Oscar's question hangs in the air. Three pairs of eyes wait for an answer I have no intention of giving.
"Spontaneous vacation," I say, lifting my tea. "I needed a break from the noise."
Oscar leans back, unconvinced. "The noise. That's delightfully vague."
"I'm a delightfully vague person." I pivot before he can dig deeper. "But enough about me. What about you three? Wives at home? Girlfriends wondering why you're holed up in a cabin? Husbands?"
The words land like a grenade rolled casually across the table.
Oscar laughs, rich and unbothered. "Husbands. I like you, Kelly Bird. No, I'm happily unmarried and plan to stay that way for the foreseeable future."
Jake's expression flickers with a shadow that passes too quickly to name. He takes a long pull of his beer and says nothing.
Konnor meets my gaze with those unsettling dark eyes. "None of the above."
Three single men. Three very attractive single men.
I take a slow sip of tea to hide the flush creeping up my neck, the ceramic warm against my palms, steam curling between us like a flimsy barrier.
This complicates things considerably.
Because here's the thing about running away to hide from your catastrophic life choices: you're supposed to be invisible.
You're not supposed to be trapped in a cabin with three men who look like they walked out of a casting call for "Rugged Outdoorsmen Who Will Ruin Your Life," while your body—flooded with hormones and starved for touch—decides now is the perfect time to remember what attraction feels like.
The silence stretches, conversation stalling. I recognize the awkwardness for what it is—four strangers who've exhausted polite small talk.
"Let's play a game," I announce. "Never Have I Ever. You drink if you've done it. I'll stick with tea since I'm the concussion patient."
Jake studies me with that unreadable expression. "This feels like an interrogation disguised as entertainment."
"All the best games are." I smile sweetly. "Unless you're afraid of a little honesty?"
"I'm in," Oscar declares. "I'll start. Never have I ever cooked a meal that made someone cry."
He drinks immediately, grinning. "A woman literally wept over my risotto last year. Tears of joy, obviously."
"Your ego is exhausting," Konnor mutters.
Through the rounds, I piece together their histories.
Oscar is a chef who talks about food the way evangelists talk about salvation—with fervor, conviction, and the absolute certainty that his path is the righteous one.
He dreams of a Michelin star like he's tasted the edge of greatness and refuses to stop until he swallows it whole.
Konnor is a cardiothoracic surgeon who describes hearts with clinical detachment—all valves and chambers and things that can be repaired if you know what you're doing.
He speaks about cracking open chests the way most people discuss changing a tire.
Jake is a fire captain, divorced with a teenage daughter. Her name is Lily, and the way his voice softens around those two syllables tells me everything about the kind of father he is and the kind of husband he probably tried to be.
When Oscar jokes about burning buildings, something shutters behind Jake's eyes. He's seen things he carries silently, and I recognize that weight because I carry my own.
They've known each other since childhood—Jake and Konnor from Seattle, Oscar from summers with his grandmother nearby. These trips are their annual tradition, and it's sacred.
My turn comes, and I reveal small truths through what I don't drink to. Never been fired. Never cheated. Never had a one-night stand.
Each admission makes Oscar's grin widen, makes Konnor's gaze sharpen, makes Jake's jaw tighten in a way that sends heat pooling low in my stomach.
Then Konnor sets down his beer with a loud thud. "Never have I ever shared a woman with someone else."
His dark eyes cut to Jake, then Oscar. The challenge is unmistakable.
Jake drinks. Oscar drinks. Then, slowly, with a private smile, Konnor raises his own beer and drinks.
For a moment, the three of them exchange glances loaded with something I can't fully decode—Oscar's eyebrows climbing toward his hairline as he looks at Konnor, Jake's jaw going slack before he schools his expression back to neutral.
There's history in those looks. The kind of silent conversation that only happens between people who've seen each other at their most unguarded.
My breath catches. The heat flooding through me has nothing to do with the tea cooling in my hands.
"Wait." I hold up a palm, brain short-circuiting. "All three of you? At the same time? With the same woman?"
Oscar's grin turns wolfish. "Why, Kelly Bird. Is that judgment or curiosity?"
"Neither. You three don't seem like you'd agree on pizza toppings, let alone..." I wave my hand vaguely, unable to finish.
"We have complementary skill sets," Oscar says, and Jake actually chokes on his beer.
"That's one way to put it." Konnor's voice is dry as bone. "Another way is that Oscar has no impulse control and peer pressures everyone around him into questionable decisions."
"They weren't questionable. Nicole certainly didn't think so." Oscar stretches his arms along the back of the couch. "Her name was Nicole. We met her a few years back. We were young and experimental, and she was… adventurous."
"Adventurous," I repeat flatly. "That's the word we're using."
"Would you prefer 'enthusiastic'? 'Flexible'? Both literally and—"
"Oscar." Jake's voice carries a warning, but his steel-gray eyes are fixed on me, watching my reaction.
Change the subject. Be a normal person who doesn't interrogate strangers about their sexual history.
"How does that even work?" I hear myself ask instead.
What is wrong with me?
"How does it work, she asks." Oscar's delight is palpable. "Jake, you want to field this one?"
"No."
"Konnor?"
"Absolutely not."
"Useless, both of you." Oscar turns back to me. "It works beautifully, since you asked. When everyone's on the same page, when there's trust, when you're all focused on the same goal..." He pauses. "There's nothing like giving someone that much attention. That much pleasure. Watching her fall apart because there's nowhere to turn that isn't more."
"It only happened once," Konnor adds, his obsidian gaze fixed on me. "In case you're wondering."
"I wasn't," I lie.
His slight eyebrow raise says he doesn't believe me.
"The point is," Oscar continues, "it requires the right chemistry. The right woman. Someone who can handle being the center of that much focus."
The word focus lands low in my stomach and detonates.
I take a long sip of tea that doesn't help. My face burns. My pulse hammers against my throat. All three of them watch me now with varying degrees of amusement.
"It's late." I stand too quickly. "I should get some rest. Doctor's orders."
Konnor's dark eyes track my retreat with unsettling precision.
"Sweet dreams, Kelly Bird," Oscar calls.
Jake says nothing, but I feel his gaze on my back until I disappear into his bedroom.
I close the door and lean against it, heart pounding so hard I can feel it in my teeth.
This is pregnancy hormones. Perfectly normal. Completely biological. It has nothing to do with three attractive strangers and the image of them—
I cut the thought off, but the damage is done. The heat between my thighs is undeniable, insistent, maddening.
I press a hand to my stomach—still flat, still hiding its secret—and remind myself who I am. Kelly Goodwin doesn't fantasize about strangers. Kelly Goodwin maintains control.
________________
Swipe up to continue
In my defense, no one told me pregnancy would turn me into a hormonal disaster who gets wet thinking about men she met four hours ago.
Where was this in the pamphlets?
I stare at the ceiling fan spinning its useless circles, accomplishing nothing except pushing hot air from one corner of the room to another.
The rain stopped sometime in the past hour, and now the cabin feels like a sauna wrapped in humidity. I kick off the blankets. Pull them back. Kick them off again.
But the heat isn't the problem. Not really.
The problem is three men admitting they've shared a woman, and my traitorous body deciding that information warranted a full-scale revolt against common sense.
Get a grip, Kelly. You're pregnant, alone, hiding from your entire life, and fantasizing about strangers like a teenager with her first romance novel.
The silence stretches. And my mind—because it hates me—drifts backward to the last time I let myself want anything that deviated from the script.
Mason and I had been dating for eight months. Comfortable enough that I thought honesty might be safe.
I'd read an article about fantasies, about how sharing them built intimacy, and I'd let myself be vulnerable in a way I never was with anyone.
We were in his apartment, and I felt brave. Stupid, reckless, eighteen-glasses-of-wine brave, except I'd only had two.
"What if we tried something different?" I'd asked, my heart hammering so hard I was sure he could hear it. "Like... adding someone. Another man, maybe?"
Mason's face had twisted like I'd suggested we adopt a feral raccoon.
Then came the laugh—not warm, not surprised, but sharp and dismissive. The kind of laugh designed to make me feel small.
"Jesus, Kelly." He'd propped himself up on one elbow, looking at me like I'd transformed into someone dirty. "What kind of woman asks for that? You want to get fucked by two guys at once? That's... I mean, that's not something brides do. That's porn shit. That's what sluts want."
I'd backpedaled so fast I gave myself emotional whiplash. "I was just joking. Saw it in a movie. Forget I said anything—"
"It was stupid," he'd agreed, kissing my forehead like I was a child who'd embarrassed herself at a dinner party. Like I needed absolution for the crime of wanting.
I'd buried that fantasy so deep I almost convinced myself it never existed. Convinced myself that wanting more made me broken.
And look how that turned out.
Mason, the man who'd called me a slut for wanting more, had been screwing his twenty-three-year-old assistant for months.
Brittany, with her perfect highlights and her complete lack of moral complexity.
Funny how the rules only apply to women.
I roll onto my back, and the ache between my legs pulses with renewed insistence.
Clinical explanations flood my mind: increased blood flow during pregnancy, heightened sensitivity, hormonal fluctuations that turn perfectly rational women into walking nerve endings.
But clinical explanations don't account for the specific images flooding my brain.
Jake's rough hands, calloused from years of gripping fire hoses, wrapped around my hips.
Konnor's intense focus—the same precision he probably uses to crack open chests—applied to taking me apart piece by piece.
Oscar's teasing smile pressed against my inner thigh, making promises I want him to keep.
Stop. Stop it right now.
I can't stop.
The fantasy builds without permission, constructing itself from spare parts and desperation. Three sets of hands. Three mouths.
Three voices telling me I'm beautiful, I'm wanted, I don't have to maintain control for once in my goddamn life.
My hand slides beneath the oversized t-shirt before I can think better of it. Just to relieve the pressure. Just once. Just so I can sleep.
The cabin walls are thin—I can hear someone moving in the main room.
Jake is settling on the couch, probably.
The thought that he's just on the other side of this door makes everything more intense.
More forbidden.
I imagine what they'd do to me if I let them.
Jake would be commanding, his voice rough against my ear, telling me exactly how to move.
He'd hold me like he held me when I stumbled out of the car—steady, certain, like he'd never let me fall.
Konnor's fingers would replace my own, precise and knowing. He'd study my reactions like data, cataloging what makes me moan.
And Oscar—Oscar would trail his mouth down my stomach, lower, that wolf's grin pressed against places Mason never bothered to explore. He'd make me laugh even while I begged.
My fingers find the slick heat between my legs, and I bite my lip to stay silent. I'm so wet it's almost embarrassing, my body betraying every denial I've tried to construct.
This is insane. You don't know these men. You're pregnant.
But the arguments dissolve under sensation, and I chase the feeling building at the base of my spine.
My free hand fists in the pillow, my breath coming in shallow gasps I desperately try to muffle.
I imagine all three of them, together, taking turns and then not taking turns. Oscar's earlier words echo through me.
There's nothing like giving someone that much attention. That much pleasure. Watching her fall apart because there's nowhere to turn that isn't more.
More. I want more. I've always wanted more, and I've spent years being ashamed of it.
The orgasm crashes through me, and I barely manage to swallow the moan that claws up my throat.
Wave after wave pulses through my body, my back arching off the mattress, my toes curling against sheets that smell like Jake.
I lie there afterward, trembling, staring at the ceiling fan that still accomplishes nothing.
Horror filters in slowly.
What did I just do?
I'm pregnant with another man's child. I'm supposed to be figuring out my life. I'm hiding from a scandal that would destroy whatever remains of my reputation.
And I just brought myself to orgasm thinking about being shared by three strangers I met four hours ago.
Mason's voice slithers through my memory, dripping with disgust: That's what sluts want.
Maybe he was right. Maybe I am exactly what he accused me of being.
My hand is still trapped between my thighs, evidence of the crime I can't undo.
A floorboard creaks outside my door.
I freeze. Every muscle locks into place, my breath seizing in my chest. The sound is unmistakable—the specific groan of old wood protesting sudden weight.
Someone is standing right there. Right outside.
Silence stretches, thick and suffocating. I don't breathe. I don't move. My heart slams against my ribs so hard I'm certain it can be heard through the walls.
Please let them be walking to the bathroom. Please let this be coincidence.
Then, soft footsteps moving away. A door closing elsewhere in the cabin.
The air rushes back into my lungs, but relief doesn't follow.
Someone was there. Someone heard. And I have no idea which of the three it was—or what I'm supposed to say when morning comes.
________________
Swipe up to continue
I lie in Jake's bed, staring at a ceiling I've memorized over the past hour, replaying the floorboard creak from last night on an endless loop.
Someone heard me. And whichever man it was now carries a secret I'd pay good money to erase from existence.
Get up. Face the consequences. You've survived worse.
The pep talk rings hollow, but I force myself upright anyway.
My plan is simple: tiptoe to the bathroom, splash cold water on my face, and construct a functioning facade before encountering any of them.
Ten minutes of solitude to become Kelly Bird again—whoever she is.
I slip out of bed and ease the door open, wincing at every creak the hinges produce.
The hallway stretches before me, empty and quiet, and I allow myself one steadying breath before padding toward the bathroom.
But the smell of coffee cuts through the cabin, and my stomach drops.
The living room sits empty in the gray morning light—leather couch facing a stone fireplace filled with last night's ashes, a stack of fishing magazines on the rough-hewn coffee table, empty beer bottles lined up like soldiers waiting for disposal.
The kitchen beyond is all butcher block counters and cast iron skillets, a coffee maker gurgling its final breaths beside a sink full of mugs that suggest these men have been awake for hours.
Jake's couch is empty, blankets folded.
I round the corner toward the bathroom, head down, shoulders hunched, and collide directly into a wall of warm muscle.
Jake's hands catch my waist before I can stumble, fingers spanning my hips with an ease that makes my breath hitch.
He's shirtless—because of course he is, because the universe has a sick sense of humor—and my palms land flat against his chest.
"Morning." His voice is rough with sleep, graveled and low.
I should step back. I should definitely step back. But his thumbs press into the curve of my waist, and his steel-gray eyes catalog every micro-expression on my face.
There's a flicker in them—quick, almost imperceptible—where his gaze drops to my mouth before snapping back up.
He felt that too. Whatever electrical current just arced between us, I'm not the only one it burned.
Move. Say something. Stop staring at his mouth.
My body stages a full mutiny against my rational mind. I lean in, just a fraction, drawn by gravity or insanity or both.
His grip tightens for half a heartbeat, fingers digging into the soft curve of my waist like he's fighting the same losing battle.
Then he releases me. Just lets go and steps aside like nothing happened.
My body protests the absence so loudly I'm surprised he can't hear it—every nerve ending screaming why did you stop, go back, put your hands where they were.
"Bathroom's free," he says, completely unaffected. "I'm heading out to check on your car. See if we can tow it ourselves or if we need service."
"I'm coming with you." I say, and it's not a question. Sitting in this cabin, waiting for Oscar's teasing or Konnor's knowing stare, sounds like psychological torture.
Jake raises an eyebrow. "You sure? Rain let up about an hour ago, but it'll start again soon. It's muddy as hell out there."
"I've seen worse than mud." Like boardroom coups. Like public humiliation. Like finding your fiancé balls-deep in his assistant. "Give me five minutes."
I'm ready in four.
The truck smells the same as last night—coffee and pine—but the silence between us feels different. Less tense, more contemplative.
The forest drips with last night's rain, everything green and glistening in the pale morning light.
I watch the trees blur past, steam rising from the wet earth, and try not to think about how aware I am of his hands on the steering wheel.
The same hands that caught me this morning. The same hands I imagined last night—
My gaze betrays me, trailing up his forearms where the sleeves of his flannel are rolled to the elbow, following the curve of muscle to his shoulders, the column of his neck.
A tendon flexes when he turns to check the side mirror, and my mouth goes dry.
Stop cataloging the man like he's a buffet and you skipped dinner.
"How'd you sleep?" Jake asks, eyes on the road.
The blush hits me so fast I nearly choke.
Was it him? Was he the one standing outside my door, listening to me come apart while thinking about—
"Fine." The word comes out strangled. "Your bed is comfortable."
"Mm." A pause stretches too long. "You were pretty restless. Heard you moving around."
He glances at me then. The corner of his mouth twitches, not quite a smile, more like he's actively choosing not to smile.
Oh god. Oh god oh god oh god.
"The heat," I say quickly. "I'm not used to Florida humidity."
His expression gives nothing away. Either he's an excellent poker player or he genuinely didn't hear anything incriminating. I cling to the second option like a life raft.
"So, Kelly Bird." He glances at me sideways. "Tourist, wrong place, wrong time. That's your story?"
"That's the truth."
"Parts of it, maybe." He turns down a narrow dirt road, the truck bouncing over ruts. "The parts you want me to know."
"Everyone has parts they don't share with strangers."
"We're not strangers anymore." His voice drops lower. "You've slept in my bed."
The words land differently than he probably intended. Or maybe exactly as he intended—I can't tell with him.
"I'm just taking a break," I say finally.
"Running from something or toward something?"
I consider the question longer than I should. "I haven't figured that out yet."
Jake nods slowly, like my non-answer told him everything he needed to know. "Fair enough."
When we arrive, my rental car looks exactly as pathetic as I remember—half in a ditch, front end crumpled against a tree, looking sorry for itself.
Jake circles it with professional assessment, checking the undercarriage, testing the wheels.
While he works, I drift toward the truck bed, pretending to inspect the tow equipment like I have any idea what I'm looking at.
The rain has left everything slick and gleaming, and I brace myself against the tailgate to keep from sliding in the mud.
That's when I notice a photograph wedged beneath a toolbox, edges curled from humidity.
The woman in the picture has the kind of effortless beauty that makes other women want to take up a competitive hobby. Dark hair, easy smile, one arm wrapped around a teenage girl with Jake's exact steel-gray eyes.
The girl—Lily, I remember—grins at the camera with the unguarded joy of someone who hasn't yet learned that people leave.
Jake stands behind them both, younger by years, and there's a softness in his expression I haven't seen since I crashed into his life.
His hand rests on his daughter's shoulder, his smile genuine.
He was happy. He had a family, a life, a woman who fit perfectly under his arm.
I slide the photo back beneath the toolbox, feeling like I've read someone's diary without permission.
Whatever happened between him and the woman in that picture—divorce, he'd mentioned—it left marks.
The kind you carry in the spaces between words, in the careful distance you keep from anything that might make you feel too much.
I know those marks. I'm collecting my own.
"Good news," Jake says finally. "We can tow it ourselves. My truck has the gear."
Relief floods through me. "And the bad news?"
"Axle's damaged. You're not driving this anywhere for at least a week." He straightens, wiping his hands on his jeans. "Maybe more, depending on parts."
The words take a moment to register.
A week in that cabin. Seven days of shared meals and thin walls and Jake's hands and Konnor's unsettling stare and Oscar's wolf-grin smile.
"Great," I mutter. "Just great."
But a small, reckless part of me whispers: Would that really be so bad?
________________
Swipe up to continue