch her pull ahead on the trail, her silhouette cutting through the late afternoon light, and I press my hand against the side of my neck where her fingers were.
What the hell are you doing, Maxine.
Swipe up to continue
Maxine’s POV
"Ashton Howard?" The blonde girl — Becca, maybe, or Bianca — nearly chokes on her drink. "Oh honey, get in line."
I'm three drinks in and sitting on a kitchen counter at someone's massive house with a group of people I met forty minutes ago.
The music is loud enough to vibrate in my chest. I'm wearing a black dress Zara threw at me before we left the ranch with a single instruction: Don't embarrass me.
"What do you mean, get in line?" I ask.
The girl next to Becca-or-Bianca leans in. "Ashton flirts with every girl he trains. He gives you the speech about your potential and your raw talent and you think you're special. And then you find out he said the same thing to six other girls that week."
My grip tightens on my plastic cup.
Your passage has real potential. We should build a plan.
He said that to me while looking me in the eyes like I was the only rider in the world. I replayed that moment in the shower. Twice.
"He's hot, though," one of the guys says. Trevor — tall, dark hair, nice smile, been standing a little too close to me all night. "Can't blame the guy."
"Sure you can," Becca-or-Bianca says. "He's thirty-two and he's flirting with teenagers."
Everyone laughs while I take a long sip of whatever's in my cup. It's sweet and strong and I can't feel my lips anymore, which is probably a sign I should slow down.
So Ashton does this with everyone.
The compliments, the eye contact, the hand that lingered on my ankle in the stirrup a beat too long. Not special. Just his routine. I'm not the girl he discovered — I'm the girl of the week.
It's fine. You're still you.
If he does this with everyone, you just have to be the one he can't forget.
"You okay?" Trevor nudges my knee with his. "You look like someone stole your candy."
"I'm great." I flash him a smile. "Just thinking."
"Dangerous hobby." He grins.
He's cute, actually. Easy. The kind of guy who'd hold your hand at a movie and text you back within five minutes.
I should be paying attention to him. I should be enjoying this — my first real party, people actually talking to me, a boy who keeps finding excuses to touch my arm.
But my eyes won't stay where I put them.
Across the room, Zara is sitting on a couch with a girl I've never seen before. Dark hair, red lips, legs crossed toward Zara like she's angling for something. They're close — the girl's hand is on Zara's thigh, casual and familiar, like it lives there.
Zara's laughing. Not the almost-laugh I nearly got out of her during the match. A real one. Low and quiet, her head tipped back just slightly, her throat exposed.
She laughs like that for other people?
"Who's the girl with Zara?" I ask, trying to sound casual.
Trevor glances over. "That's Elsie. They hook up sometimes. Zara's not exactly subtle about it."
Hook up. With a girl. Zara hooks up with girls.
My brain rearranges itself in real time. The trail ride. The question about whether I'd considered girls. Her fingers on my neck. The way she looked at me like she already knew the answer.
"Oh," I say. "Cool. Good for her."
Cool? Good for her?
What am I, a guidance counselor?
I take another drink and force my eyes back to Trevor. Trevor is talking about some competition he almost qualified for. I'm nodding. I'm smiling. I'm not hearing a single word.
Because across the room, Zara leans in and kisses Elsie. Her hand comes up slow and deliberate to Elsie's jaw and she tilts her head and it's…
I can't look away.
Zara pulls back from the kiss and looks directly at me. Right across the room, right through the crowd, right into my face. Like she knew exactly where I was sitting the whole time. Like this whole thing was for me.
My whole body flushes hot. Something twists low in my stomach — not the alcohol, something sharper, something that has teeth.
I want to look away and I can't. I want to be angry and I am — she's over there putting on a show with this girl while I'm sitting here like an idiot with beer on my breath and a boy I don't care about touching my arm. But underneath the anger there's something else.
Something that felt exactly like the trail ride when her fingers were on my neck. I refuse to look at it too closely.
Zara holds my gaze for one more second. Then she turns back to Elsie like I don't exist.
Fine. Fine. Two can play this game.
"Trevor." I turn to him and put my hand on his chest. His eyebrows shoot up. "Tell me more about that competition."
He grins. "Yeah?"
"Yeah." I shift closer to him on the counter.
Our knees press together. I don't even know what I'm trying to prove. I just know Zara kissed that girl while looking straight at me, and now I need to do something.
I remember the trail.
Have you ever kissed boys? Just kissed?
The way she said it. Like I was a child who hadn't started living yet.
I lean into Trevor's space. He smells like beer and cologne and he's looking at my mouth. This is easy. This is what I'm supposed to want.
"You want to go upstairs?" he asks, low enough that only I hear it.
My heart is pounding. Not from him — from everything. From Zara's eyes across the room and Elsie's hand on her thigh and the thing in my stomach that won't stop twisting.
"Yeah," I say. "Let's go."
He hops off the counter and squeezes my hand. "Go on up — second door on the left. I'll grab a condom and be right there."
He disappears into the crowd. I slide off the counter on shaky legs and head for the stairs.
Halfway up, I glance back at the couch.
Zara is watching me. Elsie is talking to her but Zara isn't listening. She's watching me walk upstairs with a boy. And for once, I can't read her face at all.
I turn and keep walking.
You wanted me to grow up, Zara? Watch me.
Swipe up to continue