"You want to become a nun?"
Sister Agnes's question hung in the air of Father Atticus's study like incense, sweet and heavy. I'd cornered them both here, timing it perfectly when they were reviewing the weekly shelter reports together—two birds, one stone.
My carefully arranged expression of spiritual longing must have been convincing, because both of them were staring at me with the kind of gentle expectation that made my skin crawl just a little.
God, I hate having to play the devoted convert.
"I... I think I do," I whispered, letting uncertainty color my voice while my mind remained coldly calculating. This was it—my path deeper into their organization, closer to Mikael, further from my family's reach. "I've been praying about it for days now, and I keep feeling this... calling."
Calling. Right. The only thing calling me is survival.
Father Atticus leaned forward in his chair, his grandfatherly eyes warming with what looked like genuine pleasure. "Tell us what you're feeling, child. What draws you to religious life?"
I dropped my gaze to my hands, arranged them in my lap with practiced humility.
The lie formed itself with the ease of long habit.
"When I was... with him," I began, letting my voice catch slightly on the fabricated abusive boyfriend, "I thought love was supposed to hurt. That pain was just part of caring about someone. But here, I've seen something different. Pure love. Divine love."
Sister Agnes made a soft sound of understanding, and I pressed my advantage.
"My past showed me that love can be poisoned, corrupted. But the love I've witnessed here—the way you care for broken people without expecting anything in return, the way Father Mikael tends to our wounds..."
The way he looks at me like I'm something precious instead of something to be used.
"I want to be part of that. I want to help other people find what I've found—a sanctuary that can't be taken away."
The words tasted like ash in my mouth, but both of them were nodding with the kind of approval that meant my performance was working.
These people actually believe their own mythology.
It would be endearing if it weren't so useful.
"Have you considered what religious life truly means?" Father Atticus asked gently. "The vows of poverty, chastity, obedience? The surrender of your own will to God's?"
Surrender my will? That's rich.
I've spent my entire life fighting for the right to have a will at all.
"I understand it's a sacrifice," I said aloud, making my voice small and earnest. "But after what I've been through, the idea of belonging to something greater than myself... it feels like freedom, not imprisonment."
Sister Agnes's eyes grew bright with unshed tears. "Oh, my dear child. What you're describing sounds like a genuine calling. The way grace can transform our deepest wounds into our greatest ministry..."
"But I don't know if I'm worthy," I interrupted, hitting exactly the right note of vulnerable self-doubt. "I don't know if someone with my past can truly serve Him. I'm so far from perfect, so broken..."
So manipulative, so calculating, so willing to exploit your kindness for my own survival.
"God doesn't call the qualified, child," Father Atticus said firmly. "He qualifies the called. Some of our most effective ministers have been those who've walked through the darkness and found the light."
"Then you think... you think I might truly have a vocation?"
"I think you have the heart of a servant," he replied, studying my face with those sharp eyes that seemed to see too much. "If you're serious about pursuing this path, I'd like to arrange for you to receive proper spiritual direction."
My pulse quickened, but I kept my expression carefully composed. "Who would provide that guidance?"
"Father Mikael has experience with spiritual formation," Father Atticus said, and I had to suppress my triumphant smile. "He's young but exceptionally gifted at discerning genuine callings. He also handles some of our more... specialized ministries. Exorcism, for instance."
Exorcism. Of course he does. How perfectly ironic.
"Would you be comfortable helping him?" Sister Agnes asked gently.
I arranged my features into grateful relief while my mind raced with possibilities. "Father Mikael has been so kind to me already. I would be honored."
And you have no idea how much I'm counting on that kindness.
An hour later, I knocked on Mikael's study door, my heart hammering with anticipation rather than nerves. When his voice called for me to enter, I stepped inside and found him arranging books on his desk—preparation for our first formal lesson.
"Wren." His smile was warm, genuine, and for a dangerous moment I almost felt guilty about what I was planning. "Father Atticus told me about your conversation. I have to say, I'm not entirely surprised."
That caught me off guard. "You're not?"
He gestured for me to take the chair across from his desk, studying me with those beautiful brown eyes.
"You've been asking very thoughtful questions during our informal talks. And there's something about the way you've been helping Sister Agnes, the care you show the other women... it suggests someone with a genuine heart for service."
Genuine heart for service, my ass.
"Though I have to admit," he continued, and there was something almost teasing in his tone, "your theological knowledge seems... spotty. For someone who claims to have found faith through prayers."
My chest tightened. He was more observant than I'd given him credit for.
"I told you, I never really learned to pray properly," I said carefully. "My religious education was... limited."
"Mmm." He leaned back in his chair, still watching me with that penetrating gaze. "You stumble over basic prayers but discuss complex theological concepts with surprising sophistication. It's an interesting contradiction."
Shit. Think, Rowan. Think!
"I read a lot," I said, forcing uncertainty into my voice. "When I was... hiding from him, books were my escape. I devoured everything I could find, including religious texts. But reading about faith and actually living it are different things."
"Indeed they are." His expression softened slightly, but I could see the wheels turning behind those warm eyes. "Well, that's what spiritual direction is for. Speaking of which," he continued, pulling out a leather-bound notebook, "let's begin with prayer. It's the foundation of everything else we'll explore together."
He settled back in his chair, and I felt my carefully constructed mask beginning to slip.
"Just speak to God about whatever is on your heart," he said gently. "There's no wrong way to do this."
The request caught me completely off guard. For a moment, panic rose in my throat, because I didn't know how to pray. I'd never spoken to any god except to curse them.
The coven had power, magic, ancient rituals—but no prayers, no supplication, no surrender to anything greater than ourselves.
The silence stretched between us, growing heavier with each passing second. For the first time since arriving at the cathedral, I felt genuinely exposed.
"I don't know how..." I whispered, and it was the first completely honest thing I'd said to him.
Something shifted in Mikael's expression—surprise giving way to something infinitely gentler. He leaned forward slightly, his voice becoming even softer than usual.
"That's alright. There's no shame in not knowing. Prayer isn't about eloquence or getting the words right. It's about speaking truthfully from your heart."
He paused, studying my face with those warm brown eyes.
"I can guide you through something simple." I nodded, not trusting my voice. "Close your eyes if it helps. Just speak to God as you would speak to someone who loves you completely. Start with gratitude—what are you thankful for?"
I closed my eyes and tried to find words that wouldn't reveal too much while still sounding genuine.
When I finally spoke, my voice was barely above a whisper.
"I'm... grateful for shelter when I expected to die in the cold. For safety when I thought I'd never feel safe again. For kindness from people who had no reason to care about someone like me."
The words felt foreign on my tongue, but something about the quiet intimacy of the moment—his patience, his genuine care—created an unexpected vulnerability.
"I'm grateful for second chances I don't deserve. For people who see something worth protecting when I can't see it myself."
When I opened my eyes, Mikael was watching me with an expression I couldn't quite read. There was something deeper than professional interest, warmer than spiritual guidance.
The careful distance between us seemed to collapse entirely, and I became hyperaware of everything—his proximity, the way his breath had quickened slightly, the intensity of his gaze.
"Beautiful," he said quietly, and I knew he meant it.
The sincerity in his voice did something dangerous to my chest, made me want things I had no business wanting. The moment stretched until he seemed to catch himself, clearing his throat and reaching for another book with hands that weren't quite steady.
"We should continue with the reading," he said, but his voice carried a rougher edge than before.
As the lesson proceeded, I realized I'd succeeded beyond my expectations.
I'd gotten closer to him, established regular access, positioned myself perfectly to gather intelligence and ensure my protection.
But I'd also discovered something I hadn't anticipated: the growing certainty that my greatest danger might not be exposure as a witch, but the way my carefully guarded heart responded when Mikael looked at me.
Well, shit. Didn't see that coming.
Swipe up to continue
During the time of my theological education for the past few weeks, I'd settled into a routine that served my original purposes just perfectly.
My lessons with Mikael had expanded far beyond basic doctrine, and I found myself with access to texts that offered tantalizing hints about the Order's true mission.
References to "purification" and "divine judgment" scattered throughout otherwise mundane theological treatises. Mentions of Saint Michael's sword being more than metaphorical.
I was also genuinely quick to learn—a natural intelligence I'd never been allowed to display in the coven, where asking too many questions earned you a backhand and demanding silence.
All while appearing to be nothing more than a helpful novice eager to serve.
But it was our work together that had truly brought Mikael and me closer.
The long evenings in his study, bent over ancient texts and correspondence, had created an intimacy that went far beyond spiritual direction. We'd developed an easy rhythm, a comfortable familiarity that made my chest warm in ways I hadn't expected.
Dangerous territory, Rowan. But useful.
Tonight was different, though. Tonight, I had a specific goal.
"So when I take my preliminary vows," I said, settling into the chair across from his desk with calculated casualness, "what exactly will my duties be? I want to make sure I'm prepared."
Mikael looked up from the stack of reports he'd been reviewing, his hair slightly disheveled from running his hands through it. The sight sent an unexpected flutter through my stomach.
Focus. This is about survival, not attraction.
"Well," he said, setting down his pen and giving me his full attention, "you'll assist Sister Agnes with the shelter operations, continue your theological studies, and help with various parish functions. You'll also accompany me on some of my... specialized assignments."
"The exorcism work?" I raised an eyebrow, letting skepticism color my tone. "I still find it hard to believe that's a real thing in the twenty-first century."
His lips quirked upward in that almost-smile that made my pulse quicken. "Your skepticism is noted, Sister-to-be. But you'll see for yourself soon enough."
"Will I really be helpful, though?" I leaned forward slightly, ostensibly earnest but very aware of how the movement made his gaze flicker briefly to my neckline. "I mean, what if I freeze up? What if I'm more hindrance than help?"
"You won't be." His voice was warm, confident. "You're braver than you know, Wren. And more intuitive than most people I've worked with."
There it is—that protective, admiring tone that makes him so easy to manipulate.
I stood and moved around his desk, ostensibly to look at one of the theological texts spread across its surface. But really, I wanted to be closer, wanted to see how he'd react to my proximity.
"This passage here," I said, leaning over his shoulder to point at a random line of Latin. "What does it mean exactly?"
I was close enough to catch his scent—soap and something uniquely masculine that made my skin feel too tight. Close enough to feel the warmth radiating from his body, to see the way his breathing had quickened slightly.
"It's... it's discussing the nature of temptation," he said, his voice rougher than usual. "How even the most faithful can be tested."
"Temptation," I repeated thoughtfully, letting the word roll off my tongue as I straightened but didn't move away. "Do you ever feel tempted, Mikael?"
The use of his given name instead of his title was deliberate, intimate.
I saw the way his pupils dilated, how his hands gripped the edge of his desk. "Everyone faces temptation, Wren. It's part of being human."
"But you handle it so well," I said, turning to face him fully. We were close enough that I could see the flecks of gold in his brown eyes, close enough that he'd have to crane his neck to look up at me. "You're so disciplined, so... controlled. I admire that about you."
A flush crept up his neck, and I felt a thrill of victory. This powerful, dangerous man—a witch hunter who could destroy me if he knew the truth—was blushing because of a few carefully chosen words.
God, I love making him react like this.
"I'm not as controlled as you think," he said quietly, and there was something raw in his voice that made my chest tighten.
"No?" I reached past him for another book, deliberately letting my breast brush against his shoulder. "You always seem so... steady. So sure of yourself and your faith."
His breath caught audibly at the contact. "Wren..."
"Yes?" I let my voice drop to barely above a whisper, leaning down so my lips were close to his ear. "What is it?"
For a moment, I thought I'd pushed too far. His whole body had gone rigid, and I could feel the tension radiating from him like heat. Then his hand came up to rest on my wrist, not pushing me away but not pulling me closer either.
"I know what you're doing," he said, his voice strained.
"Do you?" I let my fingers trail along the edge of his desk, close enough to his other hand that our skin almost touched.
The air between us crackled with tension. His eyes went dark, fixed on my face with an intensity that made my pulse race. I could see the war being fought behind those warm brown eyes—duty battling desire, faith wrestling with very human need.
Just a little more pressure, and he'll break.
"Wren, I—"
"And what exactly is happening here?"
Brother Dominic's voice cut through the charged atmosphere like a blade. We sprang apart, guilt written across both our faces despite the fact that we hadn't actually done anything improper.
He stood in the doorway, his pale eyes fixed on me with undisguised suspicion and distaste. He was massive, broad-shouldered, with the kind of heavy features that looked carved from stone. Everything about him screamed zealot.
"Brother Dominic," Mikael said, his voice carefully controlled as he stood. "Wren was just asking about her future duties after she takes her preliminary vows."
"Her duties." Dominic stepped into the room, his gaze never leaving my face. "And those duties require such... intimate consultation?"
I felt my cheeks flush, but I kept my expression innocent. "I was just looking at the texts Father Mikael was explaining. I wanted to understand—"
"Oh, I'm sure you want to understand many things," Dominic interrupted, his voice dripping with disdain. "Tell me, Wren, what exactly do you hope to gain from your... spiritual journey?"
The way he said my fake name made it sound like an accusation. My skin crawled under his scrutiny, but I forced myself to remain calm.
"I hope to serve God and help other people who've suffered as I have," I replied evenly. "The same as any woman called to religious life."
"Hmm." He moved closer, studying me like I was something distasteful he'd found on his shoe. "And you believe the best way to serve God is by... distracting His priests from their sacred duties?"
"Brother Dominic," Mikael's voice carried a warning. "That's enough."
Dominic turned to face him, and I saw genuine concern beneath his obvious dislike of me. "The path you're walking leads only to destruction—for both of you."
"I don't know what you think is happening…" I began, but he cut me off.
"I think you know exactly what's happening. And what the consequences will be if you continue down this path. Mikael has given his life to God. His vows aren't just promises—they're sacred oaths. Break them, and you destroy not just his career, but his very soul."
The words hit their mark, and I had to suppress a smile of satisfaction. Because Dominic, in his zealous concern for his friend, had just given me the perfect weapon.
With that, he turned and stalked out of the room, leaving Mikael and me alone with the weight of his accusations hanging between us. The silence stretched uncomfortably until he cleared his throat.
"I should... We should probably end tonight's session here," he said, not meeting my eyes. "It's getting late, and Sister Agnes will be wondering where you are."
"Of course," I replied, but I didn't move toward the door. Instead, I stepped closer, close enough to see the conflict warring in his expression. "Father Mikael, what he said…"
"He's right." The words came out harsh, final. "This... whatever this is has to stop. My vows have to come first."
I let my face fall, let disappointment and hurt cloud my features. "I understand. I never meant to make things difficult for you."
"I know you didn't." His voice gentled, and I saw the exact moment his resolve began to crack. "You're not doing anything wrong, Wren. It's me. I'm the one who's supposed to be stronger than this."
"You are strong," I whispered, reaching out to touch his arm lightly. "The strongest man I've ever known. If there's... if there's something between us, maybe it's not weakness. Maybe it's something more."
For a moment, I thought he might close the distance between us right there in his study. His eyes darkened, his breathing quickened, and I could practically feel the need radiating from him.
Then he stepped back, putting the desk between us like a barrier. "No. Dominic is right—this is dangerous. For both of us."
I nodded, letting tears gather in my eyes. "I'm sorry. I never meant to be a burden to you."
"You're not a burden. You're... " he said quickly. "God help me, you're the most incredible woman I've ever met. But that's exactly why this has to stop."
As he left me alone in his study, Dominic's words echoed in my mind. The threat of Mikael's destruction, the consequences of broken vows, the power I now held over his future… Could be the way.
After all, what's love without a little blackmail?
Swipe up to continue
"You seem tense, dear," Sister Agnes observed as I aggressively folded linens in the supply closet. "Are you nervous about taking your vows soon?"
The constant presence of Brother Dominic. The man had apparently appointed himself my personal watchdog, appearing at the most inconvenient moments with that suspicious gleam in his pale eyes.
All while Mikael won’t look me in the eye the way he used to before.
It was exhausting. And infuriating.
I'm tense because I'm surrounded by witch hunters, hunted by my older sisters, being stalked by a zealot, and failing spectacularly at seducing the one man who could protect me.
But sure, let's call it pre-vow jitters.
"Just eager to begin my real service," I replied, forcing my voice into something appropriately humble.
"That's beautiful, child. Your devotion is truly inspiring."
If only you knew what I was actually devoted to. Or to who. Yeah, nevermind.
I was helping Sister Agnes prepare for a supply run to the local market when Mikael appeared in the kitchen doorway.
"Sister Agnes," he said, his voice carefully professional. "I need to pick up some books from the theological college across town. Would it be possible for Wren to accompany me? It would be good for her to see more of the academic side of religious life."
Sister Agnes beamed with approval. "Of course, Father Mikael. What a wonderful opportunity for her."
Twenty minutes later, I found myself sliding into the passenger seat of Mikael's modest sedan, hyperaware of the confined space and his proximity.
In the small interior, his frame seemed even larger—broad shoulders taking up more than his fair share of space, the quiet strength in his build making me acutely aware of how much smaller than him I was.
How much closer we were.
I tried not to stare at his hands on the steering wheel, or the way his black shirt pulled across his chest when he reached for his seatbelt. His dark hair was trimmed so precisely at the nape of his neck that I had the completely inappropriate urge to touch it, to see if it was as soft as it looked.
Even that damned white collar at his throat—the universal symbol for off-limits, do not touch, sworn to celibacy—only made it worse.
"Thank you for coming," he said as he started the engine. "I know things have been... awkward between us lately."
"It's alright, I understand."
He glanced at me, something unreadable flickering in his expression. "Do you?"
Because Dominic has been filling your head with warnings about the dangerous woman who's trying to corrupt you.
"You have responsibilities, obligations," I said simply. "And I never should have made things complicated for you."
"You didn't make anything complicated," Mikael said quietly. "The complication was already there."
I turned to study his profile, noting the tight line of his jaw, the white-knuckled grip on the steering wheel. "What do you mean?"
"I mean..." He was quiet for so long I thought he wouldn't answer. "I mean that from the moment you walked into my life, everything became more difficult."
Well, progress is it.
"I'm sorry," I whispered, letting vulnerability creep into my voice.
He shook his head, as if trying to clear it, and we went silent for the rest of the ride.
As we pulled into the parking lot of the theological college, I realized that I'd gotten exactly what I wanted—proof that his desire for me was stronger than his resolve.
When we walked through the street, I couldn't appreciate the scenery.
My eyes constantly scanned the crowds, my body tense with the expectation of seeing a familiar face. Every dark-haired woman made my heart race. Every glimpse of movement in my peripheral vision had me calculating escape routes.
"You seem on edge," Mikael observed gently as we browsed the theology section. "Is being in the city difficult for you?"
"Old habits," I said, forcing a smile that felt more like a grimace. "When you've spent months looking over your shoulder, it's hard to stop. Every face in a crowd could be the wrong one, you know?"
I let my vulnerability show just enough to make him want to protect me, then deliberately brightened.
"But I feel safe with you. Safer than I've felt anywhere."
The way his chest expanded slightly at my words told me the compliment had hit its mark. Good. Building his protective instincts was crucial for what came next.
I actually took much less time than expected to select several books on medieval theology and early church history before getting in the car, heading back to the cathedral.
"Can I ask you something personal?" I said, timing the question perfectly as he settled in the driver seat. "I hope it's not inappropriate, but I've been wondering about something."
Mikael shifted uncomfortably starting the engine, already wary. "What is it?"
"Do you ever wonder what you gave up when you took your vows?" I leaned in slightly, lowering my voice. "I mean… You're young, attractive, intelligent. You could have had any life you wanted. A wife, children, a family of your own. Didn't you ever want those things?"
"My calling came early," he said carefully, his fingers tightening around the steering wheel. "I've never really thought about alternative paths."
But I caught the slight hesitation, the way his eyes flickered to mine before returning to the road. There was something there—doubt, maybe, or regret.
I pressed my advantage with a cat-like smile. "Never? Not even before you entered the seminary? No girlfriend in high school who broke your heart when you chose God over her?"
The flush that crept up his neck told me everything I needed to know. "There was never... I mean, I was focused on my studies fully. My path was clear from an early age."
"So you've never...?" I let the question hang in the air, watching as understanding dawned in his expression. His silence was answer enough.
A virgin priest.
How perfectly, beautifully convenient.
"That's actually incredible," I continued, my voice carrying admiration. "In a world where everyone gives themselves away so carelessly, you've preserved something sacred, something pure."
I could see him struggling between embarrassment and pride, unsure how to respond to such directness. "I... yes. It's part of my commitment to serve God completely."
I reached across the gearbox, letting my fingers brush his in a gesture that could be interpreted as comfort. "I just can't imagine being so strong. So disciplined."
The word 'disciplined' seemed to affect him even more than 'pure' had.
I could practically see the effect I was having—his breathing had quickened, and he was staring for a few seconds at my hand on his with an intensity that had nothing to do with spiritual contemplation.
I traced my thumb across his knuckles in a gesture that was definitely not comforting.
"Though I suppose it's easier to sacrifice something you've never experienced. You don't know what you're missing."
The look he gave me was sharp, almost alarmed, as if he'd just realized how dangerous this conversation had become.
"Wren..." His voice carried a warning, but it was weak, uncertain.
"I'm just saying I admire your strength," I said innocently. "Not many men could resist temptation the way you do."
He said nothing as he returned his gaze back to the road again, but didn’t pull away his hand under mine.
For the rest of the ride to the cathedral, I continued my careful assault on his defenses. I sat closer than necessary, letting our arms brush. I laughed at his nervous attempts at humor, each sound warm and appreciative.
When we stopped at the parking lot, I placed my hand on his arm to get his attention, letting the touch linger far longer than necessary.
"Thank you for today," I said, stopping him from stepping out of the car "For making me feel safe. For talking to me like I'm… worth knowing. Worth caring about."
"You are worth knowing, Wren." His voice was rougher than it should be, strained with something he couldn't acknowledge. "More than worth it."
The intensity in his eyes when he said it sent a genuine shiver through me—one I quickly suppressed.
This was about survival, about gaining his protection. The fact that my body responded to his obvious desire was simply a biological reaction I could use to my advantage.
"I know we can't," I whispered, moving close enough that my breath warmed his skin. "I know you belong to God. But sometimes I wonder... what it would be like to belong to someone like you."
His eyes dropped to my lips, and I could see the exact moment his resolve began to crack. "I can't," he said, but he was leaning closer too, drawn by the same magnetic pull. "My vows, my calling..."
For a heartbeat, I thought he was going to close the distance. I could feel his breath against my skin, could see the war being fought behind his eyes.
Then Mikael jerked back as if burned, his face flushing with guilt and desire in equal measure. "I'm sorry," he said quickly, throwing the car into gear. "I'm so sorry, I shouldn't have—"
"Don't apologize," I said, settling back in my seat with my heart still racing from the adrenaline. "Please don't apologize for feeling something real."
I could see duty battling desire in his expression, faith wrestling with very human need.
"We should go inside," he said, his voice strained.
As we entered the cathedral, I allowed myself a small, satisfied smile. I'd planted the seeds expertly. Now all I had to do was wait for them to take root, slowly driving him mad with wanting something he could never allow himself to have.
The growing attraction I felt was simply another tool in my arsenal of survival.
Nothing more.
Swipe up to continue