Amy’s POV
I stared at him like he had just grown a second head. His words echoed in my ears like some weird, delayed joke I wasn’t sure how to process.
“With you?” I repeated slowly, raising both eyebrows. “What, like therapy sessions and yoga or something?”
James grinned as he scooped another spoonful of vanilla ice cream from the tiny McDonald’s cup and licked it like we were talking about the weather. “Nah,” he said casually. “Fake dating. Public. Petty. Perfect.”
I blinked.
Then blinked again.
It took a second before the absurdity of what he said hit me fully, and to my own surprise, I let out a laugh. A real one. It tumbled out of me, cracked and messy, but real. My chest shook with it, and I covered my mouth, afraid the whole restaurant might hear.
“You’re joking,” I said once I caught my breath. “You have to be joking.”
James leaned back in the booth, resting one arm along the seat and looking at me with that cocky little smirk that I was beginning to think never really left his face. “Nope,” he said. “Dead serious. You get your power back, and I get to piss off your ex. Win-win.”
Our schools are rivals because it’s been that way forever. It all started with this one huge sports season, and ever since, we’ve been competing for everything—who’s got the better team, the better athletes, you name it. It’s like we can’t help but go at each other, always trying to one-up the other school.
I stared at him, stunned. I had never met someone so bold. So weirdly confident. He wasn’t just joking around—he meant it. He was actually suggesting we fake date each other. Me. Amy Garcia. Miss predictable. Miss good girl. Miss background pretty.
“And you’d really do that?” I asked, trying to find the catch.
James shrugged, like it was no big deal. “Let’s just say…”—he paused, and his eyes danced with something teasing and maybe even a little dangerous—“…I have a thing for pretty girls with messy lives.”
My heart skipped.
Literally skipped.
I hated that it did, but it did. James Carter was bold, wild, and the complete opposite of everything I thought I wanted in a guy. And yet, there was something magnetic about him. Something that made it hard to look away.
He didn’t try to fix me. He didn’t tell me I was overreacting. He didn’t say “you’ll get over it” or “they’re not worth it”like everyone else probably would. Instead, he just showed up in a black Jeep, nearly ran me over, and offered ice cream and revenge.
And now he was offering this. A plan. A new identity. A chance to rewrite the ending to my summer.
I looked down at the remains of my fries, cold and soggy now, and tried to picture what life would look like if I actually said yes. If I walked through school with James Carter beside me, if I smiled for photos and held his hand just to watch Charlie squirm. If I stopped playing the role everyone expected and did something reckless for once in my life.
It didn’t sound awful.
It actually sounded… kind of amazing.
After a while, we left the booth, tossing our trash in the bin near the exit. The sky had grown darker outside, stars scattered across it like glitter on black velvet. The parking lot was mostly empty now, the glow from the streetlights casting long shadows as we walked back to his Jeep.
The silence between us wasn’t awkward. It was the kind of quiet that felt full of something waiting to happen.
When we reached my house, he pulled up to the curb and left the engine running. The porch light was on, and I could see the curtains in the living room window twitch slightly. Mom was probably peeking through, wondering where I had gone after storming out.
I unbuckled my seatbelt slowly, not ready for this weird night to end.
Before I could open the door, James spoke again.
“Let me pick you up tomorrow,” he said, his voice softer now but still confident. “We’ll make it official. Operation: Reinvent Amy.”
I froze with my hand on the door handle. My heart beat a little faster.
Operation: Reinvent Amy.
It sounded ridiculous.
It sounded like something out of a movie.
But maybe that was what I needed.
Not a boyfriend. Not more tears. Not more explanations.
Just something new. Something mine.
I turned to look at him one last time, studying the curve of his smile and the way his curls framed his face in the dim light.
Then I opened the door, one foot hitting the pavement. I paused, staring up at my front porch, and then back at him.
I hesitated.
Then smiled.
“Fine,” I said, the corners of my lips lifting into something I hadn’t felt all day.
“Tomorrow. Let’s fake-date the hell out of this summer.”
Swipe up to continue
Amy’s POV
The smell of hair dye filled my bathroom, heavy and pungent, like cherries and chemicals had exploded in the air. I was barefoot on the cool white tiles, wearing an oversized T-shirt, my hands stained pink like I’d just finished painting something dangerous. My hair was soaking wet, heavy with color, twisted up under a plastic shower cap as I stared at my reflection in the fogged-up mirror.
I didn’t look like myself. And for once, I actually liked that.
The old Amy would’ve never done this. She would’ve cared too much—about what people thought, what Charlie would say, what her cheer captain status meant. But that girl was gone, buried under layers of betrayal, rage, and vanilla fries. In her place was someone braver. Wilder. Messier.
I grabbed my phone from the counter, fingers trembling as I typed out a text to my mom in Italy. “Hey, just checking in. Hope everything’s good there. Miss you.”
I hit send and stared at the screen. Seconds ticked by. No response.
I knew it was coming. It always was. A few hours later, my phone buzzed with a vague reply: “Busy. Everything’s fine here.” It wasn’t even a real answer, just another reminder of how alone I really was.
When I rinsed the dye out, it stained the sink like spilled wine. When I dried it and looked in the mirror, I couldn’t stop staring. The shade was loud, almost firetruck red, with hints of orange in the sunlight. It clashed with my pale skin, made my brown eyes look darker, sharper. It didn’t match anything I owned.
And I loved it.
It wasn’t subtle. It wasn’t polite. It didn’t whisper. It screamed.
I opened my phone, went to Charlie’s contact, and stared at his name. My thumb hovered over it for a moment. There was a time when I would have hesitated. Not anymore. I blocked him on everything—Instagram, Snapchat, even Venmo. I didn’t want to see his face or his stupid updates. I didn’t want to be reminded of how he used to call me “his girl” and then let Camilla straddle him like I didn’t even exist.
Then I opened Instagram.
I took a selfie, tilting my head so the red hair looked wild around my face. My lips were parted slightly. My eyeliner sharp. My eyes still puffy from the last two days, but determined. Fierce.
I posted it with the caption: watch me rise.
Ten minutes later, I posted another one—this time from the front porch, my new hair glowing in the sunlight. I captioned that one: background girls don’t burn.
My phone lit up with likes, heart reacts, shocked comments from classmates. Even some of the cheer girls messaged me things like “omg bold queen” and “slayyyyyy.” I didn’t care if they meant it or not. I cared that I felt powerful for once.
The next morning, I sat on the steps in front of my house, sipping iced coffee, waiting to see if James would actually show up.
At exactly 10:03 AM, his black Jeep pulled up to the curb, windows rolled down, music thumping low from the speakers. He was wearing dark sunglasses and leaned back in the driver’s seat like he owned the entire planet. When he turned his head and looked at me, he whistled.
“Damn,” he said, sliding the sunglasses down the bridge of his nose just a little. “I almost didn’t recognize you.”
He paused, grinning.
“Almost.”
I rolled my eyes but smiled as I got in the car. “You ready for this, fake boyfriend?”
He smirked. “You kidding? I was born for chaos.”
Our first official fake date wasn’t dinner or a movie or anything normal. James insisted that normal was boring. Instead, we drove downtown and hit up a thrift store with one goal: pick the weirdest outfit possible for the other person and then wear it in public, no complaints.
He handed me a sparkly blue cowboy jacket, oversized red sunglasses, and a skirt with sequins shaped like cats. I gave him a vintage pink hoodie with glittery letters that spelled out “Drama Queen” and a pair of yellow bell bottoms.
We wore them. We owned them.
People stared. We laughed.
Then, on the way back to the car, we stopped at a random gas station where someone had set up a small karaoke machine out front as part of some summer promotion. James grabbed the mic like it was a sword, and without warning, belted out the worst, most off-key version of “Livin’ on a Prayer” I’d ever heard in my life. He didn’t care that people were watching. In fact, he bowed at the end like he had just performed at Madison Square Garden.
I laughed so hard I almost dropped my slushie.
We ended the day on the roof of the old, abandoned theater by Main Street. James climbed up first, then reached down to pull me up, our hands warm and sticky from cherry-flavored syrup. We sat side by side on the rough concrete edge, slushies in hand, legs swinging over the edge. The sun had just started to set, painting the sky with streaks of pink and purple.
For a moment, everything felt quiet. Not sad quiet. Just still. Like the world had paused for us.
I snapped a photo on impulse—me mid-laugh, my head thrown back, James holding my hand and smirking at the camera like he knew exactly what he was doing.
I posted it right away.
Caption: This summer, I choose chaos.
By the time I got home and showered, the post had already blown up. More comments. More fire emojis. Some people were confused. Some were nosy. I ignored them all.
But one notification made my stomach twist.
A DM.
From Charlie.
I opened it with shaky fingers.
His message was short.
Cruel.
“You’re hotter angry.”
Swipe up to continue
Amy’s POV
The gym smelled like sweat, citrus body spray, and determination. I was on my second round of sprints, trying to outrun everything tangled in my chest—Charlie’s message, the memory of Camilla’s smug smile, and the way my own voice still cracked when I said their names out loud. I didn’t want to think about any of it. I wanted to burn it all away. So I ran harder, faster, until the air burned my lungs and my legs trembled.
I had been coming to this summer training camp three days a week, mostly because it was the one place where I didn’t have to smile or explain myself. No one here cared about school gossip. No one asked about my relationship status. They just ran, stretched, and sweated in silence.
I was halfway through a cooldown stretch when I heard the sound of sneakers behind me and the familiar rustle of a plastic cup holder.
“Please tell me those are for me,” I said without turning around.
James’s voice was smug and full of trouble. “Only if you haven’t passed out yet.”
I turned and found him standing there, a cocky smile plastered across his face and two large iced coffees in his hands. He wore joggers and a sleeveless hoodie, and his curls looked even messier than usual, like he’d just rolled out of bed and into a Nike ad.
“Is this your way of stalking me now?” I asked, raising an eyebrow.
“Nah,” he said with a lazy shrug. “Just checking if you still cry when you run.”
I snorted, taking one of the coffees and pressing the cold plastic against my cheek. “Rude. But fair.”
We sat down on a nearby bench under the shade. I sipped my drink and gave him a sideways glance. “You know, there’s a couples steam yoga session starting in twenty minutes.”
He raised an eyebrow. “Couples?”
I grinned. “Well, we are fake dating, aren’t we? I figured we should make it believable. Plus, I could use a laugh watching you fall over.”
He groaned dramatically. “That’s not even real exercise.”
I leaned closer, poking him in the ribs. “If you survive it, I’ll buy you tacos.”
His eyes narrowed playfully. “You drive a hard bargain, Garcia. Fine. But if I die in there, I want fries at my funeral.”
We changed quickly and walked into the steam room studio, where the air was already thick and heavy with heat and eucalyptus. The instructor gave us mats and smiled at us like we were some hot couple in a movie montage. I could feel the sweat on my neck before we even started.
The first few poses were easy—some deep breathing, gentle stretches—but it didn’t stay that way for long. Soon we were balancing on one foot, twisted in ways that felt unnatural, the steam clinging to our skin and making everything slippery and intense.
James wasn’t terrible, but he wasn’t great either.
“Still think this isn’t real exercise?” I teased, glancing at him as he wobbled in a half-lunge, half-pretzel pose.
His hand reached out, steadying himself on my hip, and I felt it like a jolt of lightning. His fingers were warm, firm, and didn’t move right away. My breath caught, just for a second, as his palm rested there a moment too long. He smirked, but there was something different in his eyes—something quieter. More serious.
“Just trying not to break my face,” he said, his voice softer than before.
I nodded, trying to focus, but my heart had picked up its own rhythm, one that had nothing to do with yoga. We shifted into another pose, and I stepped slightly off balance, not expecting the ground to tilt the way it did. My foot slipped.
James caught me instantly.
His arms were strong around my waist, holding me in place, pulling me closer than either of us probably meant to be. I froze in his grip, my hand braced against his chest, feeling his heart pounding beneath my palm.
I didn’t move.
Neither did he.
I looked up, meeting his eyes, and something thick and unspoken passed between us.
“Why are you looking at me like that?” I whispered.
His gaze didn’t waver. His hands didn’t let go.
“Like what?”
I swallowed.
“Like this fake thing,” he said, barely above a whisper, “is starting to feel dangerously real.”
Swipe up to continue