Nate’s POV
"Are you ready for this?" I ask Kat as we approach the main dining hall, my hand finding the small of her back with practiced ease.
The gesture looks natural, protective, exactly what people expect from a new boyfriend.
"As ready as I'll ever be," she replies, though I can hear the nervous tremor in her voice. "Just remember what we practiced."
The main dining hall at Ridgeview is designed to impress and long tables arranged in a careful hierarchy that everyone understands but no one openly acknowledges.
The athletes' table sits perfectly in the center, visible from every angle, commanding respect and envy in equal measure.
As we walk through the entrance, conversations pause. Heads turn. Eyes track our progress with laser focus.
"There's the table," I say, nodding toward the center where my teammates are already gathered. "Remember, just be yourself. They're going to love you."
I guide her through the maze of tables, acutely aware of the whispered conversations that follow in our wake. Kat keeps her chin up, her posture perfect.
"Nate!" Marcus Chen calls out, our goalie grinning as he waves us over. "About time you showed up. We were starting to think you'd forgotten how to eat."
"Just had some important business to take care of," I say with a grin, pulling out a chair for Kat.
It happens to be right next to where Liam usually sits, which is perfect for maximum impact. The reaction is immediate and exactly what I'd hoped for.
Conversations around our table stutter to a halt as my teammates take in the sight of Kat settling gracefully into the chair, her designer sweater and confident smile marking her as someone who belongs in their world.
"Guys, I'd like you to meet Kat," I say, taking the seat beside her and casually draping my arm around her shoulders. "Kat, these are the animals I have the privilege of playing hockey with."
"Animals is right," laughs Jessica Martinez, captain of the soccer team and Marcus's girlfriend. "Though some of them are house-trained."
Kat smiles, and I'm impressed by how natural she looks despite what I know has to be nerves.
"It's nice to meet you all. I've heard so much about the hockey team."
"All good things, I hope," says Tyler Ross, our right wing and notorious flirt.
His eyes linger on Kat with obvious appreciation, and I feel a sudden spike of something that might be jealousy.
Which is ridiculous, since this is all fake anyway.
"Mostly good," Kat replies with a laugh that sounds genuinely amused. "Though Nate did warn me about the locker room humor."
"Hey, that's not locker room humor," protests Jake Morrison, our left wing. "That's just my charming personality."
The banter continues, and I watch with growing satisfaction as Kat seamlessly integrates herself into the group dynamic.
She laughs at Tyler's jokes, compliments Jessica on her recent tournament win, and asks intelligent questions about our upcoming season. Within minutes, it's like she's always been part of our circle.
More importantly, I can see the effect our little performance is having on the rest of the dining hall.
The whispered conversations, the pointed looks, the way other students are reassessing Kat now that she's clearly under my protection.
"So Kat," Jessica says, leaning forward with obvious curiosity, "how long have you and Nate been together? I feel like this came out of nowhere."
I feel Kat tense slightly beside me, but her smile never wavers.
"It's still pretty new," she says, glancing at me with what looks like genuine affection. "We've been getting to know each other before I started here."
"And he finally worked up the courage to ask you out?" Tyler grins. "That's not like our boy Nate. Usually he's smooth as silk with the ladies."
"Maybe I just needed to meet the right girl," I say, squeezing Kat's shoulders gently.
The words come out easier than I'd expected, and for a moment I almost believe them myself.
"Aw, that's actually sweet," Jessica coos. "I love a good romance story."
"Speaking of romance," Marcus says with a wicked grin, "wait until Liam sees this. He's going to lose his mind."
I feel Kat stiffen at the mention of my brother, though she tries to hide it.
"Why would Liam care?" she asks, her voice carefully neutral.
"Because he's been in a mood all week," Tyler explains. "Even worse than usual, which is saying something. And now his little brother is dating the hottest new girl at school? His ego's going to take a serious hit."
"Liam doesn't control my dating life," I say firmly, though part of me is secretly pleased at the idea of getting under his skin. "Besides, he's too focused on hockey season to care about my personal life."
"Don't be so sure about that," Jake says, nodding toward the dining hall entrance. "Speak of the devil."
I turn to see Liam walking through the entrance, his usual confident stride faltering as his eyes sweep the room and land on our table.
Even from across the dining hall, I can see the exact moment he processes what he's seeing—Kat sitting in his usual spot, my arm around her shoulders, the easy way she's laughing with our teammates.
His jaw clenches. Something dark flashes across his face before he manages to school his expression back to forced neutral.
"This should be interesting," Marcus murmurs, following my gaze.
Liam makes his way across the dining hall with deliberate slowness, stopping to chat with other students, clearly trying to project an image of casual indifference.
"Hey everyone," he says as he approaches our table, his voice perfectly pleasant. "Sorry I'm late. Got held up talking to Coach about the game Friday."
"No problem, bro," I say, making sure to keep my arm firmly around Kat's shoulders. "We saved you a seat."
Liam's eyes flick to Kat, then back to me, and I see something dangerous flash in their green depths.
"I see we have a guest at our table."
"Actually," I say, meeting his gaze steadily, "I'd like you all to officially meet my girlfriend, Kat."
The word 'girlfriend' hangs in the air like a challenge.
I feel Kat's subtle intake of breath beside me, see the way Jessica's eyes widen with delight, hear Tyler's low whistle of appreciation.
But it's Liam's reaction that holds my attention. For just a moment, his carefully constructed mask slips, and I see something raw and unguarded in his expression.
Pain, maybe. Or rage. Or something else entirely that I can't quite identify.
"Congratulations," he says finally, but the word sounds more like a threat than a blessing. His smile is sharp enough to cut glass. "I hope you know what you're getting yourself into, Kat."
"I think I can handle it," Kat replies smoothly, though I can feel the tension radiating from her body. "Your brother's been nothing but wonderful to me."
"I'm sure he has," Liam says, his tone making it clear that he means the exact opposite. "Nate's always been good at making people feel... welcome."
The conversation continues around us, but I'm focused entirely on the silent battle of wills happening between Liam and me.
This is more than just brotherly rivalry—this is war. And Kat is caught right in the middle of it, whether she realizes it or not.
"Well," Liam says finally, pulling out the chair across from Kat, "I guess I'll have to get used to having a sister-in-law around."
The casual cruelty of the comment—implying that our relationship is serious enough for marriage while making it clear he thinks it will never last—is so perfectly Liam that I almost have to admire it.
"We'll see how it goes," Kat says lightly, but I catch the flash of anger in her eyes.
Let the games begin, indeed.
Swipe up to continue
Kat’s POV
Three days into our fake relationship, I was starting to understand what I'd been missing at my previous school.
The difference in how people treated me was remarkable—where before I'd been the scandal-ridden transfer student to be avoided, now I was Nate Carter's girlfriend, automatically granted entry into the most exclusive social circles at Ridgeview.
"This is actually kind of addictive," I admitted to Nate as we walked across the quad together, his hand warm in mine. "The way people look at us now."
"You mean like we actually matter?" he said with a grin. "Yeah, I've noticed the difference too. Even the teachers are treating you differently."
He was right. Professor Colton had actually smiled at me during Advanced Literature yesterday, and I'd been invited to join a study group for AP Physics—something that never would have happened when I was eating lunch alone.
"I got asked to three different parties this weekend," I said, still amazed by the sudden shift in my social status. "Three!”
"Actually," Nate said, his eyes lighting up with excitement, "forget those parties. I have something much better in mind."
I raised an eyebrow. "Better than three parties?"
"Way better." He stopped walking and turned to face me, his hands gripping mine. "You remember Marcus and Jessica from lunch? And Tyler and Jake?"
"Of course."
"They're going to Marcus's family lake house near Ontario this weekend. It's their beginning-of-semester tradition—big group trip, lots of people, total blast."
His smile grew wider. "They asked me to invite you too."
My heart did a little flip. "They want me there?"
"The whole crew's going. Hockey team, soccer team, even some people from the figure skating team. And get this—the lake usually freezes early up there, so you can bring your skates if you want."
"Really?" The idea of skating on a frozen lake, surrounded by mountains, sounded like something out of a dream.
"Really. What do you say? Want to spend the weekend at a lake house with your fake boyfriend?"
I grinned. "When you put it like that, how can I refuse?"
* * *
Friday evening arrived faster than I'd expected.
The drive to the lake house was filled with laughter and music, our group of seventeen crammed into various cars. When we finally arrived at the sprawling log cabin nestled against the mountainside, I couldn't help but gasp.
"This is incredible," I breathed, taking in the massive deck that overlooked the lake, the towering pines, the way the setting sun painted everything golden.
"Wait until you see the inside," Jessica said, grabbing my arm. "Marcus's parents basically built a resort up here."
The inside was even more impressive—stone fireplaces, leather furniture, a kitchen that could feed an army. But as everyone began claiming rooms and unpacking, reality hit me like a slap.
"So we're in the blue room," Nate said casually, shouldering both our bags. "Second door on the right."
I followed him down the hallway, my stomach churning with sudden nerves.
When he opened the door, my fears were confirmed—one king-sized bed dominated the room, flanked by large windows that offered a perfect view of the lake.
"One bed," I said, my voice coming out smaller than I'd intended.
"One bed," Nate confirmed, setting our bags down.
He turned to look at me, and whatever he saw in my expression made him grin.
"Oh, come on. Don't tell me you’re nervous about sharing a bed with your boyfriend."
"I'm not nervous," I said quickly, then immediately contradicted myself. "I mean, I am, but not because… It's just that we're not actually—"
"Katya." Nate stepped closer, his voice gentle but teasing. "Relax. I'm not going to attack you in your sleep. I'll stay on my side, you stay on yours. Easy."
"But what if someone comes in? What if they expect us to—"
"They won't," he said firmly. "And if they do, we'll deal with it. Trust me, everything's going to be fine."
His confidence was reassuring, but as night fell and we prepared for bed, my nerves returned with a vengeance.
I changed in the bathroom, taking longer than necessary to brush my teeth and wash my face, trying to calm my racing heart.
When I finally emerged in my pajamas, Nate was already in bed, scrolling through his phone.
He'd changed into just boxer shorts, and I tried not to stare at his bare chest, the defined muscles of his shoulders, the way the lamplight played across his soft skin...
"You okay?" he asked, patting the empty side of the bed.
"Fine," I managed, sliding under the covers and immediately scooting as far to my side as possible without falling off.
"Goodnight, Kat," he said softly, reaching over to turn off the lamp.
"Goodnight," I whispered back.
But sleep wouldn't come for a long time.
I lay there in the darkness, hyperaware of every sound he made, every shift of his body, the warmth radiating from his side of the bed.
The memory of his bare chest kept flashing through my mind, and I squeezed my thighs and eyes shut, trying to force myself to think about something else.
Anything else but Nates Carter’s freakingly hot body.
The next morning dawned crisp and clear, the lake surface frozen solid and sparkling in the sunlight. By the time I'd managed to drag myself out of bed—having finally fallen asleep around three AM—the house was already buzzing with activity.
"Perfect skating weather," Marcus announced as we gathered for breakfast. "The ice is thick enough."
I felt a thrill of excitement as I looked out at the pristine surface, imagining the feeling of gliding across it with mountains as my backdrop.
"You brought your skates, right?" Jessica asked, nudging me with her elbow.
"Of course she did," Nate said, appearing at my side with a cup of coffee. "My girlfriend doesn't go anywhere without her skates."
The casual way he said 'my girlfriend' sent a heated flutter through my chest, but I pushed it aside.
This was all part of the act. The performance.
The day unfolded like something out of a movie. We spent hours on the lake—some of us skating, others playing impromptu hockey with borrowed equipment.
I felt truly happy for the first time in months, laughing with new friends, showing off jumps and spins that earned impressed cheers from the crowd.
Nate stayed close, his hand finding mine whenever we weren't actively skating, his arm around my waist as we watched the hockey game. Everything felt natural, comfortable, right.
Everything except the weight of Liam's stare.
He'd come on the trip too, of course. I'd seen him arrive with the second group of cars, had watched him claim a room on the opposite end of the hall.
But throughout the day, I could feel his eyes on me. On us.
On the way Nate's fingers intertwined with mine, the way we leaned into each other, the easy intimacy of our fake relationship.
It made my skin burn in ways I didn't want to examine.
Late in the afternoon, as the sun began to set, I joined the figure skating team for one last session on the lake. We spread out across the ice, practicing jumps and spins, lost in the pure joy of movement.
That's when I heard it—a sharp crack that echoed across the water like a gunshot.
"Everyone off the ice!" Marcus shouted from the shore. "Now!"
Panic exploded through the group as we all scrambled toward the shore. The ice was giving way, spider web cracks spreading across the surface with terrifying speed.
I was the farthest out, near the center of the lake, and I could hear the ice groaning beneath my feet as I raced toward safety.
Almost there. Almost—
The world exploded into freezing water as the ice gave way beneath me. The shock stole my breath, the cold hitting my body like a physical blow. I flailed, trying to find purchase on the crumbling ice edge, but my waterlogged clothes were dragging me down.
"Kat!" Nate's voice, distant and panicked.
Then suddenly, strong arms were hauling me up, pulling me from the water onto more solid ice. I gasped, choking on lake water, my entire body shaking from cold and shock.
"Got you," a familiar voice said, rough with exertion. "You're okay. I got you."
I looked up through chattering teeth to see Liam's face above me as his arms remained locked around my trembling body. His hair was wet—he'd gotten in the water to reach me.
His green eyes fierce with concern and something else. More softer than I’ve ever seen.
"True Ice Princess now, huh," he said, but his voice was gentle, almost tender.
Then Nate was there, pulling me from Liam's arms into his own. "I've got her," he said, his voice tight with something I couldn't identify. "I've got you, baby."
He lifted me easily, carrying me toward the house as I shivered against his chest.
But as we reached the shore, I found myself looking back over his shoulder at Liam, who was still standing at the water's edge, watching us with an expression I couldn't read.
Swipe up to continue
Kat’s POV
Nate kicked our bedroom door shut with his foot, his arms still wrapped around me as I shivered violently against his chest.
My teeth chattered so hard I could barely speak.
"N-Nate, I'm f-fine," I managed to stammer, but my body betrayed me with another violent shudder.
"Like hell you are," he said, setting me down on the bed with surprising gentleness. "We need to get you out of these wet clothes. Now."
"I can do it myself," I protested.
But when I tried to grab the hem of my soaked sweater, my fingers wouldn't cooperate. They were numb, clumsy, useless.
"No, you can't," Nate said firmly, stepping closer. "Kat, you're hypothermic. Stop being stubborn and let me help you."
"But I'm not— We're not actually—"
"I don't care what we are or aren't," he interrupted, his hands already reaching for my sweater. "You're freezing to death, and I'm not letting that happen to you."
His fingers brushed mine as he gently pushed my hands away, and I felt heat flood my cheeks despite the cold.
"Close your eyes if it makes you feel better," he said softly, "but these clothes are coming off. Right now."
I squeezed my eyes shut as he carefully pulled my sweater over my head, his movements respectful but efficient. When his hands moved to the waistband of my jeans, I grabbed his wrists.
"I can't," I whispered, my voice barely audible.
"Yes, you can," he said, his voice gentle but unwavering. "Trust me, Kat. I'm not looking at anything I shouldn't. I'm simply trying to keep you safe."
The wet denim clung to my legs as he helped me out of my jeans, and I kept my eyes firmly closed, mortification burning through me even as my body continued to shake. When he wrapped a dry towel around me, I finally opened my eyes to find him already turning away, giving me privacy.
"Get changed while I run you a hot bath," he said, his back to me.
I heard him turn on the faucet in the bathroom, followed by a string of creative curses. I only had time to put on a new pair of underwear when I heard his footsteps and sprinted under the covers.
"No water," he said, appearing in the doorway with a frustrated expression. "I’ll go check what's wrong with the plumbing."
He left me alone in the room, pulling covers up to my chin. But even though it was already dry and under blankets, I couldn't stop shaking. The cold seemed to have settled into my bones, and every breath felt like ice crystals forming in my lungs.
That's when the memories hit me.
Liam's face above me as he pulled me from the water. The way his voice had been rough with concern. The feel of his strong arms hauling me to safety.
The look in his green eyes—like he was genuinely afraid for me.
Why had he been the one to save me? Why had he risked himself to get me out of the water?
The door opened, and Nate returned, shaking his head grimly.
"Marcus says the pump is out of order. No water until the plumber comes tomorrow morning." He looked at me huddled under the blankets, and his expression grew alarmed. "Jesus, Kat, you're still freezing."
"I'm f-fine," I lied, my teeth chattering so hard I could barely form words.
Nate crossed the room in two strides and started pulling his shirt over his head.
"Wait, what are you doing?" I sat up straighter, clutching the blankets to my chest.
"Getting in bed with you before you freeze to death," he said matter-of-factly, tossing his shirt aside. "Body heat is the fastest way to warm someone up"
"Nate, we can't—"
"We can and we will," he said, unbuttoning his jeans.
I squeezed my eyes shut as he stripped down to his boxers, but I could hear the rustle of fabric, the soft thud of clothes hitting the floor. The mattress dipped as he climbed into bed beside me.
"Come here," he said, his voice gentle but commanding.
The second his warm skin touched mine, I gasped with relief. Without thinking, I pressed closer, seeking more of that blessed heat.
His arms came around me, pulling me against his strong chest, and I tangled my legs with his, desperate to absorb every bit of warmth he offered.
"Better?" he asked, his breath warm against my hair.
"God, yes," I breathed, melting into him. His hands stroked my back in slow, soothing circles, and I let out a soft moan of relief.
The heat from his body was intoxicating.
I found myself pressing closer, my hips moving against his without conscious thought, soft sounds escaping my lips as warmth finally began to seep back into my bones.
"Kat," Nate said, his voice strained. "You need to—"
But I was lost in the sensation, the blessed relief of finally being warm. I ground against him again, and his sharp intake of breath cut through the haze in my mind.
"Katya, stop," he said more firmly, his hands gripping my hips. In one smooth motion, he rolled onto his back, pulling me on top of him. "You need to stay still."
"What?" I looked down at him, confused by the sudden change in position.
"I promised I wouldn't touch you," he said, his voice rough. "But I'm still a man, and you're a beautiful, half-naked girl grinding against me. So unless you want this fake relationship to become very real very fast, you need to stop moving against me."
The meaning of his words hit me like a physical blow. Heat that had nothing to do with hypothermia flooded my cheeks as I realized what I'd been doing, what I'd been making him feel.
"Oh god," I whispered, mortified. "I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to—"
The door burst open without warning.
Liam stood in the doorway, his eyes taking in the scene—me straddling Nate's bare chest, both of us flushed and breathing hard.
For a moment, nobody moved. Nobody spoke.
Then I buried my face in Nate's chest, wishing I could disappear entirely.
"Having fun, I see?" Liam asked, his voice dripping with sarcasm.
Something sailed through the air, and Nate caught it smoothly—a heating pad.
"Thought you might need this," Liam said, his tone mocking. "Though it looks like you two have the warming-up situation well in hand."
"Thanks, brother," Nate said tightly, his arms tightening around me protectively.
"Don't mention it," Liam replied. "Wouldn't want the lovebirds to catch a cold."
When the door slammed shut behind him, I groaned into Nate's chest. "I want to die."
"Don't worry about him," Nate said, his hand stroking my hair. "He's just being an ass."
But I could hear something in his voice—tension, anger, something darker that I couldn't identify.
The next morning, I woke up warm and surprisingly rested, still wrapped in Nate's arms. True to his word, he'd been a perfect gentleman, holding me close but never taking advantage of our intimate position.
"Feeling better?" he asked, his voice husky with sleep.
"Much," I admitted, though I made no move to disentangle myself from his embrace.
We spent the day inside, everyone too concerned about my near-drowning to venture back onto the ice. The house filled with the sounds of conversation and laughter, but I couldn't shake the weight of Liam's stare.
Every time I looked up, he was watching me with those intense green eyes, and I couldn't stop thinking about the way he'd looked at me in bed with Nate.
"Let's play Seven Minutes in Heaven!" announced Sarah, one of the figure skaters, holding up an empty bottle.
Several people groaned, but others perked up with interest. Marcus and a few others headed to the living room for beer pong, but enough people stayed to make a circle.
"I'm in," I said quickly, not wanting to seem like a prude in front of my new friends.
The bottle spun, landing on couples who disappeared into the hall closet amid cheers and catcalls.
My heart hammered as I waited for my turn, wondering what it would be like to be alone with Nate for the whole seven minutes.
"Nate!" Marcus called from the living room. "Can you help me move this table?"
"Be right back," Nate said, squeezing my hand before leaving.
The bottle spun again, and this time it landed on me. Of-fucking-course.
Sarah spun it a second time to choose my partner, and my blood turned to ice as it slowed, wobbled, and finally stopped.
Pointing directly at Liam.
"Ooh, this should be interesting," someone said, but their voice sounded miles away.
Liam stood slowly, his green eyes locked on mine. "Come on, Princess," he said, his voice low and dangerous. "Seven minutes in heaven as they said."
The closet door closed behind us with a soft click, plunging us into darkness.
For a long moment, neither of us spoke, the tension so thick I could barely breathe.
"So," Liam said finally, his voice a low rumble in the darkness. "Having fun playing house with my brother?"
"It's not playing house," I said, my voice sharper than I intended.
"Isn't it?" He stepped closer, and I could feel the heat radiating from his body in the small space. "The perfect girlfriend, the loving couple, the whole charade. You're quite the actress, Princess."
"Don't call me that."
"Why not? It's what you are, isn't it? Rich girl with daddy's money, skating through life on your reputation."
"You don't know anything about me," I hissed, anger flaring in my chest.
"I know enough," he said, stepping even closer. I could feel his breath on my face now, warm and intimate in the darkness. "I know you're using my brother."
"I'm not—"
"And I know you're playing games you don't even understand," he continued, his voice dropping to a whisper. "With people you can't control."
"Like you?"
The question hung in the air between us, charged with something dangerous and electric. I could hear his breathing, feel the heat of his body just inches from mine.
"Yeah, Princess," he said, his voice rough as he stepped closer and placed his hands on the both sides of my head, leaning closer and closer. "Like me."
I felt him lean even closer, felt my own heartbeat in my throat, the heat pooling heavy in my belly. Felt the whisper of his breath against my lips.
My heart hammered against my ribs as the space between us disappeared inches by inches—before the closet door burst open, flooding us with light.
"Having fun with my girlfriend?" Nate's voice was deadly calm, but I could hear the fury underneath.
Liam straightened slowly, his eyes never leaving mine. "Just having a conversation."
"I bet you were." Nate's hand found my arm, pulling me from the closet. "Time's up, brother."
The word 'brother' sounded like a curse, and I could feel the violence simmering just beneath the surface as the two of them faced off.
Swipe up to continue