The silence that follows is deafening.
Three months. Living with Jaxson. In this house.
"You're joking," Jaxson says flatly.
James shakes his head. "I'm afraid not."
Jaxson's jaw tightens, the first crack in his armor. "You're telling me I can't return to Italy for three months?"
"Not if you want your inheritance," James confirms. "The will is quite specific. Moreover, the cohabitation must be continuous. Neither of you can leave for more than twenty-four hours during the three-month period, or the clock resets. If the clock resets a second time, neither of you inherits anything."
My mouth goes dry. The room suddenly feels too small, the walls pressing in like they're trying to trap us together.
I watch Jaxson process this information, his fingers drumming against the armrest in a pattern I remember from years ago—his tell when he's calculating his next move.
"There's more," James continues, and I hate the apologetic tone in his voice. "At the end of the three months, you'll each have a say in whether the other deserves their share of the company. Harper, you'll evaluate whether Jaxson should receive his portion. Jaxson, you'll do the same for Harper."
The betrayal hits me like a physical force, stealing my breath. My father, the man who taught me about integrity and trust, engineered this manipulation from beyond the grave.
For the first time in my life, I understand the rage that used to burn in Jaxson's eyes when he looked at Richard. I understand why his fist went through that wall.
"Are you going to say anything?" Jaxson asks, his voice cutting through the fog before my eyes.
I turn away from Jaxson, focusing on James instead. "Is there any legal way to contest this? Some loophole that would let us access our inheritance without this ridiculous cohabitation clause?"
James shifts uncomfortably in his chair. "Your father was very thorough. The will is ironclad, and he had it reviewed by different firms to ensure there were no vulnerabilities."
"Still pretending I don't exist, Harper?"
Jaxson's voice slides across the room like silk over broken glass.
"First Richard ships me off like unwanted luggage, and now you can't even look at me when discussing the scraps he left behind. I'm starting to see a pattern here."
That pulls my attention back to him, and I snap.
"Don't you dare make this about your perpetual victim complex," I snapped, whirling to face him. "He tried to be a father to you. He tried to include you, to give you opportunities, but you threw it all back in his face because you'd rather nurse your grudges than accept that someone actually wanted to help you."
"Help me?" Jaxson's eyebrows rise in mock surprise. "Is that what you call shipping me off to Italy the moment I didn't fit his suburban fairytale? His version of help was trying to turn me into another one of his corporate puppets."
"At least he tried to give you a future instead of letting you self-destruct," I fire back. "Which, let's be honest, was exactly where you were headed with your bar fights and your little revenge stunts."
He rises from his chair, his gaze raking over me with disdain. "You wouldn't understand what I mean, would you? Poor little Harper, so grateful for daddy's love that you never noticed the strings attached."
"You insufferable—"
"What? Go ahead, Harper. Say what you really think."
The venom I've stored for seven years rises in my throat, ready to spill.
"Oh, y want to know what I think? I think you're pathetic. You left for seven years and now show up here within hours of learning there's money involved."
His eyes darken to that midnight shade I remember.
"And you're so desperate for daddy's approval that you molded yourself into his perfect little protégé. Tell me, Harper, does Preston know he's just another box you're checking off Richard's list? Good family, good connections, good enough to parade around at company functions?"
"At least I'm capable of maintaining a relationship that lasts longer than a weekend," I shoot back.
Yes, I checked his Instagram from my fake profile.
The one I made specifically to watch him live his best life in Milan with a rotating cast of women who all looked like they stepped out of Italian Vogue.
"Maintaining? Is that what you call whatever tepid arrangement you have with that walking LinkedIn profile?"
He says it with a look that tells me he's been keeping tabs on me too. And this twisted thought sends a pathetic little thrill through my chest that I immediately want to suffocate.
The worst part is that he's not wrong.
Preston's idea of spontaneity is ordering a different wine at dinner. But at least Preston doesn't make me feel like my entire body is on fire just by existing in the same room.
"Better than your revolving door of Italian models who probably can't spell your name," I shoot back.
"My Italian models can spell just fine, thanks. They can also do plenty of other things your Princeton boy probably needs a manual for."
He's probably right about that too. Preston approaches sex like he's following a checklist for a quarterly performance review.
"You're disgusting," I hissed.
"And you're repressed."
"If I might interrupt this... reunion…” James clears his throat loudly, “there are additional documents." He pulls two envelopes from his briefcase, our names written on them in my father's precise handwriting. "Richard also left personal letters for each of you, to be delivered with the will reading."
The sight of my father's handwriting drains the fight from me. My hand shakes slightly as I take the envelope. Jaxson takes his envelope but doesn't open it, just tucks it into his jacket pocket like it means nothing.
The casual dismissal of Father's final words makes my chest tight with an emotion I can't name.
"I need some air," I say, standing abruptly.
The letter burns in my hand, unopened. I can't read it here, not with Jaxson watching, ready to mock whatever vulnerability my father's words might expose.
"Running away already?" Jaxson's voice follows me as I head for the door. "The three months haven't even started yet."
I pause at the doorway, not turning around. "James, when does the clock start?"
"Monday at noon," James replies. "I'll need both of your signatures on some documents before then."
"Fine." I take one last look at Jaxson, and my traitorous mind notices with distant clarity that Italy has made him even more handsome.
The Mediterranean sun has given his skin a golden cast, and there's a confidence in his posture that wasn't there before. Like he finally grew into himself away from this place.
Away from me.
Swipe up to continue
My father's envelope sits on the passenger seat like it's been personally victimized by my twenty-minute stare-down in this parking lot.
The cream paper practically glows with paternal authority—Richard Sloan maintaining his death grip on perfection even after actual death.
I drove here running entirely on muscle memory and spite, my brain having checked out somewhere between Jaxson's casual cruelty and James's legal tap dancing.
Come on, Harper. Rip off the bandaid.
What's the worst that could happen?
My fingers shake as I tear into the envelope with all the grace of a raccoon opening a trash can. The letter starts with the usual paternal throat-clearing, but I skip to the part that matters:
...At my wedding to Rachel, I made a promise to be a real father to Jaxson. I failed spectacularly at this promise. I tried to mold him into my image instead of helping him discover his own. Sending him to Italy was me choosing the coward's way out.
My failure with Jaxson and my failure to honor Rachel's love for our blended family—these are the greatest regrets of my life. This will be my last attempt to right a terrible wrong.
I'm asking you to do what I couldn't. Be the good influence on Jaxson that I failed to be. Find a way to become the family that Rachel dreamed of.
All the love, baby girl.
Dad
The tears arrive right on schedule, hot and bitter.
He knew. He knew exactly what he broke and decided death was the perfect excuse to make it my problem. The sheer audacity of dying before fixing your mistakes—peak Richard Sloan energy.
I scrub my face with my sleeve like a toddler having a meltdown at Target and stumble toward my apartment. The elevator takes approximately thirty years to reach my floor, each ding counting down to my inevitable psychological collapse.
But when I open my apartment door, Preston stands there looking like he was ordered from a catalog called "Boyfriends Your Parents Would Approve Of."
Champagne in one hand, white roses in the other, his Brooks Brothers shirt so pristine it probably irons itself.
The entire scene screams romantic gesture, except I've completely forgotten our anniversary because I've been too busy mentally preparing for emotional warfare with my stepbrother.
"Surprise," he says, his Ken-doll smile wavering when he registers my raccoon eyes. "Harper, have you been crying? What happened?"
"Preston, I…"
My throat constricts around the words. Two years. We've been together two years, and I forgot because Jaxson Reid took up residence in my brain rent-free.
"God, I'm the worst. I completely forgot."
"Hey, it's okay," he says, abandoning his props to wrap me in an embrace that feels like being hugged by room-temperature milk. "You've had a lot on your mind lately. We can celebrate another night."
I don't deserve this man.
The thought arrives with the weight of truth. Preston Matthews is a walking green flag—Harvard MBA, emotional stability, the kind of guy who probably flosses twice a day.
He kisses me softly, and I taste spearmint and stability and absolutely nothing that makes my neurons fire in interesting patterns.
All I sense is the phantom burn of what Jaxson's mouth might do to mine.
"We should talk first," I say, pulling away before his hands can start their predictable journey south. "Tell me about your day. Distract me from the dumpster fire that is mine."
He pours champagne while diving into a riveting tale about country club drama.
"You wouldn't believe the scandal at today's membership meeting. Harrison's wife is trying to change the dress code because Jennifer Walsh keeps showing up to brunch in Lululemon. Though between you and me, I think it's less about athletic wear and more about Jennifer's very enthusiastic networking at the bar. She's been particularly friendly with the married men after her Pilates sessions."
The champagne tastes expensive and hollow. I nod at appropriate intervals while Preston continues his dissertation on suburban warfare.
"She actually had the audacity to sit in Thompson's lap during the auction," he continues, refilling my glass without asking. "His wife was standing right there. I mean, the woman was five martinis deep, but still. There's a code of conduct."
The female members at his club circle him like sharks who smell trust funds in the water.
I know because I've witnessed their mating rituals. The tactical arm touches, the practiced laughs at his investment jokes, the way they lean in just enough to give him a view down their designer blouses.
More wine disappears.
More sounds emerge from Preston's mouth that might be words but register as white noise.
My mind plays a highlight reel of Jaxson talking about Italian models and their particular skill sets while Preston discusses quarterly portfolios and someone named Brad who apparently embezzled from the children's charity fund.
"Can you believe that? From the children's fund," Preston says, shaking his head in disapproval. "His wife left him for her trainer last month. The one with the CrossFit gym downtown? Apparently, she'd been having private sessions for quite some time."
When he finally stops talking and starts kissing me again, I let him lead me to the bedroom where everything unfolds with the passion of a dental cleaning.
Thorough, hygienic, and over in exactly ten minutes.
He approaches intimacy like he's conducting a board meeting, hitting all the agenda items in order: kissing, foreplay mostly consisting of him asking "is this good?" every thirty seconds, main event and concluding remarks of him telling me how beautiful I am while I wonder if I remembered to set the DVR.
He goes through his routine with the dedication of someone following IKEA instructions while I contemplate the ceiling and wonder if this is what death feels like, just warmer. His hands move with all the passion of someone checking produce for ripeness.
At one point, I catch myself mentally drafting a grocery list. Which feels like the kind of metaphor for our relationship that would make my therapist reach for her prescription pad.
Afterwards, he's already drifting off, his arm draped across me like a participation trophy.
"Love you," he mumbles into Egyptian cotton.
"Love you too," I whisper back.
Gosh, I’m so sexually frustrated. Perhaps this is why I can’t stop myself from imagining forbidden things with a forbidden person, who’s definitely not my former stepbrother.
Swipe up to continue
Morning light slices through my apartment windows, all harsh angles and unforgiving clarity. The kind of light that exposes every dust mote, every imperfection, every lie you tell yourself about the life you've chosen.
Preston sleeps beside me with the serene perfection of a stock photo.
Jaw relaxed at the optimal angle. Chest rising in measured intervals. One arm positioned like he's posing for a men's health magazine even while unconscious.
His features arrange themselves into conventional handsomeness: strong jawline, straight nose, the kind of bone structure that photographs well at charity galas.
He could be anyone's ideal partner, the human equivalent of a five-star Yelp review—consistently good, reliably pleasant, zero surprises.
Boring is safe, I tell myself, the mantra I've been repeating since we started dating.
Safe means no walls with fist-shaped craters. Safe means no midnight eyes that make your internal organs rearrange themselves. Safe means Preston Whitmore and his predictable rhythms.
But the memory of yesterday clings to me like smoke damage.
Jaxson's voice, the way he said "sister" like he was twisting a knife, the crack in that wall that still exists seven years later.
The ghost of what I felt at sixteen haunts this pristine apartment, making Preston's safety feel less like security and more like a maximum-security prison where I'm both the inmate and the warden.
Preston stirs, his eyes opening with the immediate alertness of someone who's never had a complicated thought before his first cup of coffee. "Morning, beautiful."
"Morning," I manage, watching him stretch with the ease of someone who does yoga for the Instagram posts.
He disappears into the kitchen, returning minutes later with two mugs of coffee prepared exactly how we take them—his with oat milk and stevia, mine black with shame and growing dread.
The bed dips as he perches on the edge, skipping any pretense of morning affection to get straight to business.
"Harper, we need to talk about efficiency," he announces, wielding the word like other people might use "I love you."
"Efficiency?" I echo, already knowing where this conversation leads and desperately searching for the emergency exits.
"Maintaining two apartments when we spend most nights together doesn't make fiscal sense. The overhead alone could be better invested. We should consolidate our living situation."
"You want to move in together," I translate, my voice sounding like it's coming from very far away.
"Exactly. Your place or mine, doesn't matter. Though mine has better parking and that new Thermador range."
He sips his coffee, clearly pleased with his PowerPoint presentation of a relationship milestone.
"We've been together for two years. The natural progression suggests cohabitation as the logical next step."
The word "yes" escapes my mouth before my brain can intervene, a Pavlovian response trained by twenty-three years of accommodating other people's expectations.
The moment it lands in the air between us, my stomach performs a full gymnastics routine, complete with multiple backflips and a dismount straight into nausea. Preston's face lights up with the satisfaction of a hostile takeover successfully completed.
"Perfect. We can start boxing up the redundant items this weekend. I've already researched moving companies with the best efficiency ratings."
Panic floods my system like a broken dam.
The thought of Preston's monogrammed towels in my bathroom, his labeled containers colonizing my refrigerator, his presence expanding to fill every corner of my sanctuary… I physically recoil, nearly spilling coffee across the sheets.
"Actually," I blurt out, grasping for the life raft of my father's posthumous manipulation, "there's a complication."
His eyebrows perform their skeptical dance, the one usually reserved for waiters who claim the kitchen is out of his first three menu choices.
"What kind of complication?"
"The will." I inject enough gravity into my voice to sell this half-truth. "I have to live at the Sloan Estate for three full months. It's a strict condition of the inheritance. No exceptions."
"The estate? That massive place in Beacon Hill?" His eyes glaze over with the particular sheen of real estate lust. "The one with the heated floors and the wine cellar?"
"That's the one. But Preston, Jaxson will be there too, presumably making my life miserable."
I paint the picture with broad strokes of martyrdom, hoping he'll retreat from this terrible idea. Instead, his face brightens like he's just discovered a tax loophole.
"Darling, that's not a punishment, that's an opportunity. Do you have any idea what that property is worth?"
"Preston…"
"No, listen." He sets down his mug with the decisive clink of someone who thinks they've solved world hunger. "You shouldn't have to face that house alone. Or deal with your stepbrother's hostility without support."
"The will specifically states—"
"That you have to live there. Not that you have to live there alone." His smile widens with corporate efficiency. "I'm your fiancé."
"We're not engaged," I point out, my voice climbing octaves I didn't know I could reach.
"Semantics. We're in a committed relationship heading toward marriage. Surely the estate's lawyer can't deny you moral support. Email him right now, ask about guest provisions."
"I don't think that's—"
"I insist." He's already heading toward the shower, his mind made up. "Check with James Kimmons. I guarantee there's nothing preventing me from staying there with you. It would be cruel and unusual to force you to endure three months alone with someone who clearly traumatized you as a teenager."
The bathroom door closes with a satisfied click, leaving me alone with my phone and my rapidly multiplying anxiety.
My hands shake as I grab the device, ready to compose a desperate email to James begging him to create a no-guests rule, to save me from this collision of my worst nightmare and my mediocre reality.
But my inbox already holds an unread message, sitting at the top like a letter bomb.
Subject: SECURITY
UPDATE: Guest Authorization
From: James Kimmons
To: Harper Sloan
Dear Harper,
Per Jaxson's explicit instructions early this morning, security clearance has been proactively granted for Mr. Preston Whitmore for the duration of your stay. The East Wing Guest Suite—directly across from the Master Suite—has been prepped for his arrival.
Jaxson emphasized that he wants you to have everything you need to feel comfortable. He insists on it.
See you at the house.
Regards, James
The timestamp reads 6:00 AM. Hours before Preston even woke up. The phone slips from my nerveless fingers, clattering against the hardwood floor.
Jaxson didn't just know Preston would try to come—he cleared the way for him.
He's waiting for us. For me.
And I'm terrified of what happens when I'm trapped in that house with both the man I'm supposed to love and the one I've never been able to stop wanting.
Swipe up to continue