[Lottie’s POV]
Alex is on top of me, and I'm thinking about spreadsheets.
Not in a sexy way. Not in any way that could be remotely construed as arousal. I'm literally running through the Henderson account reconciliation while my boyfriend of two years performs what I can only describe as aggressive hip circles.
He shifts angles. Tries something new—and by new, I mean he's switched from missionary to doggy style, which he considers the pinnacle of sexual innovation. His face is a mask of concentration, like a man defusing a bomb or assembling IKEA furniture without the instructions.
I feel absolutely nothing.
Well, that's not entirely true. I feel the weight of him pressing down. The scratch of his stubble against my shoulder. A mild discomfort in my left hip from the angle. But that electric thing everyone talks about? That building pleasure? Complete radio silence from my nervous system.
My mind drifts to work. Did I send that email to Patterson? The quarterly reports need reformatting. I definitely forgot to buy milk this morning. The ceiling above me could really use a fresh coat of paint—is that a water stain forming?
Alex switches back to missionary, apparently exhausting his entire repertoire. He's been jackhammering away for approximately four minutes now, which he probably considers generous. Two years of this, and I've become an expert at performing enthusiasm while mentally reorganizing my sock drawer.
I make an encouraging sound. He takes this as validation and redoubles his efforts.
The nightstand buzzes. My phone lights up with a notification—probably the office group chat losing its collective mind over something trivial. My hand moves toward it before my brain registers what I'm doing.
Alex stops. Completely stops.
"Did you just—" His voice is strangled. "Are you seriously checking your phone right now?"
I pull my hand back like the nightstand is on fire. "No. I mean, I wasn't going to actually look at it. It was just... reflex."
He rolls off me. The sudden absence of weight feels like relief, and that probably says everything that needs saying about this relationship.
"Reflex." He sits up, jaw clenching in the dim lamplight. "Your reflex during sex is to check your notifications."
"Alex, please—"
"Do you have any idea how that feels? Do you have any concept of what it's like to be with someone who would rather scroll through work emails than be present with you?"
He's standing now, pacing the small bedroom like a caged animal. I try not to look down his body. I sit up and pull the sheet around myself, though modesty feels ridiculous at this point.
"I'm sorry. That was thoughtless of me."
"Thoughtless." He laughs without humor. "That's the understatement of the century, Lottie. Two years. Two goddamn years I've been trying to connect with you, to make you feel something, anything at all."
The list begins. I knew it was coming—he's been building to this explosion for months.
"I've tried different positions. I've switched things up. I bought that vibrator—"
The vibrator he bought for my birthday last year. The one he used on me for approximately ninety seconds before deciding it was "taking too long" and pushing it aside. The one gathering dust in my nightstand because apparently my pleasure has an expiration timer.
"I've done candles, Lottie. Romantic candles."
One candle. Once. A vanilla-scented thing from the petrol station that he lit for ten minutes before complaining the smell gave him a headache.
"I even watched that video you sent me. The one about what women actually want."
The video was forty-five minutes long. He watched three, told me it was "too lecture-y," and suggested we "figure it out naturally." We never figured it out.
"And you just lie there, Charlotte. Every single time, you just lie there like you're waiting for a dental appointment to end."
"That's not fair—"
"It is." His voice cracks. "It absolutely is fair. You're cold. Completely unresponsive. There's something broken in you, something fundamentally wrong."
The word hits differently than the others. Broken. It sinks into my chest and finds a permanent home there, right next to every dark suspicion I've ever had about myself.
Because here's the thing: I know his list is pathetic. I know two positions and one abandoned vibrator does not constitute "trying everything." I know that when I showed him exactly where to touch me, he did it for thirty seconds before getting bored and going back to what worked for him.
But three boyfriends now. Three men who started with enthusiasm and ended with the same conclusion. At some point, the common denominator stops being coincidence.
"Maybe we just aren't compatible—" I start, but he's already spotted my phone on the nightstand, screen still glowing.
He grabs it before I can react. For one terrible second, I think he's going to read my messages, expose some imaginary affair that would at least explain my disconnect.
He throws it. Hard.
The phone hits the wall with a crack that makes me flinch. It falls to the floor, screen first, and I already know without looking that it's destroyed.
"Two years," he says quietly now, somehow worse than the shouting. "Two years and you'd rather touch that thing than touch me."
I don't have an answer. The worst part is that somewhere beneath his martyr act, there's a kernel of truth I can't escape: I really don't feel anything. Not with him. Not with anyone.
"You're frigid." He pulls on his jeans, movements jerky. "A frigid bitch incapable of feeling anything. Good luck finding someone willing to put up with that. Good luck finding anyone who wants to spend their life trying to warm up a corpse."
The bedroom door slams so hard the paintings rattle. A moment later, the front door follows. Then silence, and I'm entirely alone.
I stare at my phone on the floor. The screen is a spiderweb of cracks, the notification light still blinking weakly. That email from Patterson, probably.
Cold. Unresponsive. Broken. Frigid.
I pull my knees to my chest and press my forehead against them. The room still smells like his cologne. The sheets are tangled from his effort—though "effort" is generous. Five minutes of the same two positions, zero attention to anything that might actually work for me.
But maybe that's the point. Maybe I'm so broken that even a genuinely attentive partner wouldn't make a difference. Alex is lazy and selfish in bed—I've always known that—but David before him actually tried. He asked questions. He adjusted. He wanted to make it good for me.
And I still felt nothing.
So maybe Alex is right. Maybe the problem isn't his technique or his laughable definition of "trying everything." Maybe the problem is me.
The cracked phone blinks again. I should feel something—anger at the destruction, grief for a two-year relationship ending.
But there's just quiet. The same quiet that lives inside me during sex, during fights, during moments that should spark genuine emotion.
I cross the room and pick up the broken phone. The screen still works, barely visible through the fractures. Through the cracked glass, I can see it was just a calendar reminder.
Dentist appointment. Tomorrow at ten.
I almost laugh. Almost.
Instead, I sit on the cold floor and wonder if every man who's called me cold was right. If there's something fundamentally wrong with the wiring in my brain. If I'm destined to drift through relationships like a ghost, present in body but absent in every way that matters.
The silence has no answers. It never does.
Swipe up to continue
The café smells like burnt espresso and poor life decisions. So, basically, my natural habitat.
Gemma is already at our usual table, aggressively stabbing a croissant like it personally offended her. She spots me and her face cycles through approximately seventeen emotions before settling on murderous concern.
"You look like death warmed over and then microwaved again for good measure," she announces as I slide into the seat across from her.
"Good morning to you too. I see we're leading with compliments today."
"Alex texted me." She abandons the croissant massacre. "Something about how he's finally free of your—and I quote—'emotional black hole of a personality.' I'm going to need you to explain why I shouldn't drive to his flat and commit several felonies."
I flag down the waiter and order the largest coffee they're legally allowed to serve. "Because orange isn't your color and prison jumpsuits have zero tailoring options."
"Lottie. What happened?"
I give her the highlights. The sex that wasn't. The phone grab that was. The wall that my phone met at approximately sixty miles per hour. The greatest hits of insults, culminating in 'frigid bitch' as his parting gift.
I deliver the whole thing flatly, without self-pity. At some point during the night, I ran out of tears and moved directly into acceptance.
Gemma's knuckles go white around her fork.
"He threw your phone? He actually physically threw your phone at a wall?"
"In his defense, it was a very sturdy wall. The phone, less so." I pull out my ancient backup device, the one I kept in a drawer for emergencies. "Had to resurrect this dinosaur just to function like a human being in society. Pretty sure this thing still has Snake on it."
"This isn't funny, Lottie."
"It's a little funny. In a tragic, my-life-is-a-disaster-film kind of way."
Gemma reaches across the table and grabs my hand. Her nails are painted electric blue today, which feels aggressively optimistic given the circumstances.
"He's wrong about you. You know that, right? You're not cold or broken or any of that bullshit he spewed."
Here's the thing about Gemma: she believes what she's saying. Completely and without reservation. That's what makes this next part so hard.
"What if he's not entirely wrong, though?"
"Excuse me?"
My coffee arrives. I wrap my hands around the cup, grateful for something to hold onto. The warmth seeps into my palms while I figure out how to say this.
"Gemma, I've never had an orgasm with a man. Not with Alex. Not with David before him. Not with that guy from university whose name I can't even remember anymore. Not with anyone, ever."
She blinks. "Never? Not even when you—"
"Never. I've tried everything. I've guided their hands, given detailed instructions, drawn actual diagrams on more than one occasion. Nothing works. My body just... doesn't respond to them. Not in any way that actually counts."
"Maybe they were all just terrible at it."
"Three different men, spanning six years of my adult life, all independently terrible? At some point, Occam's razor suggests the common denominator is the problem."
I take a long sip of coffee. It's bitter and too hot and exactly what I deserve.
"I think I might be asexual. Or broken. Possibly both. Maybe my wiring is just fundamentally wrong and I should accept that I'm going to die alone, surrounded by cats who will eventually eat my face when I keel over."
"Okay, first of all, dramatic much? Second of all, you're not broken." Gemma leans forward, her expression shifting into something I can only describe as scheming. "And third of all, I know someone who can help."
"If you're about to recommend a therapist, I've already considered—"
"Not a therapist. A man. His name is Oliver."
I raise an eyebrow. "You want to set me up with someone? Gemma, I literally just got dumped twelve hours ago. My phone is still in pieces on my bedroom floor. This seems like spectacularly bad timing."
"He's not a date. Well, not exactly." She's doing that thing where she chooses her words carefully, which never bodes well for me. "He's a former gigolo."
The coffee I just swallowed makes a valiant attempt to exit through my nose. I grab a napkin and try to maintain some dignity.
"I'm sorry, what?"
"A gigolo. You know, a man who—"
"I know what a gigolo is, Gemma. I'm just trying to understand why you think hiring a prostitute is the solution to my intimacy issues."
"First of all, sex worker is the preferred term. Second of all, he's retired. And third of all, he specialized in exactly this—helping women who had trouble experiencing pleasure. He was apparently legendary at it."
"How do you even know someone like this?"
She waves a hand dismissively. "We met at a party a couple years ago. Had a one-night thing. Very skilled, emotionally unavailable, moved on quickly. But we stayed friendly."
"Of course you did."
"The point is, this isn't about paying for sex. Oliver is selective about who he helps now. He only takes cases that interest him. And your situation? Definitely interesting."
"I am not a case, Gemma. I'm a person with apparently defective genitals."
"Your genitals are not defective. You've just never had someone who actually knows what they're doing." She squeezes my hand again. "Let me reach out to him. One meeting, that's all I'm asking. You can have coffee, talk, see if there's chemistry. If you hate him, you never have to see him again."
"This is insane."
"This is intervention. There's a difference."
I stare at her. She stares back. The croissant lies forgotten between us, a casualty of this increasingly surreal conversation.
"Fine."
"Fine? Really?"
"One meeting. Tomorrow evening. And if this blows up in my face spectacularly, you're buying me a new phone and all the wine I can drink for the rest of the calendar year."
Gemma's face splits into a triumphant grin. "Deal. I'll text him right now."
She's already typing before I can change my mind. Her thumbs move across the screen with frightening efficiency.
I finish my coffee and wonder what exactly I've just agreed to. A former gigolo who specializes in unfixable women. It sounds like the setup for a bad joke or a worse romance novel.
But here's the pathetic truth: I don't actually expect anything to change. Three men have tried and failed. My body has made its position abundantly clear. I'm doing this for Gemma, to prove I'm willing to try, to check the box before I resign myself to a lifetime of faking it.
The notification pings on Gemma's phone.
"He's in. Tomorrow night, eight o'clock, the wine bar on Pemberton Street." She looks up, eyes sparkling with excitement. "This is going to change everything, Lottie. I can feel it."
I seriously doubt that.
But I don't say it out loud. Instead, I steal the rest of her croissant and pretend my stomach isn't twisting itself into complicated knots at the thought of meeting a professional pleasure-giver while still wearing the emotional bruises from Alex's parting words.
Frigid. Broken. Unresponsive.
Tomorrow night, apparently, I'm going to find out if he was right.
Swipe up to continue
My ancient backup phone rings at three in the afternoon. The ringtone is something I set in 2015 and never bothered to change—a tinny version of a song I no longer remember liking. Possibly One Direction. Definitely embarrassing.
"Darling!" My mother's voice could power a small city. "I have the most wonderful news!"
Helen Webb does not call with wonderful news. She calls with dramatic news that she's rebranded as wonderful through sheer force of optimism.
"What's happening, Mum?"
"I'm getting married! Next week! To Richard Crawford—you remember Richard, don't you? My oldest friend from university? We've reconnected and fallen madly in love!"
I nearly drop my dinosaur phone. "You're getting married? In one week?"
"Saturday! Isn't it wonderfully romantic? A whirlwind!"
Richard Crawford. The name triggers memories I'd successfully buried for fifteen years. A large house in Kent with too many rooms. Mum dragging me there several times a year throughout my childhood.
Richard was nice enough—quiet, proper, always offering me biscuits. His son was an entirely different story.
"Richard has a son," I say slowly. "Oliver."
"Yes! He's grown into such a lovely man, apparently. You two will finally get to reconnect properly!"
Reconnect. Oliver Crawford made every childhood visit a personal hell. He hid my dolls. Pulled my hair when no adults were watching. Once he locked me in a cupboard for two hours while our parents had tea. I screamed until my throat was raw, and he stood outside laughing.
"I haven't seen them in fifteen years, Mum."
"Exactly! Come Thursday evening—we'll have a lovely family dinner before the ceremony."
Thursday. Tomorrow. Also the night I'm meeting Gemma's retired gigolo.
"I have plans tomorrow evening."
"Cancel them! This is my wedding, Charlotte."
Wine bar at eight. Kent is ninety minutes by train.
"Fine. I'll arrive late. After ten."
"Perfect!" Mum launches into napkin colors and seating charts. I make appropriate noises while my mind drifts elsewhere.
I'm going to be Oliver Crawford's stepsister by Saturday.
The universe has a spectacularly twisted sense of humor.
* * *
The wine bar on Pemberton Street is dimly lit and pretentious. Exposed brick, candles everywhere, wine list longer than most novels.
Oliver—not Crawford, the other one—sits at a corner booth. Tall, dark-haired, unfairly attractive. He stands as I approach.
"Lottie. Gemma's description didn't do you justice."
"Gemma described me as emotionally unavailable and probably broken."
"She said you were direct." His smile is disarmingly warm. "I like direct. Please, sit."
I slide into the booth. Order wine. Oliver already has a glass of red.
"So," he says, "accountant by day, orgasm-seeker by night?"
I choke on nothing. "Gemma really did brief you thoroughly."
"She mentioned basics. I prefer hearing the rest directly. Start with the ex who destroyed your phone."
"Alex. Two years of him trying every position in the Kama Sutra, according to him. One vibrator used for thirty seconds. Ended with him calling me a frigid bitch and my phone meeting a wall."
"Charming. And before him?"
"David. Very earnest. Tantric breathing workshop that nearly killed him via hyperventilation."
Oliver laughs. "I'm seeing a pattern here."
"The pattern is I'm impossible to satisfy. Three men, six years, zero orgasms."
"Has anyone ever made you come?"
His green eyes hold mine steadily. No judgment. Just curiosity.
"No. Never."
Something silver catches candlelight at his throat—a medallion on a chain. Familiar, though I can't place why.
"I have a proposition. One night together. If I succeed, you owe me a proper date. If I fail, I buy you a new phone."
I study him—the easy confidence, the practiced charm. He's heard this story before.
"Fine. One night. After my family thing. But I'm warning you—I'll be the exception to your flawless record."
"We'll see." His smile turns knowing. "But first—a little preview."
Before I can respond, he's sliding around the booth beside me. His thigh presses warm against mine.
I feel the heat of him through my dress. But that familiar nothing settles in my chest—that disconnected blankness I've felt with every man who's tried this.
His fingers find my knee beneath the tablecloth.
"This is your revolutionary technique?" I keep my voice flat. "Hand on knee? Groundbreaking."
"Patience."
His hand slides higher. I watch it happen more than feel it—aware of pressure, but nothing sparking beneath my skin.
His lips brush my ear. His mouth on my neck feels warm, objectively pleasant, like a nice bath. Nothing more. I wait for something to ignite. It doesn't.
His knuckles graze the edge of my underwear. I'm dry. Predictably, disappointingly dry. My body doing exactly what it always does—absolutely nothing.
Here it comes. The moment he realizes I wasn't exaggerating.
But Oliver doesn't pull back. His fingers press against me through the fabric—light, experimental.
"Interesting," he says quietly, like he's solving a puzzle rather than failing at one.
"Told you. Defective."
"No. Just locked up tight. Most people respond to being touched. You need to be overwhelmed first."
His teeth graze my neck. Then he bites down properly. The pain is sudden, bright—and something flickers. Faint. Distant. Like a pilot light trying to catch.
His fingers increase pressure. Not gentle anymore. Deliberate. Demanding.
"There." He sounds satisfied. "That's the crack I was looking for."
The blankness wavers. Warmth spreads from where his mouth works against my neck.
His thumb finds my center through the cotton. Circles. Not polite. Not careful. Like he knows gentle doesn't work on me.
"Oh." The sound escapes before I can stop it.
"There we go." He's smiling against my throat. "Not easy to crack, are you? Need someone willing to work for it."
The warmth builds. Slowly. Stubbornly. Like coaxing fire from wet kindling. A minute passes. Two. He doesn't rush.
"Most people give up by now," I manage.
"Most people are impatient. I'm not."
His fingers slide beneath my underwear. Skin on skin. The pilot light catches properly—heat flooding outward, unexpected and overwhelming.
I gasp. Actually gasp, like a heroine in a terrible novel.
"There she is." His voice is rough with satisfaction.
He strokes through the wetness that wasn't there moments ago. His fingers circle with devastating precision, and the heat builds faster now—like he found the right frequency.
My thighs clench around his hand. The orgasm builds like a wave I've never felt before.
I'm close. Impossibly close. In a wine bar. With a stranger.
My breathing turns ragged—
He stops.
Completely. His hand withdraws. He slides back to his side of the booth, calm as anything.
I sit there panting, flushed, throbbing. The arousal that took so long to build pulses insistently, refusing to fade.
"What the hell?" My voice comes out strangled.
"Call me when you're back." He places a napkin with his number on the table. "I'll finish what I started."
"You can't just—"
"You're not a lost cause, Lottie. You're just complicated. I like complicated." He stands. "Most people gave up because you didn't respond in the first five minutes. They assumed you were broken instead of recognizing you need more."
He leans down, lips brushing my ear.
"I don't give up. And I always finish what I start."
He walks out. Doesn't look back.
I sit alone, trembling, more aroused than I've ever been. The spot on my neck throbs where he marked me. I don't notice the hickey forming.
All I know is that for the first time in my life, I felt something real. Not immediate. Not easy. But real.
And I'm desperate for more.
Swipe up to continue