ZOE'S POV
The wine glass felt heavy in my hands. "What do you mean he destroys students? That's just a nickname, right?"
Kai set his glass down and ran his fingers through his messy hair. "Zoe, I'm serious about this. My buddy Jake went to Berklee before Mercer transferred to your conservatory. He told me stories that would make you quit music altogether."
"Come on," I said, forcing a laugh. "How bad can one professor be?"
"Bad enough that three students transferred out last semester alone." Kai leaned back against the couch. "Look, maybe I'm being dramatic, but this guy has a reputation. He doesn't just teach classical technique – he tries to rewire your entire musical brain."
I took another sip of wine, trying to calm my nerves. "Maybe that's exactly what I need. Marcus always says I'm too undisciplined."
"Marcus is an ass," Kai said flatly. "And his opinion doesn't matter here."
"He's not an ass," I protested, though my heart wasn't really in it. "He just wants me to succeed."
"By tearing down everything that makes you special?" Kai shook his head. "The Zoe I know doesn't need fixing. You need someone who gets your style, not someone who wants to destroy it."
I stared at the wine swirling in my glass. "Tell me more about these stories. What exactly did Mercer do?"
Kai was quiet for a moment, like he was deciding whether to tell me.
"Jake said Mercer would make students play the same piece over and over until they cried. Not because they couldn't play it, but because he wanted them to forget everything they thought they knew about music."
"That sounds like intensive training, not torture."
"One girl had to play Mozart's Piano Sonata No. 11 for six hours straight," Kai continued. "Every time she tried to add her own interpretation, he'd make her start over. She ended up in therapy."
My stomach twisted. "Six hours?"
"That's nothing. Another kid – a jazz guitarist like me – had to spend an entire month playing only Bach. No improvisation, no personal style, just Bach exactly as written. When he finally got permission to play jazz again, he couldn't do it anymore. He'd lost his creative spark completely. Well, that's partially because Leo hates jazz."
I stood up and walked to the window, looking down at the street below. A couple was walking hand in hand, laughing about something. They looked so carefree, so unburdened by the weight of artistic dreams.
"Maybe losing creative spark isn't the worst thing," I said quietly. "Maybe structure is what I need."
"Are you listening to yourself?" Kai joined me at the window. "You just got into one of the best conservatories in the country playing your way. Why would you want to change that?"
"Because my way got me 'conditional acceptance,'" I said, making air quotes. "Because apparently my technical consistency has concerns."
"So you'll let some professor strip away everything that makes you unique?"
I turned to face him. "What if being unique isn't enough? What if Marcus is right and I'm just noise pretending to be music?"
Kai grabbed my shoulders gently. "Listen to me. I've been playing music my whole life, and I've never heard anyone play piano the way you do. When you improvise, it's like you're speaking directly from your soul. That's not noise, Zoe. That's magic."
Tears pricked at my eyes. "But what if it's not enough for them?"
"Then they don't deserve you," he said firmly. "But don't make that decision before you even try."
I leaned against him, grateful for his warmth. "Tell me more about Mercer. What else did Jake say?"
Kai was quiet for a long moment. "Promise me you won't freak out?"
"I'm already freaking out."
"Jake said Mercer doesn't just critique your playing. He gets inside your head. He'll ask you why you chose music, what it means to you, what your deepest fears are. Then he'll use all of that against you."
"Against me how?"
"He'll tell you that your reasons aren't good enough. That your connection to music is shallow or selfish or wrong." Kai pulled back to look at me. "Jake said it was like psychological warfare disguised as education."
I sank back onto the couch. "Great. So I'm walking into battle with someone who apparently enjoys breaking students."
"Not breaking," Kai corrected. "Rebuilding. In his own image."
"Why do you say that?”
"Every student who survives Mercer's program comes out playing exactly like him. Perfect technique, zero personality. They're like musical robots."
I buried my face in my hands. "Why didn't I research him before accepting?"
"Because you were excited about getting in," Kai said gently. "And that's normal. But it's not too late to back out."
"I can't back out. This is my dream, Kai. And besides, Marcus would never let me hear the end of it."
"Screw Marcus," Kai said with more heat than I'd ever heard from him. "This is your life, not his."
I looked at him, surprised by his intensity. The room felt suddenly cold. "So what am I supposed to do? This is the opportunity I've been working toward my entire life."
Kai said simply. "Don't let him erase who you are."
"Easy for you to say. You're not the one who has to face him every day."
He was about to answer when my phone buzzed. A text from an unknown number lit up the screen.
"Miss Washington, this is Professor Mercer. I trust you're prepared to begin your transformation. I’ll be watching you at the faculty showcase tomorrow. Impress me. - L.M."
I showed Kai the message. His face went pale.
"Tomorrow?" he said. "But orientation isn’t supposed to start for two weeks."
"Apparently he doesn’t care about orientation."
I stared at my phone, my pulse pounding. Being watched was so much worse than showing up unprepared.
"He's testing you," Kai muttered. "Wants to see how you perform under pressure. No guidance. No warm-up."
My phone buzzed again. Another text from Mercer.
"And Miss Washington? Bring your jazz sheet music. All of it. We might have a bonfire."
Swipe up to continue
LEO’S POV
The faculty showcase was mandatory, which was the only reason I attended. I sat in the back row of the small recital hall, checking my watch every few minutes. The sooner this ended, the sooner I could get back to my own practice.
Then Zoe Washington walked on stage.
I'd expected some flashy jazz princess, all style and no substance. Instead, she looked nervous, almost fragile under the stage lights. She sat at the piano bench and closed her eyes for a moment, like she was gathering herself.
Then she started to play.
It wasn't the piece listed in the program. Hell, it wasn't any piece at all. Pure improvisation, starting soft and building into something that made my chest tighten unexpectedly. Her technique was sloppy in places, sure, but there was something raw and honest about her playing that I hadn't heard in years.
She made mistakes. Several of them. But somehow the mistakes felt intentional, like they were part of the story she was telling.
When she finished, the audience erupted in applause. I found myself clapping too, which annoyed me.
After the showcase, I cornered her near the refreshment table. She was talking to another student, laughing about something.
"Miss Washington," I said, and she turned. Up close, she was younger than I'd expected. Early twenties, maybe. There was something almost defiant in her dark eyes.
"Professor Mercer," she said, and I could hear the wariness in her voice. "I guess you're my new advisor."
"Against my better judgment," I replied. "We need to talk."
The other student mumbled an excuse and disappeared. Smart kid.
"About what?" Zoe asked.
"About the fact that you completely ignored the assigned repertoire tonight."
She lifted her chin. "The music said what I needed it to say."
"The music said nothing coherent. It was self-indulgent noise masquerading as art."
I expected her to get defensive, maybe storm off. Instead, she studied my face with those sharp eyes.
"You really believe that?" she asked quietly.
"I believe in discipline. In structure. In saying something worth hearing instead of just making pretty sounds."
"And you think jazz can't do that?"
"I think jazz is an excuse for musicians who don't want to do the real work."
She was quiet for a long moment. Then she said, "Can I show you something?"
Before I could object, she was walking toward the hallway that led to the old practice rooms. Against my better judgment, I followed.
She stopped at a door I'd passed a hundred times but never opened. "Do you know what's in here?"
"Storage, probably."
She produced a key from her pocket. "Marcus gave me this. Said it was the best practice room in the building, but they don't advertise it."
The door opened to reveal a small room with a magnificent old Steinway. The instrument had to be worth more than my car.
"How did you get access to this?" I asked.
"Connections," she said with a small smile. "Want to hear what discipline actually sounds like?"
She sat at the bench and began to play Bach's Goldberg Variations. Not the flashy, show-off sections that students usually picked, but the quiet, contemplative aria that opened the piece.
Her technique was cleaner than I'd expected. Still inconsistent, but there was something deeper happening. She understood the emotional architecture of the piece, the way Bach built tension and released it.
"Where did you learn to play like that?" I found myself asking.
"Marcus taught me classical when I was a kid. Before I discovered jazz."
"Why did you switch?"
She kept playing as she answered. "Because classical felt like wearing someone else's clothes. Beautiful, but not mine."
"And jazz feels like yours?"
"Jazz feels like breathing."
I watched her hands move across the keys. There was something almost vulnerable about the way she played Bach, like she was revealing a secret.
"Play the jazz piece you did tonight," I said suddenly.
"I don't have sheet music for it."
"Play it anyway."
She transitioned seamlessly from Bach into her improvisation. This time, I could hear the classical foundation underneath the jazz flourishes. The way she used space, the subtle harmonic progressions, the careful balance between chaos and control.
"You hear it, don't you?" she said, still playing. "The structure is there. It's just... hidden."
I did hear it. That was the problem.
She finished and looked at me expectantly. "So? Still think it's just noise?"
I flexed my left hand, feeling the familiar ache that reminded me why I was here instead of on a concert stage somewhere.
"Technique isn't everything," I admitted grudgingly.
"No," she agreed. "But it's not nothing either."
"Your classical training shows. That's the only reason your improvisation works at all."
"Maybe. Or maybe they're not as different as you think."
I found myself moving closer to the piano. "Play something sad."
"Sad?"
"Whatever that means to you."
She began a slow, minor-key improvisation that made my chest ache. There was longing in it, loss, the kind of deep sadness that came from understanding how fragile beautiful things were.
"You play like you've never known real loss," I said, the words coming out before I could stop them.
She stopped playing abruptly and turned to look at me. I could see the questions forming in her eyes, and I immediately regretted revealing so much.
Before she could respond, the door swung open, revealing Marcus Washington. I recognized him immediately – that commanding presence, those sharp eyes that seemed to take in everything at once.
His familiar face darkened when he saw us alone together.
"Zoe, I've been looking everywhere for you. What are you doing with him?”
Swipe up to continue
ZOE'S POV
I could feel the tension in the air like electricity before a storm. Professor Mercer had gone completely silent after asking me to play something sad, and now Marcus stood in the doorway looking like he wanted to punch someone.
"Uncle Marcus," I said quickly, standing up from the piano bench. "I was just—"
"I can see what you were doing." His voice was ice cold. I'd never heard him sound like that before.
Professor Mercer cleared his throat. "Mr. Washington. I was just getting acquainted with my new student."
Marcus didn't even look at him. His eyes stayed locked on me, and there was something dangerous in them that made my stomach flip.
"Zoe, we need to talk. Now."
"Actually, we were in the middle of—" Professor Mercer started.
"Now, Zoe." Marcus's voice cut through the room like a blade.
I looked between them, confused. What was happening here? Minutes ago, Marcus had been his usual supportive self, bragging about me to other faculty members. Now he looked ready to explode.
"I should go," I said to Professor Mercer, though I didn't really want to. For the first time since starting this program, I'd felt like someone was actually listening to my music. Really listening.
Professor Mercer nodded, but his expression was weird. Guarded. "We'll continue this discussion during your first official lesson."
"Sure," I said, grabbing my bag from the floor.
Marcus stepped back to let me pass, but I could feel him watching Professor Mercer the whole time. Like he was sizing him up. Like he was trying to decide whether to fight him or not.
As soon as we got into the hallway, Marcus grabbed my arm and pulled me away from the practice room. Not rough, but firm enough that I knew he wasn't messing around.
"What the hell are you doing with Leo?" he demanded.
I stopped walking and stared at him. "Leo? You mean Professor Mercer?"
Marcus didn't answer. He just kept walking, practically dragging me down the hallway toward the main exit. Students were still hanging around from the showcase, laughing and talking in small groups. They all went quiet when they saw Marcus's face.
"Uncle Marcus, you're scaring me," I said, trying to keep my voice down. "What's wrong with you?"
He didn't stop until we were outside in the parking lot, away from everyone else. The cool night air hit my face, and I could finally breathe again.
"You know Professor Mercer?" I asked, studying his face in the streetlight.
Still no answer. But his jaw was clenched tight, and his hands were balled into fists at his sides. I'd seen Marcus angry before—at incompetent musicians, at people who didn't take music seriously, at bureaucrats who tried to cut funding for arts programs. But this was different. This was personal.
"He's my professor," I said slowly. "The one who's supposed to be in charge of my intensive mentorship classes."
Marcus spun around to face me, his eyes wide. "He's what?"
"My mentor. The department assigned him to me. Why? What's the big deal?"
"The big deal?" Marcus laughed, but there was no humor in it. "Zoe, you need to change your so-called mentor. First thing tomorrow morning, understand?"
"What? No." The word came out louder than I meant it to. A couple walking to their car turned to look at us. "Why would I do that?"
"Because I'm telling you to."
"That's not a reason, Uncle Marcus. That's just you being controlling."
His face went red. "Controlling? I'm looking out for you, Zoe. That man is—"
"Is what? He seemed fine to me. More than fine, actually. He actually listened to my music tonight.”
"Of course he did. He's probably trying to—"
"Trying to what?" I crossed my arms over my chest. "Be a good teacher? Help me improve? Isn't that what you wanted when you pulled strings to get me into this program?"
"You can't stay in his class, Zoe. Find someone else."
"I can't just switch mentors for no reason. Classes haven't even been going for a week yet. I need a good reason to ask for a change, and 'my uncle doesn't like him' isn't going to cut it."
"I'm reason enough."
"No, you're not." I stepped closer to him, trying to read his expression in the dim light. "What is your deal with Professor Mercer? Why do you look like you want to kill him?"
Marcus turned away from me, staring out at the empty campus. For a long moment, he didn't say anything. Just stood there with his shoulders tense and his breathing too fast.
"Uncle Marcus," I said again, softer this time. "Why does seeing Professor Mercer make you so angry? How do you even know him?"
Silence.
"Marcus." I grabbed his arm, forcing him to look at me. "What aren't you telling me? Why did you react like that when you saw us together?"
He met my eyes, and for the first time in my life, I saw something that looked like fear there.
"I know him," he said finally, his voice barely above a whisper. "From way back."
The words hit me like a physical blow. Everything suddenly made sense—the tension, the anger, the way they'd looked at each other in that practice room.
"You two were classmates?" I whispered.
Marcus nodded slowly, and I felt my mouth fall open.
"Oh my God."
Swipe up to continue